Yes, go for it Abstract, I think that it's pretty clear that this isn't a linear journey for any of us.
I, personally, am in almost mute agreeance with pretty much everything being said here, even the comments that seem to contradict each other, such as those about the need for/against isolation. Therein lies a huge part of my struggle I think. Each healthy domain of my life brings sometimes deal-breaking negatives, so somehow, each choice I make hurts as it heals. Figuring out which way the scaels are, or should, ultimately tip, on these issues, is something that is so beyond me that it leaves me almost empty of words and ways to try to think about it.
Perhaps quite unsurprisingly, my initial enthusiasm for the Bradshaw book, based on his uncanny appraisal of toxic shame and how it forms and exists, has hit a terrible snag now that we've reached the "what to do about it" part. His strategies seem horrifying to me, and I'm not even quite able to articulate why yet. I will try though, perhaps on the shame thread... Somehow my scheming defeating little mind is busy convincing me that he's actually some sort of extremist zelot, or something...
Back to the issue of isolation and its impacts on my identity, I think that part of why I inevitably default back to isolating is that I just plain don't like the way I feel about myself when I am with people. That's not to say I am any happier, or less unhappy, when I am alone, but at least that I feel as though I have a more stable sense of who I am, and less conscious attention focused on the parts of me that I hate. Being around people shines a spotlight on everything that makes my skin crawl about myself, and even positive and safe interactions somehow reach in and squeeze parts of me that hurt more than I can, or want to, tolerate. I'm not sure why, or what to do about it.
Maddog