it helps me to look at things objectively
It really does.
Like
@Ronin said, the difference between trafficking & sex work is exactly the same as the difference between slavery & employment.
For some reason, especially in the US -I’m not sure why- people tend to confuse the two.
I’d add a couple more levels...
Trafficking / Slavery
Coercement / Abuse (choice?)
Desperation / Crime (choice)
_
Work
Avocation
If someone falls in the first 3 categories? It’s comparing apples to oranges, to try and compare them the second 2. Or maybe fruit to shoes. IDFK. Vaaaaaastly different groups. And still? There are so many
hard & unique things involved in each.
One of the most difficult things in coercement and desperation is the element of choice. Because it’s not the same
kind of choice, as choosing your work or choosing to go to work. Hating
yourself and the choices you make (or made) is 180 degrees differed from hating your job, or your life (because of your job). Inward vs Outward. You hate your job? Hate your life? Pfft. You can change those (comparatively) easily. Because every choice is a better choice, than what you’re currently choosing. A whole damn
sea of better choices to choose from! When you’re desperate or being coerced? It’s the opposite. You’re. not. making. bad. choices. You’re making the BEST choices possible... they just happen to suck the least of all the worse choices. There are no better choices (right now). Which you know. Because day in and day out you’re choosing all over again the best of the worst.
It’s one of the few upsides of things like rape & slavery, trafficking & imprisonment. There is no shred of choice involved.
Coercement and desperation is a mindf*ck in that regard, because you are literally choosing it. That doesn’t mean you liked it, much less wanted it, nor does it make it your fault in many cases. It’s like choosing between having your arms or your legs cut off. They’re BOTH things you. do. not. want. But if someone has a gun to your head, or your kids head, and says choose? Yeah. You’d rather not die. So you choose the best of the worst. But you were still coerced into that choice. If the only way to feed yourself, or your kid, is to lose a limb? Yeah. You’d rather not starve. Being desperate as f*ck doesn’t mean you
wanted to lose a limb, and if there was any other way under the sun you could conceive of to feed yourself or your kid? Hello arms and legs! No f*cking way in hell would you ever part with one... unless the alternative was even worse.
I think that when people say a tiny number of people willingly choose sex work, or variations thereof? They’re thinking of people forced into it, who go on to force others; or for whom they made the choice out of desperation, and found they liked it and preferred it over other work. Both of those groups
are tiny, compared to the masses inside that group of trafficked, coerced, and people with no other better choice. I think they’re forgetting, the entirely different group of people for whom it’s their chosen field, out of many good choices, or their avocation.
For anyone interested in the other side of the street? Maggie McNeil of
TheHonestCourtesan has compiled one whole heckuva lot of data from a helluva lot of sources, all linked & supported.
Frequently Told Lies
Safety in Numbers
Handy Figures Revisited
Numerology