• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

News Article: 9/11 Trauma Passed Through Pregnant Women To Offspring

Status
Not open for further replies.

BloomInWinter

VIP Member
Their victim-blaming 'title' non-withstanding....(shameless to blame traumatized pregnant women. Wow do they need a new editor...) still an interesting topic.

[DLMURL]http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/neurophilosophy/2011/sep/09/pregnant-911-survivors-transmitted-trauma[/DLMURL]

Could our PTSD be from previous generations?
 
The question that screams in my mind is how much impact parental behavior had on the learned responses of the children.
This is also my primary incite to reading that entire news story... which cited:
A key study in this emerging field, published in 2004, showed that the quality of a rat mother's care significantly affects how its offspring behave in adulthood.
Well no shit... there are plenty of studies that already exist that empirically prove that neglecting a child in early childhood affects that child in teen and adulthood... it called emotional abuse.

Not really sure what exactly it has to do with them trying to pair the lower cortisol levels from parent to new born though. Clear evidence already exists that our bodies can and do change constantly, which means, whilst a parent may have passed a lower cortisol level to their newborn, that level can change if the child is raised in a healthy manner and the child is well cared and loved, hence other studies mentioned in that same article.

I think its extremely idiotic to use 9/11 as an excuse. They got it right in the first instance, being psychologists thought they would have this flood of business after 9/11, yet it didn't exist, because empirical data already exists on how robust the human brain is to overcome from trauma, hence the current trendy term, plasticity.

Therapy models where changed from 9/11 because they found it was far better to not intervene with therapy and instead put all the effected persons in a room together and let them talk amongst themselves, cry, grieve, etc, with others who understood their pain directly... the results changed therapeutic training to what we know now, being a majority of people will suffer symptoms after trauma, being normal, yet will also recover 100% within six months without any intervention. Its only a minority that after this time don't recover, or have snowballed trauma within their pasts, where one traumatic event is the straw the broke the camels back, so to speak.
 
I'm wondering if some of the symptoms that are so distressing in out civilized lives may actually have served an important biologically adaptative survival function. If we were still living in caves, would we be the ones most likely to successfully rear our offspring successfully to adulthood?

Could PTSD be a primative, protective response in one hostile environment even while being so difficult in a civilized (relatively) one?

Could being in a hostile environment ignite the brain into not a 'maladaptive' response back then, but rather a highly desirable survival triad of;

constriction (sticking to known paths to and from one's cave or areas of cover)

hypervigilance (being ready to act on environmental cue)

numbing (being able to ignore pain, injury to get our tribe and offspring 'back to the cave' before collapsing)

Interesting to ponder, no? Then passing these survival characteristics would be granting our offspring a greater chance of survival.

Turns our 'being a wreck' dreck on it's head, then.

Then, WE are the strong members of the tribe, leaving behind the non-PTSD tribe members behind....maybe we're not so weird.

'When you're being chased by a lion, you don't have to run faster than the lion, just faster than your companions...'

:P
 
The epigenetics of stress has already been scientifically demonstrated clear back to the Holocaust. Yehuda's study was novel in that it was prospective and follwed 'live' chemical masrkers.

PTSD patients are generally more perceptive to danger but not always able to act - so while we may recognize the lion in the grass, we don't always have the ability to run. We often read people perfectly and still wind up abused by them.
In cave man days, living long enough to pass along your genetic material was the goal - so yes we would have been the ones most likely to pass along our genetic material. In this day however, our mechanisms of survival are costly.
 
The freeze response would have been good for some of our tribe back then, if they were the ones entrusted with the care of our offspring. Then, they would 'freeze' with the children while we 'fight' types took the fight to a different area. :>

*sigh. If only our finely adapted brains were useful when navigating Wal-Mart.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar posts

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom