• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

News Interview Regarding Memory Formation And Proteins

Status
Not open for further replies.

heidi

Platinum Member
Link Removed

What do you think? How about the claim that a woman's painful memories were vanished by taking beta blockers while recalling painful memories?
I would do a follow up interview with that woman.
I'd be surprised if she experienced even a slight improvement.
 
Wow the first question asked was if you could take a pill to forget would you. Absolutely not because I have learned so many lessons that I might accidently repeat if they were just wiped away. I would however like the pain associated with the memory erased. Then again would that effect our coinsience?
 
*just want to warn.. there are some graphic photos of a car accident within the text (and first responders)...
But here is the article the interview was based off of. Contains much more detailed information.
[DLMURL]http://www.wired.com/magazine/2012/02/ff_forgettingpill/all/1[/DLMURL]
 
This is still the old news of propranolol, which they're still trying to find a use for in trauma as it's a massive market worth billions of dollars per annum.

Propranolol failed in military trials as a beta blocker, giving it to soldiers before going on combat missions to lessen the effect any event would have within the brain. Well... it failed as a majority result.

Because that failed, due to their claims it could block the memory forming if taken as a preventative measure prior to trauma exposure, so have since now taken up round two of the medication in fighting for the trauma market... this time, lets give it during the recall of memories to really do the same thing, except instead of when being faced with the trauma, the exact same thing is being achieved except through recalling it, claiming it reduces the memories impact after being exposed to the drug.

As usual, the media grabs everything and anything and rewords it for marketing potential to an audience of readers. Readers perpetuate it... then just like propranolol's initial media marketing and the best drug to hit the trauma market years ago, it will again die down with minimal results affecting a small minority.

There will be a small minority who will likely jump on it, use it on every client they have and attempt to justify everything back to it... all without the clinical results to back it up.

Right now, this is all media hype, just like its initial release as a pre-trauma memory forming preventative, which failed dismally.

Drugs companies are doing what they do... trying to come up with a drug to fix mental health. Everything to date points away from drugs being a viable solution to mental health treatment as a primary solution... instead they're finding minority results in using them as secondary aids and treating mental health primarily with psychotherapy showing the best results still today.

The biggest hurdle though, which hasn't changed to date, is the person being treated.
 
Well that's disappointing. It sounded so sciencey with the discussion of proteins being rebuilt. Guess it's all just a bunch of BS though.
 
They love to make things sound official and empirical Heidi... unfortunately, empirical only comes when the same results show a similar outcome based on the test performed, thus building a foundation of factual information.

People love to do one study, try and market that one study as factual and accurate, and it works to a small degree... then as more studies are done, suddenly the same results aren't shown, thus empirical validity fails to be proven and the substance of the outcome is all BS.

They keep going back trying to get propranolol into the trauma market... yet even the US DOD rejected it at the end of the day as nothing more than a half arsed hit and miss partial solution, which showed little positive results overall. When weighing into such drugs the negative side effects on those it doesn't work, to date it simply isn't a viable solution... though they are continuing to try nonetheless.

They may come across the right beta blocker to achieve empirical results in the next 5 - 10 years, but right now... it's just another pharmaceutical fad.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$980.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  54.4%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom