• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

What Do You Talk About?

Status
Not open for further replies.
@Notsowild I'm not sure what you mean. You mean the difference of if I saw a male therapist instead of a female therapist? I chose to see a female T because my childhood trauma happened at the hands of a male abuser. If I was seeing a male T, the sessions themselves would be a trigger :(
 
Yes that's what I mean. I have a male T and I feel a strange connection with him which is strange because I am child sexual abuse survivor too. I'm usually scared of men too. So it's all pretty confusing ?
 
I can understand and relate to how it's confusing. I think everyone's different, and we are going to "jive" differently with different people we meet. I've had/have multiple male figures in my life (bosses, doctors, trainers, etc) who I'm fine with. However, without going into too much detail, there are too many aspects of the therapeutic relationship and the sessions themselves w/ a male T that would be very triggering and anxiety inducing.
 
Well, as I said, I think everyone is different. I know for me personally, I'm choosing to work through my distrust in men by talking about it with my female T. We're all going to work through things differently though. If you feel like you have a connection with your male T, then that's great. Maybe bring up to him your confusing feelings and worry of getting too attached? It may give you some piece of mind :)
 
So what would be the difference with a female with a male T?
.

That would completely depend on the type of transference and previous issues the person had.

For someone whose mother was abusive / absent and did not have their needs meet via their mother grown up, then it is more liiley they would experience transference with a female figure (be it a T, friend, female lover etc). If the person felt neglected by a father figure, and / or abused by a male, then the dynamics with a male T would make transference more likely in that scenario.

I don't think the point is to 'avoid' it - if you know you might end up having transference feelings for a female T, then seeing a male T and not having transference experience would still mean you potentially have a lot of unresolved issues despite all the therapy with the male T. I think its part of the reason we sometimes need to change Ts - we do work with on,e get so fr, then find changing is the best thing, so we can continue on with another T, and explore different issues.

Erotic transference can happen with a male or female T - regardless of sexual orientation. Again, that depends on the issues / pevious experiences a person has if it will happen or not. A male client might develop erotic transference for a male T, even if that male client is not gay, never has been nor ever will be. Same with female clients and female Ts - regardless of if you are lesbian or not. Why? because erotic transference is not about sex, it's about power and need. How the 'sexual' part comes into it is instead of fearing the other person and the power they have over us (face it, Ts do had power over us, even though most won't use it against us, it is still there!), we create in our minds, a fantasy where we have power over them - to have them 'fall' for us, or to 'have sex' with us, demonstrates we have had enough poet to 'make them' break very strong professional boundaries. We have the power to have them 'weak at the knees', wanting us'. While many people fantasize about sexual relationships with a T, we know it is purely fantasy and would be MORTIFIED if it actually happened. Of course, there are some exceptions to this - some people totally believe what they feel is 'real' and 'reciprocated' and spend all their time and energy trying to seduce their T, because they do not see it as transference, but as 'real'.

Even if a female had never been abused by a T, had a positive relationship with her father etc, she could still develop erotic transference for a male (or female) T.

The key things is - the feelings we put onto a therapist are transference. A good T will remain a 'blank slate' - not divulge anything about themselves or their home / personal lives. It's a part of good therapy, in that the more a 'blank slate' they are, the more likely our relationship and feelings towards them, will more accurately reflect our deepest issues and the things we need most to heal from.

One sample being, if you had a female T for whom you had feelings of her wanting to 'mother you' - that is more likely to come up as an issue if you didn't know she did not have her own children or had no desire to ever be a mother. Or, at the outset your male T said they were gay and in a long term relationship with their male partner - it wouldn't necessarily stop transference towards him and you wanting him to be your husband, but it might make the transference less powerful than it might have otherwise been.
 
But can you not work through your distrust of men that way?
I guess I don't understand if you were abused by males that you would be treated by men. I'm not saying you are wrong. Far be it to me to say I know anything about this stuff...but I'm just saying what I feel. I am new to all this crap. I don't feel comfortable around men despite the fact I have been in all male dominated jobs for the past 15 years. I am just trying to figure things out myself.

So if you are abused by men, do you feel ok talking to male therapists? Do you interact with them and discuss what happened to you in detail? I'm just curious, so maybe I could try it sometime if my stuff doesn't work. I am really afraid right now, but you never know.

I wonder if women know how dangerous men are. Men know the viciousness they can show. They realize how dangerous they can be. I wonder how many women really process how dangerous men really are to them.
 
This is a really interesting thread. My question would be: Say you have a history of CSA by a male you and as a result you are simply more aware of the fact that men can and do sexually assault women. The news every single day reinforces that that is a fact. So if you were to see a male T and be very, very cautious about the fact that he could be a predator and you were frightened by any sudden movements he made, would you be experiencing transference or simply hyperaware of a statistically legitimate risk?

I guess I don't understand if you were abused by males that you would be treated by men. I'm not saying you are wrong. Far be it to me to say I know anything about this stuff...but I'm just saying what I feel. I am new to all this crap. I don't feel comfortable around men despite the fact I have been in all male dominated jobs for the past 15 years. I am just trying to figure things out myself.

idk. I do know that after 5 years with a female trauma specialist I felt like the biggest issue left for me to work on was a significant fear of men, and that was something I could talk about with her, but never really work through, so I got a referral to a male T. He seems nice but I'm terrified of him. I'm just hoping / feel like if I could have one significant, safe relationship with a man it might help me live more normally.
 
@xena21... So far I like having a male T. I was a little nervous at our first meeting. But he's easy going and I feel safe with him. I wouldn't want him touching me or getting too close. We don't talk too much about my CSA. We are dealing with the issues involving my car accident. But of course the CSA always slips into the conversation. I don't really think about him being a man ( or try not to) I think of him as my therapist. And he is doing a great job with my therapy.

@Sarah2732.... How long have you had your male T ?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom