• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Slow-motion passive suicide vs normal active suicide

Ecdysis

Diamond Member
I'm in a weird situation regarding "passive slow-motion" suicide.

When I was younger and physically healthier, it would've been quite a lot of active effort to die by suicide, but now I'm older and my health is so poor, it wouldn't take much effort at all... I'm sort of like a diabetic who, if they completely f*ck up their medication and insulin will manage to die within like 6 - 12 months, and it would be recorded as a death due to unmanaged diabetes... Or similar for a kidney patient, or heart patient, who doesn't take their meds and does the opposite of what the doctor's say...

Like it's a passive, slow suicide, but would be recorded as natural death due to health complications from a serious chronic illness. Anyway, the point is, that when I was younger, it was pretty clear what was actual SI attempts and what was not.

I know for others, it's not that clear cut... Like, serious alcohol addiction or drug addiction or serious eating disorders or other forms of self-harm would fall into that category of slow-motion passive suicide too. I guess stuff like super risky driving or super risky sports, where people are thrill-seeking in a way that death is quite a possible/probable part of the equation can also fit that bill.

But in my case, I didn't do that kind of stuff when I was younger. So now I'm in that blurry slow-motion passive SI situation for the first time.

I find it especially confusing in medical situations where I'm getting treatment (sometimes quite complex and expensive) aimed at keeping me alive, while my brain is trying to die in that subtle, passive, slow-motion way, not the "dramatic" fast/active ways that we ususally think of suicide attempts as.

It feels so weird to me that medical staff (external to me) are trying to keep me alive, while large parts of my brain (not all) are like "Hey, it's soooo easy to die... I just need to not take my meds properly and do the opposite of what I'm meant to do and, yah, eeeeasy..." And I feel so, so weird having medical staff doing complicated stuff like scintigraphys, while I'm silently sitting there going hmm... so I'm voluntarily at this medical appointment whose purpose is to keep me alive, while I'm kind of actively-passively trying to die...???"

I'm so confused by it. I've written about it before, and I've fired my last trauma T cos he was so, so useless at talking about suicidal ideation. It's like part of my brain (70%?) is trying to die and a smaller part (30%?) is like "No, no, that's just a symptom of depression... Get the depression treated and try and stay alive..." Those two conflicting stances already have me beyond confused.

And then add in the blurry slow-motion passive suicide that doesn't "really" seem like a "proper" suicide to make it more confusing, and then add in medical treatments trying to keep me alive at the same time as much of my brain is trying to find subtle but effective ways of dying?

Ugh... I just don't get it or how to deal with it or any of it...

Edit to add:

This is what the AI (ChatGPT 5.3) says about it - I'm pasting the official terms it used, because I think they're quite helpful for me to get my head around it:

"Passive suicidal ideation – wishing for death or being indifferent to living, without an immediate active plan.
Self-neglect – intentionally or semi-intentionally not caring for one’s health.
Indirect self-destructive behavior – patterns where harm accumulates slowly rather than through a single act.
Chronic suicidal ambivalence – living in a long-term state where parts of the mind lean toward death while others continue living.

Researchers sometimes call this “life-threatening non-adherence” when it involves medication or medical care.
It’s surprisingly common in chronic illness and long-term depression."
 
Last edited:
my psychotherapy for suicidal ideation was in the '70s, back when people were smarter than phones. we called those slow, tedious suicides, "a death wish." i had to do a web search to see if the term is still in use. it is, with some potentially useful information involved. in my own case, i believe a goodly portion of my death wish is accepting my mortality. i don't get to keep my beautiful bod forever. with my 72nd birthday around the corner, that truth is more evident by the day.
I find it especially confusing in medical situations where I'm getting treatment (sometimes quite complex and expensive) aimed at keeping me alive
for me, this is a separate issue. i started boycotting doctors in 1995 when the age-related testing became a full-time opportunity. waiting rooms and hospitals are not where i want to spend my end of days. talking to peers who are living procedure to procedure makes me want to vomit. then we get to the insurance joys. thanks but no thanks.
 
Yeah it’s a confusing thing. I ask god to kill me every day but I put on my seat belt, drink water, etc. My poor daughter also has SI and tells me she won’t make to 20, cuts her arms but refuses to have her blood drawn because she’s afraid of the pain. Also she will randomly tell me in tears she’s afraid she has some terrible disease. I think the SI is more about wanting certain feelings to end rather than the entire experience of life?
 
I think the SI is more about wanting certain feelings to end rather than the entire experience of life?
agree with this.

I think I used to heavily live like that. when I was little I would ideate bad things happening to me, accidents and stuff, instead of outright thinking about killing myself. same with my self harm ideation. I did self harm but Id also just ideate bad things happening to me, getting hit by a car for example. a lot of my ideas of suicide involved me just not being careful and something happening to me. also self harm by not treating pain/stuff that was already there.

and then trauma stuff started obviously coming up and it got a lot worse, was just living badly, and habitually doing stuff that could get me sick or make me weak, or in more pain, etc. that was my way of being, just doing as little as possible for myself. but then I had some kind of cardiac event once and I walked myself to hospital after calling 111. so it is weird.

but I think as rose white said it's a lot more about wanting specific stuff to stop than life itself. which can be hard to tel the difference of when its a feeling consuming your life, but it is different. I think a lot of the time it feels like there's no other way to cure the thing than for everything to stop, but when it comes down to it the bits about being alive that are okay kick in and you logically know it's not necessary to die, and that like you said, maybe things can change and things will be different/better/more manageable in the future.

bit that lives in whatecer's fueling the SI vs bit that lives in the present with the knowledge that this isnt the entire scope of life.

it's like cutting/other self harm isnt really about being in pain, it's about managing/venting feelings that are too much (incl self hatred). which is why most of the time being hurt by someone else or being hurt in other ways than selected self harm method is still offputting/scary/whatecer.
 
I'm in a weird situation regarding "passive slow-motion" suicide.

When I was younger and physically healthier, it would've been quite a lot of active effort to die by suicide, but now I'm older and my health is so poor, it wouldn't take much effort at all... I'm sort of like a diabetic who, if they completely f*ck up their medication and insulin will manage to die within like 6 - 12 months, and it would be recorded as a death due to unmanaged diabetes... Or similar for a kidney patient, or heart patient, who doesn't take their meds and does the opposite of what the doctor's say...

Like it's a passive, slow suicide, but would be recorded as natural death due to health complications from a serious chronic illness. Anyway, the point is, that when I was younger, it was pretty clear what was actual SI attempts and what was not.

I know for others, it's not that clear cut... Like, serious alcohol addiction or drug addiction or serious eating disorders or other forms of self-harm would fall into that category of slow-motion passive suicide too. I guess stuff like super risky driving or super risky sports, where people are thrill-seeking in a way that death is quite a possible/probable part of the equation can also fit that bill.

But in my case, I didn't do that kind of stuff when I was younger. So now I'm in that blurry slow-motion passive SI situation for the first time.

I find it especially confusing in medical situations where I'm getting treatment (sometimes quite complex and expensive) aimed at keeping me alive, while my brain is trying to die in that subtle, passive, slow-motion way, not the "dramatic" fast/active ways that we ususally think of suicide attempts as.

It feels so weird to me that medical staff (external to me) are trying to keep me alive, while large parts of my brain (not all) are like "Hey, it's soooo easy to die... I just need to not take my meds properly and do the opposite of what I'm meant to do and, yah, eeeeasy..." And I feel so, so weird having medical staff doing complicated stuff like scintigraphys, while I'm silently sitting there going hmm... so I'm voluntarily at this medical appointment whose purpose is to keep me alive, while I'm kind of actively-passively trying to die...???"

I'm so confused by it. I've written about it before, and I've fired my last trauma T cos he was so, so useless at talking about suicidal ideation. It's like part of my brain (70%?) is trying to die and a smaller part (30%?) is like "No, no, that's just a symptom of depression... Get the depression treated and try and stay alive..." Those two conflicting stances already have me beyond confused.

And then add in the blurry slow-motion passive suicide that doesn't "really" seem like a "proper" suicide to make it more confusing, and then add in medical treatments trying to keep me alive at the same time as much of my brain is trying to find subtle but effective ways of dying?

Ugh... I just don't get it or how to deal with it or any of it...

Edit to add:

This is what the AI (ChatGPT 5.3) says about it - I'm pasting the official terms it used, because I think they're quite helpful for me to get my head around it:

"Passive suicidal ideation – wishing for death or being indifferent to living, without an immediate active plan.
Self-neglect – intentionally or semi-intentionally not caring for one’s health.
Indirect self-destructive behavior – patterns where harm accumulates slowly rather than through a single act.
Chronic suicidal ambivalence – living in a long-term state where parts of the mind lean toward death while others continue living.

Researchers sometimes call this “life-threatening non-adherence” when it involves medication or medical care.
It’s surprisingly common in chronic illness and long-term depression."
I was just going write a post on this and here it is so thank you so much. I know and I’ve probably known for a long time this is going on. What’s strange is it’s only part of me which is family systems stuff but I use it because parts seem to fit me so well. And here is the weird thing part of me is actually happy if I’m left alone . I like things. I even like work and physical labor I was born for in a way lots of people can’t do it. I should have worked with my head but another story. The point is that’s another part. They’re separate. Then the little kid part then the girl part yada yada.

Then the suicidal part. He she it just can’t live with it and the spooky part is the subconscious self harm. I’m afraid of people because I make them abuse me. So I’m a recluse . It’s not so bad if you can get away with it. If I don’t have to interact with people, my symptoms are very manageable.

But the subconscious self harm part it’s still finds ways to get at me. I’m doing a computer project right now and I’m actually working quite hard and I like it . I’m always afraid to though mistakes in particular are a devastating self harm mechanism. It’s like a blind spot .

I’m musical I’m creative I’m happy I’m suicidal. WTF are you supposed to do with that ? I don’t use terms like drug addict anymore because I don’t like labels even if they fit. But I finally have the meds I want . Managing them is nightmarish but it beats suicidal depression.

If you understand this I’m your friend forever and I have a very few, friends that is. I sympathize and empathize. Even the very few Friends I’ve had, that’s hard to manage. I’m not if I look back, and there’s more looking back now I’m 67, what you’d call likeable. Not exactly a people person, which is a bad joke. But there’s a few people and you click with them and they know what you’re like and somehow they don’t mind it. It’s weird. Thanks this thread is right where I am currently. I needed this.
 

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom