1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

The Daily Dose

Get the last 24hrs of new topics delivered to your inbox.

Click Here to Subscribe

Stupid Question ? Why Do Some Get PTSD, And Others Not?

Discussion in 'General' started by Terry, Jan 11, 2007.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Terry

    Terry Well-Known Member

    I know this may sound stupid and the answer is prolly obvious but here goes.
    Why is it that I have gotten PTSD from some incidents and there were other cops or EMTs there but some of them don't seem to be effected by them as I am. I'm sure it's got to bother them but they don't show it or they haven't gone to psyc. as much as I have. Rumors always get out in my business. I guess what I am wondering is, is there a pysical difference not just mental ?
  2. Register to participate in live chat, PTSD discussion and more.
  3. Andre

    Andre Active Member

    I do not know how related this is but reading your question about physical differences reminded me of something I read and a thought I had because it might also be some complicated biochemical process. I remember reading somewhere a few years ago that the effects of anesthesia can take a decade and more to fully recede, I do not know whether this is really true but it has been in the back of my mind since reading that. During my stay in the hospital I know that I was given anesthesia repeatedly. There are probably giant tomes of scientific journals devoted to these sorts of details about the effects of emergency treatment, but I am not familiar with anything like that-I only know introductory biology myself. I suspect that my lengthy exposure might have played some part in making me more susceptible to having PTSD but I can not say I know of anything that supports this conjecture. Just as easily I could see it having to do with being in the middle of puberty at the time, that is another complex thing. To give some response to your question, maybe taking certain prescription drugs, other drugs, over the counter drugs, or some environmental toxins (lead, mercury, etc.) could have had some effect, but I do not know anything proven myself or if you had any exposure like that.
  4. cookie

    cookie I'm a VIP

    physical difference in your brain. i'm told you can see it on mri, chemical diff. too
  5. NakedAnxiety

    NakedAnxiety Member

    I think the easy answer to that is that we are all different human beings with different perspectives of life. Some people look at a dead cat in the middle of the road and wonder why the city hasn't cleaned it up and some tear up a little.
  6. permban0077

    permban0077 Policy Enforcement Banned

    Terry, if we knew the whole cause and effect more clearly... Honestly, no one has a clue. Theories are all over but full of holes. This one my dear has no defenitive answer. I have an identical twin with a very simuliar background, why did that flake who rolls over not get it? I did? So I poo poo on genetics. Weak willed or mined nope. She was the flake. But at the same time people who lack backbone and roll over get it too. We are just lucky until they find out why.
  7. Scott_Fraser

    Scott_Fraser Well-Known Member

    I don't know that one Terry, I wish I knew the answer. But why is it the Coppers and Firefighters get counselling straight away, but us poor buggers in the Armed forces don't.
  8. nov_silence

    nov_silence Well-Known Member

    One perspective is that it's a culmination of factors: patterns of behavior experienced from our family (eg how things were dealt with), the age of first trauma or traumas, number, severity, and duration of traumas, coping mechanisms/skills, ... and then how all of this impacts our wiring = depleting the chemical resources in our brain (no, I am not jumping up and down about med management... esp since the med field really can't account for how medications work, I mean, really work. And yes, I am on medication).

    I have felt alot of guilt the past about how much my parents' treatment of me has impacted me in comparison to my cousins who grew up in Trinidad. However, that was a really unfair and peripheral view. The things I experienced many of them didn't. Totally different variables involved/interacting/banging the hell out of each other. And trying to firmly incorporate this in my process helps to "normalize" the presentation of symptoms.
    anthony likes this.
  9. wildcritter44

    wildcritter44 Active Member


    on page 3 here on PTSD chat is a threat--Hope this helps --PTSD soldiers & their families .

    It is long a couple of pages, research was done for a psychology class and a DR was the instructor. She stated it was a well done paper...

    see if anything there sheds any light on your question....

    D (wildcritter)
  10. ranger2_75

    ranger2_75 Active Member

    If I understood corectly when I was researching the paper that wildcritter mentioned, I found that it is not a physical thing that is responsable as the change people are mentioning has taken place in all cases of PTSD. Yes it can be seen on an MRI but that is as a resault of this change having already taken place, combined with the lack of timely treatment. I believe that the reason some get it, and others don't, is due to the thought proceses and beliefs of the individuals them selves. Not a pre-existing psychological or physical issue that a traumatic event has exacerbated.
  11. bob

    bob Member

    Speaking for myself, it's part nature and part nurture. I am the kind of person that is affected by trauma. That is to say that if I find a dead animal I find it disturbing and can be haunted by the sight for days after. Also when my traumas occurred I didn't have any supportive network in place to be able to deal effectively with them. That is to say that I had to cope with trauma on my own. I find that both of these factors have had a profound effect on my ability to cope with trauma.
  12. catatonicky

    catatonicky Member

    i think its a complex issue; some of these other people MAY get PTSD later, for example, it dosnt always show up immediately. Also we all have different biochemistry; eg some research suggests that those who have glucose intolerance, migraines, and/or thyroid problems are less able to ride through trauma unscathed. There may even be a genetic link with stress sensitivity, depression, etc. But in any case, physical differences ARE also mental ones, the two are inseparable. The fact that you have been to psychs and they havent dosnt mean they arent just as affected. In fact, you have a better chance of getting over it by recognising it. Denial is the strongest predictor, in my personal experience. Dont forget that public personas are merely a mask, and that to admit to being traumatised dosnt make you weaker but actually more adaptable and humane, and ultimately stronger, than those who repress themselves to keep up thier public face.
  13. vcc123

    vcc123 Active Member

    Terry... Amen. I feel the same way.
Similar Threads - Stupid Question PTSD
  1. JASON1976
  2. Never_falter
  3. anonymous
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
Show Sidebar