• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

My Boyfriend Is In The Military - But I'm The One With Ptsd

Status
Not open for further replies.

carharjo

New Here
A new chapter in my life began a year ago when I started seeing my boyfriend. I haven't had a stable relationship since my trauma(s). My three traumas are from when I witnessed my mother die - her heart stopped- and be brought back to life when I was 8, I had an emotionally and sexually abusive boyfriend in high school, and I am a survivor of a school shooting at my college when I was 17. Now I am 24 and finally embarking on a journey into relationship territory.

There's a catch though. He's in the military.
And I'm the one with PTSD? Yep. Uncharted territory! (Or at least for me it is).

First issue: Guns.

I grew up in a family that was whole-heartedly against guns. Born and half-raised in Montreal, Quebec - where guns are only for hunting and at that the laws are pretty strict. We moved to Arizona when I was 8 and my parents had to start asking my friends' parents if they had a gun in the house. If they did, I was not allowed over. Period. We participated in the Million Mom March against gun violence. We had lock down drills at school and my sister's high school was closed one day because of a kid who threatened to put sleeping gas in the AC system and shoot everyone while they were unconscious. Then, there was Columbine. I was only 10, but I understood what was happening. A couple years later, my family knew we had to move back to Canada to get away from all of the crime and violence. Everything was fine and dandy. Life was (for all intents and purposes) good.

September 13, 2006 I became a victim of a school shooting. My college in Montreal was the target of a mass shooting. I have had to deal with severe PTSD because of it. Because a guy wielding multiple semi-automatics tore my life apart. We moved away from that, didn't we? I thought I was safe.

Guns will never be safe for me. So why do I feel safe with my soldier boyfriend? This weekend he is away on course and he will be shooting live rounds. He is an expert marksman in the infantry and loves his job. He talks about having a gun rack one day, in his house. So why do I feel safe with my soldier boyfriend? Granted, when he says things like that I want to run in the opposite direction... but I think I trust him. I was saved by the brave men and women of the SPVM (Montreal police), and I trust that they have been trained on their weapons to do no harm - to protect and save the lives of the innocent. I trust the military to do the same. In some ways, I feel safe with my soldier, because I know he will protect me.

Nevertheless, there will always be a nagging thought at the back of my head that what if he turns into the bad guy? There are so many trained military personnel that snap one day, that have schizophrenic breaks and use their weapons for harm. It wouldn't even have to be his fault. I may trust him, but can I trust the gun?

Second issue: Military.

My family is also a very pacifist family. My parents do not believe in war. My mother once called all soldiers murders - in front of my soldier boyfriend. (He almost lost it). I know she didn't mean to call him a murderer, but she was expressing a sentiment that my WW2 veteran grandfather expressed to her. He also suffered from PTSD and used to abuse his family; my mother holds a great deal of pain from that. My mother does not understand why I am dating him.

I do, though - for the most part ;). I took conflict studies and human rights at university (although it was too emotionally difficult for me to finish; but that is a story for another day). I came at it with an open mind so as to really understand why conflicts arise and why people resort to violence. Not all of my questions were answered - nor do I think they can be. I used to admire the Tibetans for lasting for 300 years without a standing army, but unfortunately they were overrun by the Chinese and their beautiful peace was ruined, their culture decimated. I learned that standing armies are a necessary part of maintaining the safety of a nation. I still maintain that armies should not be used as an aggressive force, but solely for the purpose of self-defence. All that to say, I am okay with the idea of the military and their duties and functions.

There is another aspect to look at this with. He is a soldier, and I have PTSD. Of all people, a soldier could understand. Their fellow soldiers suffer all too often from PTSD. Sure, there are the soldiers who are of the mind to say "Suck it up, don't be weak." But I have found one who cares enough to try to understand. I know it scares him to see me when I am having a panic attack; he feels lost and helpless. He has said he will reach out to the resources he has at his disposal from the military (although it is clear in Canada that they are failing to reach out to suffering vets... but again, that is a rant for another day!) to learn about the disorder. One time we were at the regiment and I was starting to panic. He held me and told me that they are my family too, they will protect me. The comradery and solidarity that the military brings is now mine to protect me.

He wants to help, but he does not always know how. Luckily, I am at a part in my recovery that I am strong enough - for the most part - to help him help me.

--------

Does anyone have any advice for me? for him? I'd love and appreciate any kind of feedback on my situation.

Thank you all,
C.
 
Separate the person from the moral and ethical issues. Evaluate him as he is warts and all. Though your families position on weapons and pacifism could complicate a relationship for you, if his personal ideology and views are compatible with yours these could be negotiable.

A for instance was my budding relationship with the man who is now my spouse of 24 years. I had an absolute no guns policy in my home, but decided that provided he was a responsible hunter, lawful, and demonstrated time and consistency with honoring my wishes to stay in the relationship as he had many character qualities that were compatible with my own and we weren't just "in love" but very "simpatico" (nice, pleasant and congenial).

"What if he turns out to be a bad guy"? Only you can determine whether or not to accept the risk in continuing (as you called him your boyfriend, so you're already IN a relationship) the relationship with him. It looks to me like he has given no cause for alarm, by what you've posted, though again only you know all the facts here.

A plus in his favor is that he's interested in assisting and open to a relationship with you knowing you have PTSD, and he's teachable as you are "helping him help you".
 
Please just block me, @The Albatross, as you obviously have nothing nice to say to me (ever) other than directly addressing me to pick on my replies. I didn't say anything nasty, but you feel the need to play moderator, and really, mods don't even go to that extent!
 
I don't have the percentages or numbers in my head, but the majority of PTSD cases are not from the military.

That's part of the reason why it's called PTSD rather than battle fatigue or shell shock; they needed a more comprehensive term.

Welcome to the forum!
 
@carharjo - welcome to the forum. To answer your questions, I think, if you feel comfortable with this guy and your ethics are not being compromised, then it sounds great. He sounds, from what you say, that he is willing to try and understand your struggles with PTSD. Regardless of the statistics, yes, most people associate PTSD with the military, not that they always have a very good approach to it, but, as you say, that is another story.

Just keep monitoring your feelings for this guy and get to know him. If he gives you any cause for concern, as would be the case in any burgeoning relationship, then assess where you are at that stage. Your family is not dating him and should keep their opinions to themselves, though I know what families are like, having a father who likes routinely to devalue academics and teachers to their face - according to him they do no work - sigh! Apparently that is humour, but it fits with his other abusive tendencies, so I'm used to it. What is hard is when the family you know and love are not very circumspect with their views when dealing with others outside of the family network. But really it is your choice.

Trust your own instincts and communicate your needs around guns. I think it is entirely reasonable to insist that there should be no guns in your home if you should chose to live with, or marry, this man. He may well be perfectly happy to compromise at that stage for love of you. If he won't respect that, then the possibility of triggering for you would be considerable, I should have thought, but only you can tell.
 
I dunno - my gut feeling, is when we have PTSD and are not well with it, it can be very very hit and miss as to picking a 'right' match partner for us. I read a lot of relationship threads on here, and I really do struggle to understand how any of them 'work' if one or both people have PTSD at the time they began dating….

I know there's always exception to the rule - but I just think of how intense it is for me when I'm struggling with symptoms, and having or being in a relationship when I'm sick with this would be the furthest thing from my mind. Healthy relationships needs equally healthy partners within them for it to work. If 'we' have unresolved trauma, I just don't see how 'we' can possibly be all we are 'meant' to be in what we can offer another person (while we are in the depths of the PTSD).

I don't think 'we' can make our best decisions when in the depths of PTSD - and given our perceptions of things and people can be distorted, I'm willing to bet many of us in early treatment and recovery for PTSD will even attract a 'healthy' person to be in a relationship with.

When I was in recovery with my drinking problem, it was reiterated to me 'don't have a relationship for at least two years of sobriety' because my focus needed to be on getting well, and forming the most important relationship of all - the one with myself.

Bottom line - I personally think beginning any relationship is a risk it might not end out well and we could get hurt emotionally - but I think if you add PTSD to the mix, especially when we're very early in recovery from it, I think the likelihood of it not working out / being brought with difficulties, would be SO much higher.
 
Carharjo. I think maybe because you have a sense of gratitude to police because of what you experienced - I have read all your postings and thanks for replying to mine - that the feeling of safety you expereinced has become a powerful emotional bond. I think it might be psychologically dangerous for you to be in a relationship on that basis. Whether any relationship is a good thing now or not I am not qualified to judge but little alarm bells are going off with me about this one. If he is posted overseas he will in all likelihood come back with serious PTSD. Do you want to be his future therapist?

I was in a relationship with a man who claimed to have military experience and PTSD - it was hard to know what was true - for sure he had been abused as a child. I became a sort of live-in therapist. My whole family is still suffering because of the time I spent with this man. I am still having dreams about him and I see him around the neighborhood. I am not threatened by him - he is more afraid of me and avoids places where I maight be. It is a weird dynamic.

I think it might be helpful for you to read a bit about stockholm symdrome and read about Patty Hearst who married her prison guard or something - after she had had a relationship on the run before her arrest and imprisonment. I can understand that you feel a powerful emotional attraction to someone who is lke your past rescuer. But this could backfire on you. If not having guns around is part of your upbringing then you have to consider your older deeper values. My suggestion - wait a bit before getting involved with someone - then find a guy who is playful and only wants to play with non-lethal paint guns or water guns or something. Someone who can listen to what you went through in real life and slow down if even this gets too intense. I think anyone with real guns is way too complicated for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom