• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Question About Article

Status
Not open for further replies.

Redtail

Silver Member
Ok so I am trying to get this organized in my head and how to get started, so several questions come to mind;

-Do the articles have to be sourced or can they come from personal experience and training received. Some of the training I received was 15 or so years ago and I cant not remember instructor names, course title etc..
- How much of the overlapping needs to be covered or left out. I am trying to focus on Police related PTSD and the symptoms are the same and treatment is the same so those should not be covered. Should it only be on the topic that is somewhat in limbo to the diagnoses and treatment?

Sure hope this questions make sense.
 
-Do the articles have to be sourced or can they come from personal experience and training received.
They don't need to be sourced, however; some form of reference should be found at some point / some form of identification should be referenced as to where the information come from.

Whilst what you did as police, for example, may believe is correct or the only way, you then have to review other police strategies, other countries police, etc... and how they do things. You can write from experience, absolutely, but then you should go looking afterwards through something like Google Scholar or such, to find some referenced material that backup your experience findings.

How much of the overlapping needs to be covered or left out. I am trying to focus on Police related PTSD and the symptoms are the same and treatment is the same so those should not be covered. Should it only be on the topic that is somewhat in limbo to the diagnoses and treatment?
Correct. You would not create a topic on Police PTSD, because there is no such thing. PTSD is PTSD, then there is CPTSD, though that is not official. Police is a type of trauma, or more importantly, emergency services would be the correct name given, covering police, fire and ambulance, as a type of trauma.

It depends on the type of topics you could create on the type of trauma, as to whether more topics would be created on the one subject. For example, whilst you can cover the type of trauma as emergency services and delve into all three areas, you could also create a topic, off the top of my head, separating say SWAT or such, as they would be exposed to different and more likely re-occurent trauma than say the every day police officer, or merely just different types, ie. police see MVA accidents, etc, SWAT are more hostile based trauma, drugs, arms, etc... then there are specialties again, detectives in sexual abuse, they would be readily around a different type of trauma.

Saying that, you could also make one specific trauma on Police, which then breaks down all the different facets of police, as mentioned above, and the different types of trauma each endure... ie. you can't paint police with the same brush, as all see and experience different traumatic events, or less likely to experience traumatic events, etc.

I think right now, the only subject heading is Trauma. So we could create "Emergency Services" and then as sub pages to that, have a page on each, Police, Fire & Ambulance. But we will get to that as more pages are created, so we can see what structure appears naturally.

What topics do you believe you could write upon based on your experience RedTail, and what you want to write upon, being Police?
 
Very well answered Anthony, as I was perplexed about how to cover the topic.

What topics do you believe you could write upon based on your experience RedTail, and what you want to write upon, being Police?

I think trauma is the correct way to go. Also, as in Military, I think the training aspect needs to be mentioned, the training to overcome the flight or fight and push it more toward the fight. After the State standard 10 week training I attended a 12 week "stress" academy based after the US military boot camp.
Also the stigma surrounding the Police culture and admitting to an illness needs to be addressed.

Is this a little more in line?
 
I can give personal experience as Swat, Detectives, Narcotics, Officer Involved Shootings, Supervision, Patrol and Detention. I do believe that the every day patrol officer is exposed to trauma more often.
 
I would also like to address the family aspect, will probably post a research request when the time comes.
 
The above seem like relevant topics for one good wiki page, from the way I am reading it.

I think under the trauma category, we have just break the three emergency services down, Police, Fire, Ambulance, that way a specific page can exist for all three, as they will uniquely have their ups and downs.

From reading the above, I can already see a good heading structure coming together, ie.
  • Introduction
  • Training
  • Classifications
    • Patrol Officer
    • Detectives
    • Narcotics
    • Internal Affairs
    • etc etc
  • Culture
  • Family
  • Transition To Civilian Life
  • Etc...
Obviously all leading to the end result of possible PTSD / actual PTSD.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$930.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  51.7%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom