General Supporter in year three of push-pull (long, sorry!)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hello,

First, I have to say how grateful I am to have found this forum. I've been in an on again/off again relationship with a C-PTSD sufferer for almost 3 years. Well, actually we dated 25 years ago. It was very intense. He felt like the love of my life. At that time, he hadn't come to terms with his violent childhood (dad was a spouse abuser, mother used him as a faux-spouse practically from birth) and so one day he just broke up with me. It broke my heart but, long story shorter, two years later I was married to someone else.

Fast-forward to three years ago, my marriage ended and I looked him up and found him. Got in touch and we immediately reconnected. Very intense and passionate and, "Oh my God, we get another chance!" This time, he had a notion of his relationship patterns (at 48 he'd never been married, no kids, and all relationships had ended with him essentially bolting) and seemed very willing to learn to break that pattern.

So... we were together for 6 lovely months before he left. We stayed in touch, and I did research. I read about commitmentphobia which led me to read about mother-enmeshment which led me to read about children of domestic violence which, ultimately, led me to C-PTSD and to this forum. I shared ALL the information with him and he was utterly grateful. It was like a revelation to NAME the things he'd been dealing with for so long.

Unfortunately, it didn't help him stick to our relationship, and now we've gone through the romantic-breakup-friends-romantic-breakup-friends cycle about 5 times over the last three years. My friends and family are THOROUGHLY at their wit's end, and can't believe I put up with this, so I don't talk to them about it anymore. This last time we got back together (as always, at HIS suggestion) was just before Christmas. We talked about ways to make it different and easier. I thought it would be different. But in the last couple of weeks he's isolated again, and now wants to "just be friends." I'm a writer, so I write. I wrote this (below) and plan to give it to him. I'd be grateful for any opinions on how this might go over from sufferers or supporters with experience. I love this guy so much. Really. :( I know you can all understand.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear X,
First, you need to know I can take care of myself. I don't need you to "protect" me from your issues or your ways of dealing with emotions or relationships. I can manage myself. If there's any part of you that feels pressure to get away from me so as not to "burden" me with this, well, forget it. I knew going in that this might happen, and I can handle it. It's only a small piece of the puzzle for me, and it's worth it—you are a package deal that includes your wonderfulness AND your imperfections—just as I am an imperfect package. We all are. I see beauty and value in all of your parts, and I'm tougher than I seem sometimes. Sure, I might feel hurt or sad when you isolate. I might text or say something that seems insensitive because of that hurt, but I get over it. Ups and downs and disagreements are a fully normal part of all human relationships. They’re not fun, but they’re also not the end of the world.

I'm fine with letting you have space to deal with your anxiety on your own. I acknowledge that this is a hard journey for you, maybe even one that feels impossible sometimes. My feeling is that you've hit this same wall with me so many times, that maybe if you rode it out this time, and sat with the discomfort and went THROUGH it, allowed the tide of anxiety to pull back out—as it surely will—that maybe you'd end up in a new and different place on the other side. Patti Henry (and the others) suggest similarly.

There are two ways to end the cycle—ride it out and see if your feelings change back to the romantic (as they have every other time) once the anxiety diminishes, or break up. Every other time we've broken up we've found our way back to a romantic relationship because YOU'VE suggested it, which, I have to assume, means that each time you actually wanted to restart that kind of relationship with me.

I can't make you stay with me. I can only remind you that you've cycled through this so many times and I’m still here. I haven’t abandoned you or been broken by the pattern. I’ve survived, and so have you, and we’ve come a long way. We’re in this together, as I see it, so why not try something new this time? Let’s hit pause instead of game over. Let’s both breathe through the anxiety this causes and see if there's a different kind of light after the pain, at the end of the tunnel than any light we’ve seen before. I want to be your partner in the good and the bad. I aim to earn your trust so that, eventually, you’ll let me share your burdens and you’ll have the bandwidth to share mine. But that is not NOW. We’re working towards that.

Have you heard of the C-PTSD “stress cup” theory? We all have a stress cup that good and bad stressors and regular daily life stresses go into. C-PTSD is already taking up a lot of room in your cup, so you have less space for the other stressors, both negative (your work, your house, your recent sickness) AND the positive (ME! Haha). So your cup is bursting over right now, and you need room to let it empty a bit. So take the room.

You are stronger than you think you are. I have faith in your strength. You can do this. It's hard and it hurts and it’s terrifying. I really DO understand that. But you are worthy and wonderful, and you deserve love. In your darker moments, you may think you don't, but you do. I do think it would be a little easier if you had a good therapist, but that’s for you to decide about. Meanwhile, I am still ME—someone who loves you and wants you to feel safe; someone who shares your values and has common interests. We have a lot of fun together; we have an excellent base of friendship. The stress and anxiety are coloring everything you look at right now. But they won't last forever. I don't know if having my opinions and my encouragement to work through this period is helpful, or if you'll see it as me manipulating you or angling for what I want. It's not the latter. I don’t want to be with you if you have no interest in being with me. I'm willing to let you go if that's what you REALLY want.

But there are other options. This time, when we got back together, you suggested we talk about expectations and triggers and we never had that talk. Nor did we try the writing thing, where you write what you want in a shared journal as a way of helping advocate for yourself through your fear of upsetting me. If we did that, I could write back, as that’s easier for me, and in that way, we might communicate the important things more easily. We haven’t tried those new strategies yet; we just walked the same road we always have, and there are other paths we can try.

I don't think I can go back to being friends this time. There's too much water under the bridge. I could NOT watch you with some other woman. I just couldn't. I can't turn my feelings off, and I'd end up holding a torch for you and not meeting another man. The very day you suggested we get back together this time around; I was going to tell you that I couldn't do the platonic/ unrequited thing anymore. I think I'm going to need to jump off the carousel permanently if that's your decision.

Anyway, I guess that's all I can say. If you want to talk, let me know. I'm here for you. But if you want to take some days to consider and breathe and tackle the stress on your own and get perspective, do that, ok? I’ll be here when and if you come back. I won’t wait forever without communication, but I’m happy to put this on ice for a while if that’ll help.

Love (really),
Me xo
 
Hi sufferer here. I've been on the same carousel with my ex for 23 years you know the friends/unrequited love thing. Thank you for sharing your perspective with us because until I read this I never realised how difficult it is for my ex to hang with me after all I've put him (and myself) through all this time. I too veer between clinging and running away. At the root of it all is sheer bloody terror. Terror of intimacy and terror of abandonment. Can't find the middle ground that me and my bloke would both be happy with. No balance just extreme ends of the same spectrum. Need to find compromise as does your fella does too. Have to learn how to do that first before I can try to put it into practice though. Like me he grew up with no compromise whatsoever. Didn't have it modelled for him anymore than I did. I'm an incest survivor BTW. Sexual battery rather than physical but the effects of it are pretty much the same. Violence is violence whichever form it comes in. Hard enough to deal with as an adult but going through it as a kid? That's a headf*ck on a whole different level. Again thanks for sharing this with us. It's certainly given me a lot to ponder. God bless you and your bloke wants to count his blessings he's got someone as patient loving and understanding as you in his corner hope you guys can work it out xx
 
From a sufferers perspective. That would be a lovely letter to receive IF I wasn't symptomatic at the time. Symptomatic? It would be too over stimulating and have the opposite effect that you intend for it to have. Keep it short, straight and to the point. Facts, not feelings since you point out his stress cup is full.

Cut out, if he isn't thinking that, you don't want to plant the idea in his mind.
If there's any part of you that feels pressure to get away from me so as not to "burden" me with this, well,

Same point just fewer words. Reading can be difficult when symptomatic, I think what you said is really sweet, but I am running very little sleep and found it hard to follow.
you are a package deal that includes your wonderfulness AND your imperfections—just as I am an imperfect package. We all are. I see beauty and value in all of your parts, and I'm tougher than I seem sometimes. Sure, I might feel hurt or sad when you isolate. I might text or say something that seems insensitive because of that hurt, but I get over it. Ups and downs and disagreements are a fully normal part of all human relationships. They’re not fun, but they’re also not the end of the world.

Keep, but cut out the rest of the paragraph and the next two paragraphs.
I'm fine with letting you have space to deal with your anxiety on your own. I acknowledge that this is a hard journey for you, maybe even one that feels impossible sometimes.

Absolutely a keeper. cut the following paragraph though.
Have you heard of the C-PTSD “ stress cup” theory? We all have a stress cup that good and bad stressors and regular daily life stresses go into. C-PTSD is already taking up a lot of room in your cup, so you have less space for the other stressors, both negative (your work, your house, your recent sickness) AND the positive (ME! Haha). So your cup is bursting over right now, and you need room to let it empty a bit. So take the room.

Tuck this part away for later when his stress cup isn't full. Great ideas, but he is unlikely to be in a place where he could see the value of it..
But there are other options. This time, when we got back together, you suggested we talk about expectations and triggers and we never had that talk. Nor did we try the writing thing, where you write what you want in a shared journal as a way of helping advocate for yourself through your fear of upsetting me. If we did that, I could write back, as that’s easier for me, and in that way, we might communicate the important things more easily. We haven’t tried those new strategies yet; we just walked the same road we always have, and there are other paths we can try.

Cut the next paragraph for now, bring it up if you do get back together.

keep
Anyway, I guess that's all I can say. If you want to talk, let me know. I'm here for you. But if you want to take some days to consider and breathe and tackle the stress on your own and get perspective, do that, ok? I’ll be here when and if you come back. I won’t wait forever without communication, but I’m happy to put this on ice for a while if that’ll help.

Hope this helps. Isolation is the result of over stimulation, even if it is good stress, guilt is often what keeps us from coming back so the more the other person acts like it is no big deal and doesn't take it personally, the easier it is to come back.

I rarely isolate from my husband now, but to keep it that way I have to maintain large quantities of me time, that means spending less time together on a regular basis. Hope that helps. And this is really coming from a very sleep deprived person, so do keep in mind that is where I am coming from in terms of how I would react to such a letter and what I could handle at the moment and what I couldn't personally as I can't speak for him.
 
Thank you so very much for replying. Honestly, it made me cry.
At the root of it all is sheer bloody terror. Terror of intimacy and terror of abandonment. Can't find the middle ground that me and my bloke would both be happy with. No balance just extreme ends of the same spectrum. Need to find compromise as does your fella does too. Have to learn how to do that first before I can try to put it into practice though. Like me he grew up with no compromise whatsoever. Didn't have it modelled for him anymore than I did.
You're absolutely right. On a theoretical level, I understand this. But in my non-sufferer head, I still think, "Can't he just let me love him?" It's so hard to *really* get his perspective, which is why I'm so grateful for people like you, who are willing to share insights into the sufferer's thought/instinct pattern.

Are you and your guy still on the carousel? I love this dude so much that the notion of never seeing him again kills me, but I know that, ultimately, I *do* want another relationship. If it's never going to be with him, I have to go cold-turkey or I'll never be open to giving my heart to someone else. These three years...the break-ups have been incredibly painful. Honestly, each one was more painful than my divorce (after 16 years and 3 kids with my ex-husband). And I just don't think I can be this guy's buddy without wanting more. It's weird--after every break up (as devastating as they each were) I had the instinct we'd get back together. And each time we did. But when does it stop?
 
It sounds like you've put a lot of effort and thinking into this. Boundaries are essential in PTSD relationships, for both supporters and sufferers.

My main suggestion is to make sure that you're certain of your limits before sending him this. If you cannot be friends with him platonically, then you have to mean what you say. Boundaries are worthless if you cannot enforce them.

Sometimes when our sufferers aren't healthy enough for relationships it is up to us to do what is best for our own mental health and well being.

Is he getting any kind of treatment?
 
Hope this helps. Isolation is the result of over stimulation, even if it is good stress, guilt is often what keeps us from coming back so the more the other person acts like it is no big deal and doesn't take it personally, the easier it is to come back.

I rarely isolate from my husband now, but to keep it that way I have to maintain large quantities of me time, that means spending less time together on a regular basis. Hope that helps. And this is really coming from a very sleep deprived person, so do keep in mind that is where I am coming from in terms of how I would react to such a letter and what I could handle at the moment and what I couldn't personally as I can't speak for him.

OMG. I am SO grateful for your edits! You have no idea. THANK YOU. And as I read what you were cutting and keeping it dawned on me really how logical everything you're saying is. Acting like it's no big deal making it easier to come back to is absolutely what I should do. On one of our good days recently we even acknowledged that the last three years haven't *really* been a break-up/make-up cycle, but more a constant being in love and moving together and apart because of his needs. And maybe if we quit pathologizing it, and take the pattern in stride, it'll be easier. Think of it more as shifting tides (a natural in and out) instead of "OMG! We're breaking up! OMG, we're back together!"

I knew that this forum would be a HUGE help.
 
Yes I'd keep it short, under 100 words, and realize if symptomatic it's likely to be taken more negatively, so be ready understanding it could end.

I agree with this too:
'I'm fine with letting you have space to deal with your anxiety on your own. I acknowledge that this is a hard journey for you, maybe even one that feels impossible sometimes.',

but not so much that ptsd = 'imperfections', in that everyone has imperfections, but not everyone has ptsd. PTSD can feel like imperfections on steroids.

Personally I would just say the line of yours I quoted above, I love you, and hope to get together soon. The rest you might communicate in small doses at the right time in person (but I wouldn't quote researchers- and eg, knowing about the stress cup for yourself and doing things to release stress from both of yours may be more useful than talking about it). Then decide what you're able to tolerate / want for you and choose from there. JMHO though.

violent childhood (dad was a spouse abuser, mother used him as a faux-spouse practically from birth)

Might explain why he isn't crazy about getting in to that now. Very different than a (non) commitment issue, IMHO.

Bet wishes to you, and welcome. :hug:
 
Hi sufferer here. I've been on the same carousel with my ex for 23 years you know the friends/unre...

Yeah, but you’re trauma bonded with your ex so it’s like apples and oranges. The OP isn’t abusive nor is she with an abusive guy, so it’s really not the same as your situation where you can’t stop going back to a sexually and physically abusive partner.
 
Sorry Eve I keep forgetting that you're an expert on MY life How remiss of me You're now going on Ignore.
 
Thank you so very much for replying. Honestly, it made me cry.
You're absolutely right. On a...
I am in a very similar situation. Loads of break ups over and over and now he says we should just be friends because it's too hard for him. I just don't know if that is possible for either of us, and like you, think I need to go cold turkey if I decide to end this. Also like you , I always had the feeling we would be back together and it did always happen. But, ugh.

I am taking some time not to thibk about what I will do when he comes back, but here I am reading these stories.

I also think the letter was very loving and heartfelt and also way too long. I'm glad to see you got so much help revising it.very great help here!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top