• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Poll Sufferers, Which Family Role Were You In The Most?

Which role were you the most in your family?

  • the hero or family caretaker

    Votes: 18 34.0%
  • the enabler

    Votes: 2 3.8%
  • the scapegoat and/or identified patient

    Votes: 28 52.8%
  • the codependent

    Votes: 5 9.4%
  • the lost child/loner

    Votes: 25 47.2%
  • the doer

    Votes: 11 20.8%
  • the mascot

    Votes: 4 7.5%
  • the manipulator

    Votes: 1 1.9%
  • the critic

    Votes: 2 3.8%
  • the saint / golden child / parent's little princess or prince

    Votes: 11 20.8%

  • Total voters
    53
Status
Not open for further replies.

Justmehere

Sponsor
In dysfunctional families, it's common for people to take on different roles. This happens in groups of people under severe stress. It's a way humans cope with things they don't have the skills to handle in a healthier manner.

There's the caretaker, the bystander, the scapegoat... There are lots of articles about this phenomenon online. Some simplify the roles to perp, victim, scapegoat, and caretaker. Other models expand upon variations of those roles.

One article about those roles is here: Dysfunctional Family Rules and Roles | Smoky Rain Counseling Services It explains the possible roles in this poll. (I have combined the last two options as one option.)

There are many theories about why people fall into these roles, and much that is unknown about it. However, it's a pretty predictable pattern in dysfunctional families that they fall into these roles. Functional families will have flexibility and don't fall into these roles much at all.

If you are a sufferer what role(s) do you happen to fall into the most in your family system? Pick 1-3 choices, but no more than 3.

For this purposes of this particular poll, I'm seeking responses from anyone who has PTSD from any type of trauma.
 
Troublemaker, here! AKA Scapegoat*.

Functional families will have flexibility and don't fall into these roles much at all.

I'd have to challenge that a bit. It's less that functional families don't have roles/schemas (they do), it's more that they're both more fluid and the consequences aren't as severe. Like functional families have fights, punish their kids, neglect their responsibilities... But the scope is drastically different. Like mom/dad is sick and the kids run wild for a day. Or it's a busy morning and no one gets breakfast.

*
Or in my case? If anything went wrong without a clear culprit? Fridaaaaaaaaaaaay! (To be fair, I usually had a hand in whatever went wrong. It took me years to learn to hide the evidence of my misadventures.) I was the kid who was always breaking shit, always jumping off the roof, always getting brought back home by shore patrol covered in dust/mud/bits of jungle (jungle is sticky), always flirting with the sailors, always taking shit apart (and not putting it back together), always coming up with "better" ways to clean (come to find hardwood doesn't like water. I was like, 8. And the sponge shoes, for the record, worked awesome. In retrospect I should have staple gunned my own shoes, instead of my dads. But his were so much bigger, I figured they'd be more effective), always falling into whatever body of water was nearby, always taking a bat and my cleats when I went after people bigger than me, always cheering for the driver (motorbike) to jump the hill (I wasn't supposed to be using the dirt bikes or motorcycles, but if someone else was driving I figured I wasn't "using" them, so much as being ballast), always splitting hairs, always up past my bedtime, always finding the Xmas presents (and sometimes exchanging them before they were given, because it would be rude to exchange something afterward), always getting into people's love letters, always seeing if I would "fit" in the air ducts, always bringing home strays, always climbing shit I shouldn't be (including a few churches, which apparently, is "worse" than other buildings?), always asking bizarre questions in public (is this building now, or has it ever been, a church?), always coming home with grass stains and ripped up jeans, always the kid with the note pinned to their shirt (waaaaay past kindergartn), always forgetting my homework (done) or frantically searching for the (incomplete) homework I thought I'd done (and then accusing people of erasing it, or declaring it the "wrong" one, nope, just forgot it / had meant to do it so thought it was, when it wasn't), always playing my music too loud, always walking off with the lights still on (I turned the stove off! Sheesh!), always sent to the principals office, always getting As on my tests & projects and Fs on my report cards (how is that even possible? Homework. Homework is my enemy.), always carrying frogs -and other slimy things that my mom hated to find in the wash when she reached her hand in- in my pockets, always deciding thermite was the chemistry project to do instead of rock candy (to be fair I never blew up the chemistry trailer. I did, however, melt it a bit. And the aluminum dust didn't actually catch it on fire. It was just scorched. The so-called claims of my blowing up the chemistry trailer -twice- are gross exaggerations, perpetuated by my brother at thanksgiving, to deflect from his actual blowing up of the chemistry trailer).

So it's not entirely unreasonable that if the people delivering the curtains say they were told beige was the wrong color, and to come back with red? That they'd look to me (my SISTER'S favorite color is red... And she was also the family forger. I never forged a note from home. That was all her. Sadly, I just never thought that far ahead). Or if my dad slept through his alarm? That their first thought wouldn't be "Power went out" but that I might have had a hand in it (almost never). So there are a few things that no rational person would blame a child for... That I got blamed for. But mostly, we're talking "drive your parents nuts" stories. And after 10,000 -very clearly my fault- items in a week, it's hardly insane that 10,001 & 10,002 also landed at my doorstep. Even if you could have found a picture of me in the dictionary next to "affronted".

Does any of the above read like abuse? Nope.

What's even less like abuse? My being punished for what went wrong. Whether I had a hand in it, or it was someone else's actions I was being punished for. I've been sworn at maybe three times in my life by my parents? (Not a single day went by in my memory I wasn't in trouble at least once). Spanked, sure. Hit? Nope. Ditto never beaten, kicked, whipped, humiliated, starved, choked, tied up, locked up/locked in. <<< All things my son has been (by his dad, not me... for such "crimes" as dropping a fork, or my ex losing a job??? FFS in what universe does either rate the other? Not one. Because nothing rates that shit, much less noooooormal accidents, and shit completely not in my son's control.) . Grounded, often. (Although my mom considers that punishing herself, and avoided it whenever possible.) Privileges revoked. Not needs.

I left home at 17. To this day (almost 20 years later) my parents still blame me for shit. :rolleyes: Whether or not I'm on the same dang continent as they are. Whether or not they're actively yelling at someone else (my name just slips out of their mouth, and the person on front of them looks confused). Family scapegoat? Cha. What people from abusive or severely dysfunctional families mean when they say scapegoat? Not even the same durn universe. Scope & Consequences. Vastly different.
 
I was the keeper of the true life and bearer of tthe unblinking eye on the reality that surrounded us.

Mother died, father remarried within 4 months into basically an arranged marriage through the church my mother had returned to briefly before her death, and I suddenly had to live an existence that was totally foreign to anything have been exposed to before or since. I have never seen such parental narcissism as the special type these two perfected, they controlled everything, and when they couldn't control my beliefs they controlled my freedom. I was always the one that questioned everything, Mr. lack of faith and the designated non kool-aid drinker in the family. I know now that they hated me because I reminded them of their inability to cope in a real world, clinging to their archaic and misguided beliefs and their almost total separation from the society around them.
Example: They only allowed us to watch happy days and little house on the prairie and the Waltons, because those shows most closely resembled their ideal reality. I was the one that refused to watch anything on the television if all we could watch was based on fictional depictions of family perfection. I was sent to my room where I read books.

I was the fly in the holy ointment. If there is a hell it waits for them, not me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom