• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

The Absurdity Of PTSD - Bad Luck

Status
Not open for further replies.

bluesky

New Here
This post turned out rather long, my apologies!

I have been reading a book by Cordelia Fine ‘A Mind Of Its Own’. I highly recommend this book. It basically shows how the brain is deceptive, lies and refuses often to see our own faults because we need to survive. She noted, with humour, the only people who truly see reality, their own faults, are the clinically depressed! Therefore a healthy brain operates by preventing us realising our own faults. I hope I conveyed that well. It is not just her opinion or pop-psychology. She cites psychology/neuroscience research studies from Harvard, Stanford, etc. As someone who personally is involved with a level of academia, I have a trust thing with books, I don’t like to be fed lies, haha!

She grave a great metaphor of how there are several mechanisms of the brain and how it is the ‘conscious mind’s’ job to block any unsavoury messages. THAT is the brain performing optimally. However, I believe and this is my interpretation, my conscious brain has failed to do this. Someone on here has said that PTSD is not necessarily just one experience. Like all the things you have been trying to bury, even ones that weren’t particularly traumatic at the time (maybe just upsetting, weird or difficult to understand) suddenly are triggered off. You aren’t necessarily just dealing with one thing, though that may have triggered the collapse; everything else in your personal history gets illuminated. You are completely swamped. I have also heard this from a suicide clip off YouTube when a woman said her breakdown in the end was caused by the death of her husband, and then everything else just came up.

Does this sound accurate to anyone? Is this similar to your experiences? I was reflecting that really...PTSD is bad luck. Because we cannot control our brain. When I had my breakdown, I was consumed with guilt to the point of feeling suicidal. The thing I couldn’t work out was, how did people live with it? i.e. offenders. And then I worked out previous to this breakdown, it just hadn’t occurred to me to deeply reflect on them (who would? – healthy brain). It was just bad luck that the memory was triggered. And part of me thinks... I wish it hadn’t. I still fail to see any good that has come out of this. It’s meant enduring an amazing amount of personal pain, guilty, doubt, denial, delusions, confusions and depressions. I now can no longer rely on my memory and it’s undermined my confidence in myself.

And the thing is... it just was bad luck that I was triggered. If I hadn’t seen the person who brought it all back, maybe it wouldn’t have happened. I guess I posted this to see if anyone had felt similar to this, but also because I am in the position of both having mental health issues and becoming a ‘professional’ who hopefully will assist and support people during crises.
 
Here is the way it is best described for myself. Since I have C-PTSD and multiple traumatic experiences I developed many "shells" to help me through life. It's kind of like putting on make up everyday and never taking it off just piling on the mask over and over day after day. Well since this is another (can't even remember how many breakdowns I've had) severe episode the way I feel is if the stress (good or bad) gets overwhelming or reaches a threshold the make up/shell is washed off and I am bombarded with out of control emotions, fear, depression, rage, everything. Slowly but surely I will be able to put myself back together. I don't think it has anything to do with luck though. PTSD is like Malaria it can lie under the surface and then just flare up when you least suspect it.
 
My breakdown was triggered by the deaths of my father and sister within 12 months of each other (father's was unexpected, sister's was after a long illness). Like the woman who's husband's death brought up so much other stuff, so did the deaths in my family. I knew I didn't have a happy childhood and wanted to forget it. But with my brain refusing to shut up and do what it was told, I remembered the extent of the abuses and all the things I put into locked boxes and stored away suddenly were thrown open and the contents strewn about. I've spent the last four years of my life dealing with those things and trying to put them away again. Mostly success. A few things keep popping up.

I do agree that PTSD is absurd. The way/shape/form of it. There are times I laugh at the absurdity of it. I do things because I enjoy them and then I spend days afterwards ill from the stress of doing things I enjoy. Things that make you go 'huh?'. The book you mentioned does sound like a good read.

PTSD is like Malaria it can lie under the surface and then just flare up when you least suspect it.
Funny you should put it like that. The college where I work has a very large malaria program and you learn all sorts of things just by being around the research. And your words are very apropos.

Lisa
 
I still fail to see any good that has come out of this. It’s meant enduring an amazing amount of personal pain, guilty, doubt, denial, delusions, confusions and depressions. I now can no longer rely on my memory and it’s undermined my confidence in myself.

I have now found the good that comes out of PTSD so I thought I would share with you. Yes I went through amazing amounts of pain at first and could have typed those words myself. Now, I know myself. All those "bad messages" I had to explore and find where they came from. Doing that enabled me to make healthy changes. Those things I didn't like about myself and hid from, I could change because I was forced to look at them and examine them. It was very painful, have no doubt, but the end results are so worth it. I know what my negative traits are, the ones I haven't been able to completely change as of yet, I have minimized. Those I could change, I did. I explored my positive traits and used them and made better use of them.

To me there is no greater gift than knowing myself and having the ability to change what I don't like. I have power and control over who I am and who I want to be. PTSD gave me that.

I would be careful in how much of this "healthy brains hide our faults from us" that you believe. Just because there is a book on it does not mean it is agreed upon by all in Psychology. Social Work is all about exploring yourself and learning what changes you can make, what you have control over. It is about empowerment. ( Of course this depends on what aspect you lean towards, there are many different methods.) You could not be empowered, ever, if you brain never let you see your own faults and therefore would be unable to make changes. Please read more on this. Look into the different methods of Social work and what they are based on (history of Social Work is a good place to start here.)

Personally, I feel that anyone hiding their own faults from themselves is far from healthy. I don't really care what studies say what. Healthy is knowing yourself and making changes for yourself that are positive. Having control over yourself.

And yes, PTSD triggers all sorts of things. You need to deal with the trauma and all the other crap too. Anything negative or it will feed it.

bec
 
  • Like
Reactions: Iam
Since I have C-PTSD and multiple traumatic experiences I developed many "shells" to help me through life. It's kind of like putting on make up everyday and never taking it off just piling on the mask over and over day after day. Well since this is another (can't even remember how many breakdowns I've had) severe episode the way I feel is if the stress (good or bad) gets overwhelming or reaches a threshold the make up/shell is washed off and I am bombarded with out of control emotions, fear, depression, rage, everything. Slowly but surely I will be able to put myself back together.

This is a nice picture, and so true. I think my pile of masks got so thick and heavy over the years that I sometimes just cannot move a single inch, got totally stuck in it.
 
I would be careful in how much of this "healthy brains hide our faults from us" that you believe. Just because there is a book on it does not mean it is agreed upon by all in Psychology. Social Work is all about exploring yourself and learning what changes you can make, what you have control over. It is about empowerment. ( Of course this depends on what aspect you lean towards, there are many different methods.) You could not be empowered, ever, if you brain never let you see your own faults and therefore would be unable to make changes. Please read more on this. Look into the different methods of Social work and what they are based on (history of Social Work is a good place to start here.)

I agree. I am sorry if this post has offended anyone, I truly didn't mean any harm or to raise controversy. I totally agree with the Empowerment and Strengths Perspective. I guess I am still struggling to understand this disorder, and this book offered another way of seeing it? That's why I wanted to know others opinions. And yes it is healthier to know your faults! Coming to think if it that was a silly assertion I made. But I just remember the few years that I didn't have this, full blown, and I miss them. I miss feeling like I have a future.

Thank you for your feedback!
 
Your welcome but please don't apologize. It is impossible not to offend someone on a forum of this size if everything is taken personally. Just see some of Anthony's post on "offending" someone.. LOL... I also miss feeling that I have a future but have learned to live for now and this moment. And that is a lot more then I ever expected!

bec
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom