• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

My Brother Shattered My Heart After My Father Died.

Status
Not open for further replies.

AngelKeeperJ

Sponsor
My soul feels so shattered...how to heal from this?

Written to my brother (not sent). It is in response to something he said to me after Dad's memorial service. I have been my parents' caretaker since 2004, while both brothers live on opposite parts of the country. My brother, who did not know the extent of my Dad's depression, mouthed off when he had no idea of what had really happened. I hope this makes sense. It is long, and I apologize.

Dear _____

I do not expect, want, or need a response to this letter. It's purpose is to share some information you are not aware of. You do not deserve to hear it, but I deserve to tell you!

First, when I called you in January, it was during a panic attack. I was either going to call you, or injure myself in some way that would cause the people I love more pain. I apologize for calling, and for calling when I did. I'm sure you were doing important things.

I remember very little. I know I told you that I hate you, but I do not. I don't have it in me to hate you, but the thought of you and your arrogance is almost unbearable from someone I thought loved me. I remember asking you if you had ever watched them try to resuscitate your father.

I despise your ability to judge without all the information. You are a player of “Praise the Lord, and point the finger'.

Second, was I supposed to leave Dad in his office, in the dark, day after day, coming out less and less? I realized that he was spending entire days there not talking to anyone. WHO was he supposed to talk to??? Now I know one of the reasons he was so sad. How do you think he felt when his son TOLD him NOT to talk to his daughter, who was his caretaker? That thought alone makes me physically ill.

During Dad and our talks, I'm sure we did cross some lines about mother and their marriage, that's why I suggested counseling. His answer was “why bother now, I'm 81, who cares?” I CARED!!! NO ONE came from the church called to talk to him, NO ONE called to invite him out for coffee. He saw NO reason to be alive. Mom NEVER conversed with him. He felt useless, used up, and so, so tired of being sad and being in pain.

How often did you call, and how long did you talk to him when you did? How much time did you spend with him in the 8 years since they moved back to Kansas. Oh, I know you had your 'important' job, and he was proud of you. But, did you ever really GIVE him ANY time???

He wanted to die. His only concern was leaving me with Mom. Finally, it was making me so sad to see my Dad like this, that my therapist asked me to ask Dad to get counseling for ME, if not for himself. He did, and it helped. He started acrylic painting again. His therapist pointed out to him that he was a good writer (she read his blogs), she commended him for staying with a woman who gave NOTHING of herself to him. NEVER even poured him a cup of coffee?! Or made him a meal? She fixed her own meals, never asking if anyone else was hungry.

She was in awe that he was so true to his marriage commitment. They were married over 60 years. But, he felt like a failure. DID YOU KNOW THAT??? Did you know that he did not know who 'HE' was, or what FUN was?? His life was a life of service to other's in the Name of God who he worshiped.

Do you know that Mother went entire days without talking to him, until bedtime, when she would state “I'm going to bed now, I'll take my kiss”? THAT was the extent of their 'conversation' and interaction.

One week we had company several days in a row. We noticed that Mom came COMPLETELY out of her 'shell', and talked and conversed like normal. When I was gone from the house, or out of town, there was NO conversation! Don't you think that hurt Dad to the core? Do you think Dad told you only what he felt he should, and maybe it wasn't ALL that was going on?

Then, at our Uncle's funeral, it was the same. She gave Dad NO attention, unless she needed something. She acted like he was an accessory. We realized at that point that her choice to not talk at home was a choice and NOT dementia. How do you think that made Dad feel?

He did not like talking negatively about Mom, but he had to vent to someone. Who would that have been???

Was I supposed to ignore his comments that told me he was so depressed, and expressed suicidal ideation? Do you know what that is?? (Brother is 'important'-works with Homeland Security) Probably knows nothing about depression and what it does to ones' soul.

My third point. I do not want to ever hear you say my name again. When you told me that you told Dad not to talk to me, I heard the venom and disgust in your voice. (We both know the true reason for that) You were blaming me for caring enough to have conversations with my father. Do you think it hurt his heart and soul to hear you say that? You HURT MY FATHER!!!! You make me sick.

It only mattered that you got to say what you thought you should say. How may hours did you spend talking to Dad, and did he tell you only what he thought you should hear.? Did you ever invite him for a visit?

Fourth, when you come to town to visit, I want as little contact with you as possible. I would arrange to be out of town, but don't want to confuse or upset the rest of the family.

Finally, that day, a loving 'Christian' brother could have put his arms around his sister, and stated that you knew she was afraid of the future, and that you knew she was in shock and that you would be supportive. But, NO, you had to reach out and hurt me when I was already shattered. WHO ARE YOU???

You chose to shatter my heart, regardless of the pain I had already been dealt. Nothing you can say will ever 'fix' that injury.

This goes SO against who I am, but I am human, and I believe God forgives me for having feelings, being in pain, and distraught that Dad thought 'my brothers' would “be there for me”. That has not, and did not happen. At least my other brother has sent texts, and offered to listen if I need to talk to someone.

What have you offered?? Zero, Zip, Nada! Don't try now...it's too late. You have judged and hurt me enough.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Thanks for taking the time to read my 'vent'.
 
Oh AKJ, I'm so sorry. :cry: :( I don't think that's a vent, but what you are feeling and expressing from your heart. I don't know sometimes how so much pain can be packed into people's lives and bodies.

I was thinking of betrayal, or lack of love/ hatred, by those we cannot fathom could. For me, it's been doubly difficult, not just in terms of shock or trying to trust again. But the sheer pain from someone you 'expect' or 'hope' or 'thought' loved you, and how it shatters the feeling sometimes love can even be possible.

But those are his problems, his guilt and his projecting on you, sounds like he feels HE hurt your dad. For what it's worth, your dad understands now. He would want you to get the pain out.

I think YOU were there for your dad, that's what counted. In the end that's all that matters. Especially when everyone else leaves. There's some saying like that, that love is when people will walk in when everyone else would walk out. I am glad you wrote it out. Thank you for the privilege to read it.

Biggest of hugs, I mean gigantic one, :hug: , xox.
 
PS AKJ, I hope you know I didn't mean in any way to negate your feelings, and what I meant (as a person relating to him), that what was important was not whether what you tried was effective or not, but that you cared so much.

You asked how can one heal from this. I don't know AKJ, slowly. It's a huge loss and the wound is raw. :(

I think 'forgiveness', per se, can mean a willful act to not take revenge. You've not returned what your brother has given in kind. From what I've read that you've said of your dad, you are your father's daughter for sure. I hope you can take some comfort in that. I hope you can continue communicating with your other brother, too.

(((((((((Dear dear AKJ)))))))))))
 
Well, I'll have to log out after this but wished to say Thank You. I could have written that and probably will now. The only difference would be that both of my parents faced the bald hurt and dismissal of my sisters together, having been literally told it was just time for them to go die. No one who did not hear them told this ( there are some who heard also, thank God ) believes there are people who exist in the world capable of such extreme cruelty, I'm so sorry you have one also.

I don't think about the word forgiveness, simply do not know what on earth that would mean or how one applies that to such harm to others. I just do not know, wish I did.

I think it's just plain impossible for basically good people to process these extremes, gosh, the pain that goes with it has to be put somewhere, or as much of it as can be contained somewhere. I wish I knew more, but it seems to me anyway that you did awfully well in what you've said and how you presented it? I could be wrong, and am just too close to my own awfully similar family pit. When in doubt, good to read something lovely from Junebug.

Yes, by the way, for what it's worth one of the comfort points for me ( alluding to something Junebug was getting at ) has been that I'm not one of 'them' and am apparently incapable of being so. And my parents knew/know that. It's 'something', you know?

As Junebug said, Gigantic Hugs, AK. I hope some of this made sense. Like I said, I might be way too close to something incredibly simlilar, and be genuinely unhelpful.
 
Solomon wrote, “to everything there is a season, a time for every purpose under heaven, a time to die and a time to heal, a time to weep, and a time to laugh, a time to mourn, and a time to dance” (Ecclesiastes 3:1-4). Emotional healing will come. A time to sing, a time to laugh and a time to dance will return.
 
Hmmm. I have never attempted to write my brother a letter after my dad died. Our relationship is severed because of his behavior immediately before and after the events around my dad's death. I waited for 3 years before making the decision. I have a lot of feelings about it.

I'm glad AJK that you could write it out for yourself.
 
I can feel your pain and suffering in your letter. Loving your Dad opened you up, vulnerable, and allowed you to be hurt more by others' callousness.

I have observed that not everyone is resilient to growing up in a family in which one parent is personality disordered. It appears that you may be the sole "soul" survivor, the only one who can really still love. In time, you'll see the beauty of yourself more than the ugliness of the brothers who didn't fair so well. In a way, we should pity them a bit for not having the capacity for empathy; maybe they were emotionally deformed by your Mother's mental or emotional abuse/neglect. Mother-son; Father-daughter dynamics? Not a judgment or opinion here, not this is just a guess or a musing designed to help make sense of the senseless cruelty I see everyday in families. Animals seem to treat their families better than humans treat their own.

Maybe it is key to strike out and create a family of one, inside, and maybe add good, worthy people to it as you go. My blessings to you on this painful part of your journey. It has been very hard for us so far, but if we love ourselves half as much as we have loved others, we will be well. And we are well, in our souls.

Blessings, Muse
 
It appears that you may be the sole "soul" survivor, the only one who can really still love. In time, you'll see the beauty of yourself more than the ugliness of the brothers who didn't fair so well. In a way, we should pity them a bit for not having the capacity for empathy; maybe they were emotionally deformed by your Mother's mental or emotional abuse/neglect.
Maybe it is key to strike out and create a family of one, inside, and maybe add good, worthy people to it as you go. My blessings to you on this painful part of your journey.

It has been very hard for us so far, but if we love ourselves half as much as we have loved others, we will be well. And we are well, in our souls.

Blessings, Muse

Wow, (((Muse))) What a stunningly eloquent way of speaking what I believe is the truth!!

I read my letter to my T, and he asked what I was going to do with it. I said throw it away. He suggested burning it, and then burying it as a symbolic way of 'letting go' so that the feelings won't become bitterness in my soul. That is what I am going to do, and my brother will never know of it, because he simply wouldn't understand. To me, it honors my feelings, which was what I needed, and to try to share them with him would quite possible interrupt my heallng. He would simply defend his words.

I won't allow it to make me bitter, but better, and stronger, for I survived a very cruel reaction to my shattered world. He/they do not deserve to know how it has changed me...for the better. When I woke up the morning after finishing the letter, and was getting ready to go see my T, I felt very emotionally 'light-hearted', as if a huge emotional boulder had been taken off my shoulders. What a feeling!

My younger brother, the one who inflicted the pain, will be coming to visit this month or next, and I was worried about how to handle it. Now, I believe it will be fairly easy, as he is someone that I do not 'know', and also, I am someone that he does not 'know'.

I have worked hard on being 'real' over the past few years, and he still lives in the pretense that because he is a Christian, he is absolved of any 'wrong' as long as he does not think of it as a 'sin'. He has no 'responsibiity' to my heart, and never did. He assumes he is better than me because he is a Federal Officer, has been married for over 25 years, has been a chaplain, and lives a 'charmed' life.

I have always been a follower of Christian, but I feel my responsibility is to live a life that is real, and as free from judging others as much as I can. If I catch myself 'judging', I know I am stepping 'out of line'. I am not a judge of anyone but myself, and am not 'higher' or 'lower' than any other person.

I HAVE learned to love, in a way that does not require a partner, or anyone else to 'complete' me. I AM very proud of the fact that I have been single for 19 years after 4 marriages. I've dated a bit, but no longer feel as I did when I was younger. I felt that I needed a partner to be a 'whole' person. That is so far from the truth now, and is a relief. I don't NEED anyone to fulfill me that is of 'this world'.

It seems I have written a 'book' in response to your reply, but truly you did put into words what I had not been able to, and I thank you for that.

I believe I will handle their visit calmly, and cautiously, which given the past is the smartest thing to do.

Big blessings being 'prayed' your way, Dear Muse!!!
 
Angel and Muse-Your words read like a page out of my life. I've been in the same place as you Muse, with all the marriages, and the need to fill a vow in my life. I really feel closer to GOD now too Angel. And I no longer feel the need to judge anybody, nor will I continue to judge myself so harshly. i am now learning to love me.scars and all! It's been a hard, lonely road at times but, I'm getting to HAPPY!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom