• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Therapist Says That I Should Try Group Therapy Instead

Status
Not open for further replies.

wallflower

Bronze Member
I have been seeing the same therapist for about 2 years. We don't seem to be progressing so she says that I should try group therapy. I'm not sure what to think about this. Has this happened to others on here and was group more helpful than one on one?
 
I have been in therapy for about 3 and half years. I have made a lot of progress but every year I have seasonal depression. My therapist wanted me to look into going to group therapy as 'extra support'. I decided not to go though. The only other time was when I was in the hospital. There was group therapy in the hospital, I found it helpful but therapy in a hospital would be much more intense becasue most people there are very down and emotional.

When you say 'instead', do you mean your therapist wants to terminate your therapy with her all together?
 
Group therapy is not meant to replace individual therapy. It's a supplement.

I agree with Solara. Around the 2 year point I have always stopped progressing with a therapist and its time for a switch.
 
What does she think group therapy would give you? Have the two of you talked about the possibility of individual therapy with a different therapist (maybe a different type of therapy)?
 
What type of group therapy is it? Normally if this happens it is because the T feels we don't have enough coping skills and that lack is interfering with T too much.

That would make sense if for example it was a DBT or CBT group. I have to say though that it is common to still continue to have t sessions so that you have somewhere to process what comes up in group.

What do you feel has stopped your progress in therapy and what does your t think? Do you think your T is good, a good fit for you and is knowledgeable about treating trauma? Is social phobia a big issue?
 
Group therapy, done well, is an excellent adjunct therapy for many reasons. I've always found it helpful.

In group therapy, we get to learn how to discuss difficult things with a teacher/moderator/advocate right there, unlike in real life. Practicing how to stay calm and speak for ourselves without crossing others' boundaries is a very valuable and necessary skill in having a stable, peaceful existence.

We also learn that a lot of what we think is abnormal or strange about ourselves is actually pretty common, whether or not it is healthy. It combats the narcissistic defense of "I'm too smart/mature/messed up/unique for anyone else to be able to help me." Believing we're unique helps us push help and loved ones away, but it also leaves us alone in our suffering.

We learn how others handle difficult feelings, events, emotions in their lives, and receive tips on how we can manage such things in our lives. Having several options to choose from empowers us to be more personally effective in knowing and achieving our goals.

For those who have social phobia, it's an exposure therapy in a controlled environment, unlike everywhere else. For those with depression and/or suicidal ideation, it's a safe space to speak about difficult feelings without alarming our loved ones. For those of us with multiple triggers to people, or tones of voices, or certain words, it is effective prolonged exposure to the trigger so it can be extinguished and no longer hold such power.
It's a safe place to learn how to express ourselves and be heard without monopolizing the discussion. Many do not know how to do that when they were never heard growing up, so when they have the floor, they run with it. That's great in a dysfunctional environment, but not good at all in our day to day interactions with adults.

We learn that not all people are bad. Not all therapists are incompetent, nor perfect. We are made aware of cognitive distortions that interfere in our everyday life and increase our suffering.

Occasionally, we might make a friend. The first group I was in, an Adult Children of Alcoholics group, was the turning point for me in successfully separating from my sick family. The people I met in there have remained lifelong friends, though most have died premature deaths. I'm still friends with the counselor, long since retired. We don't get together or anything, but when we run into each other it feels like we've just seen each other.

Another big benefit of group therapy was running into the group members at the doctor's office, or shopping, or out in the world. A simple smile and knowing "look" helped me feel like there were others out there who knew what I deal with. Sort of like finding safe waypoints in my travels.

I highly suggest it for anyone with PTSD. It has greatly increased my positive experiences in my life, and helped me successfully manage conflicts big and small with the new tools I learned.
 
Maybe it's your therapist? Two years is a long time. Usually by that point I've learned all I can from one person.
EEk. I've been seeing the same therapist for 4 years. He is my one and only T ever. I have no intention of changing. We are both still learning. However I have not been having 'regular' therapy. Only as and when required, so its not like I have seen him every week for 4 years. In fact it is about 9 weeks since I saw him last and my next session will be when I decide I need it.

As for group therapy - I have never tried it, nor have I been offered it. I just cannot imagine doing it at all. The very idea horrifies me, and I think I would go into my shell and gain nothing.I guess it is partly because it takes such a long time to trust your therapist. Once you add other sufferers into the equation there is an awful lot of trust needed to be able to start sharing.

I appreciate it is helpful for others, and if you have reached a plateau in therapy then maybe a change would be good. I will be interested in learning @wallflower whether you go with it or not, and if so how you get on.
 
My T has tried to get me into a group for several years, but I was not strong enough to do it. Just recently I asked him if there was any groups starting soon. He was starting a group for aggression/anger management. I asked to join it as I was trying to expand my abilities and also trying to find some means of socializing. I also was/am having severe issues with anger management.

The group dynamics add other persons experience and have taught me a few things I don't think my T would have done any time soon.

I suggest giving group a chance, just like this forum, the broad experience of a group may let you discover new things.
 
I think Bloominwinter provided an excellent response (as well as other folks too :- )
I've seen a few different therapists. Like Solara, after about 1.5 - 2 years it was time for a break and/or a switch, until finding my current therapist. With her, I've had a few long breaks but she "gets me" - she knows me, knows how to talk to me and expresses genuine care (i.e. I don't feel like she strings me on because she wants/needs money or that I couldn't go on without her). So, I've gone back to her over the last seven years. Each time I've gone back I've been in a slightly in a different place. We pick up from where I (we) were and she suggests/gently pushes me to think or try something new - to move forward from where I was. I wish she was a family member so I didn't have to pay her (lol) and she'd remain in my life, but I know at some point I'll need to let her go . . .

I've done a few stints of group therapy too, as an add on to regular therapy. I found it very helpful - not always easy, but helpful.

I'd say why not try group thereapy and see what experience you have? [sorry my reply was so long]
 
Thank you for your helpful responses. I think that she meant *instead* of therapy because we seem to be stuck, but she may have meant in addition to. I guess I assumed that she was dumping me :-/. Talk therapy isn't working because I have a hard time talking about myself. I can talk about activities, my work, my kids, etc, but I really have a hard time opening up to anyone, including myself. I freeze up and the therapy session doesn't go far. Looking back at where I was 2 years ago (in a bad marriage, very unhappy, depressed), I know that I have improved a lot. I can't seem to break through what is holding me back from being the best I can be though. We know that it has to do with my childhood and whatever I'm hiding in my memories.

I guess I didn't think about all of the different kinds of group therapy. Yikes, I have no clue about what would be best for me. Possibly Adult Children of Alcoholics. Can anyone recommend where to find out about groups?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom