Well said CD... really well said. I wish, I want to even, say that I had control over things I have done in my past when PTSD was controlling me, but I honestly cannot say that I had full control. People think its to shift blame, and sometimes in cases it is, but not always. The mind and body is only capable of so much, then it breaks. Our body (we look fine to another) can handle the stress, anxiety and so forth at immediate looks, but it catches up with us through illness, looking older than we are, etc etc; our mind however breaks, and even many times daily when PTSD is for the most part, controlling the person.
We have a friend who for the life of both of us, did not think had PTSD, but then we also don't live with him either. He has some telltail traits, but I didn't think enough existed, though again, we don't live with him to accurately assess it. He doesn't show the normal signs of someone suffering uncontrolled PTSD, but he has been diagnosed with it. Why? Because he snapped, out of the blue, nearly killed a lady with his bare hands and anything he could find around him.
Afterwards, he has little memory of pieces, and broken in other areas, though he remembers he did actually do this, just not all the pieces. He went to the shrink, and he was diagnosed with PTSD from obviously what he had said to do with his past, as he was also on some of the same operations I was upon, same time, same places.
My wife actually used to live with him as flatmates, and where when I met her, and she said he changed when he returned home from a deployment, though he slowly got better. This happened to me on the same deployment actually, then bam... it caught up with me years later. We had what we thought was the normal response to abnormal situations, and we slowly healed, or so we thought, then I went down bad, and he is now going that way also.
He went to court, and he pleaded guilty, and got a suspended sentence. Now knowing this man, he is the most gentle giant you could come across, never hurt a fly. Chances are this female on the receiving end could get PTSD as a result, because she ended up in a pretty bad state apparently. Scarlette has just finished being arguementative about this exact thing, believing people have total control, that their actions should not be forgiven by people; where in fact its quite the opposite with PTSD, and in general most mental illnesses. The person could have 90% control vs. 10% PTSD controlling one moment, then it changes to 90% PTSD control vs. 10% actual control in another moment.
PTSD can be a very nasty disorder to be on the receiving end, and one never to be taken lightly. This is why I can't stress enough that the sufferer must take efforts to get themselves better, surpassing just sitting back and thinking it will happen, because it won't happen. PTSD can make a person lose total control, then honestly ask what just happened because they dissociated the entire incident.
Sure, some people could play it up, but hopefully those with some sort of moral backbone, would never take advantage of such a thing. Realistically though, some people will, and do.