• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Does Talking About "It" Help?

Status
Not open for further replies.

SGT Bilko

Bronze Member
My doctor says i need to start going to Iraq/Afhgan vet groups to talk about the things I did over seas. Its almost an unwritten law that you just don't talk about it. So i don't know what i'm feeling. Im getting all stressed out eventhinking about going to group and talking about it. She says its the only way to get better.
 
Sgt,

I don't know if talking about it will heal or not help heal you. I know that similar to trauma survivors, you have that rule as well. You simply don't talk about it. Its secret. If you reveal the secret, you'll get hurt etc.

I have found the more I can connect with others however, the better I seem to be able to heal due to that support. It may be worth a shot :)
 
sgt,

Actually this is the basis that Anthony formed this website on.....To talk about your trauma. To rip it apart, to feel it, go through it all over again.

It's what I did in therapy 15 years ago, and still do here on the forum. IMO, you have to desensitize yourself to *your* trauma in order to be able to heal, and to maintain yourself at a level that you can function pretty much symptom free.......

Yes, we all have set backs and that's when you dig deep for your inner strength, and the coping techniques that you have learned and you apply them again in order to maintain an even keel again.....

So, yes talking/writing about it, IS the only way to do this...You have to go THROUGH your trama to get better. There is no way around it....
 
For myself, I think of the saying, "You're only as sick as your sickest secrets".

When they are brought out into the open, even to one person, I find that they lose the power to effect and control me the same way.
Sort of like, kicking them to the curb.

Great thing is SGT, anyone in a support group knows exactly how you feel, because that's likely how they felt, too, at first. But when things are shared and maintained in confidence, the environment becomes safe enough to say what is in your mind and heart.
And, no rush, you can go at your own pace.
 
When they are brought out into the open, even to one person, I find that they lose the power to effect and control me the same way.

This has been true for me as well. Being able to talk about my traumas has helped me reduce the shame I feel about them and the feelings that I am disgusting/worthless/whatever. Getting it all out in the open with someone who didn't react with fear, anger, or disgust has helped more than anything else.
 
kers and Junebug, I totally agree with you two. And the others who spoke up too. I just arrived on this website very recently. SGT—After rounds of CBT and DBT, different kinds of therapy, still in therapy, on medication... Well...It does much more good when you have a group of people with whom you can be frank and honest and open. I think most of us have a lot of common no matter what the original trauma was. From what I've experienced so far, your voice will be held true and valid, and people will respect you.
 
Talking about it might help. But, I don't have any good experience in this matter. My "Doc" tried to get me into an all girl group, but the other women in the group didn't have anything in common with me. Nothing, na-da. Yeah, they were trama survivors. But, their trama wasn't even remotely military related. Further, they weren't even taking physical care of their personal problems. I felt like I was on "The View" on TV. Talking with vets who have been in the same type of situations might help.
 
I have not been through an experience like yours, but I know that I live with most of myself held in secret. People can only see the tip of the iceberg. The rest of the iceberg, deep into the sea, is where the trauma is.

I think it is important to speak about the trauma. Until we do that, we hold it inside where it can continue to have power over us.
 
I've talked about my trauma inside and out

I'll tell you something if you want to heal from your trauma talking about it only goes so far. In some cases it can burn you out or bring stuff up that will make you feel like you're reliving your trauma. I'd like to say getting the trauma out in the open and finding a community of people or some kind of support system is very important. But when talking doesn't help then you have to find something that will because trauma is mind and body related, some times its working on the physical parts of yourself to heal the mental part of yourself. Some times talking doesn't neccesarily help you release the trauma and extract it from your body. The healing process of trauma takes different step from what I've learned. The first step is facing the trauma and being aware of the problem, the second step is getting help which means turning to people, the third step is discharge getting rid of the traumas power and taking your life back. I mean there are many steps this is just general for how I've healed in my past. Letting your self be open to possibilities whether it be intense one on one therapy, a group, religion, spirituality what ever you thing might ease your suffering or begin the healing proccess I say go for it. One thing I learned is you have to let go of yourself inorder to rediscover who you are. It means you start at the bottom of a hill to get back up on the top of the mountain. Honestly everything I said is whack unless it sounds good to you then take what you want and leave the rest. Your the only one who really knows the answer to your health and wellbeing!:smile:
 
Talking about the trauma definitely made my symptoms worse for a time. But I was working closely with a doctor twice a week doing EMDR and brain spotting. She gave me a bilateral CD, the same one I was getting conditioned to respond to in her office and when the time was right explained some of what I could do at home when I found myself in "the thick" of some PTSD memories (you know: flashbacks, intrusive thoughts or awoken by nightmares).

It's been a helluva long six months for me. I was telling my wife that the timing of my diagnosis was uncannily convenient actually. It was probably the first time in my life that we were in a position where I could voluntarily put work aside, be supported by her, have health care and was final-freakin'-ly ready to deal with all the ghosts of my childhood and teen years.

I've now moved into the next phase of my recovery where we are beginning to engage a few CBT methods (formally and informally I suppose). It's about life management and new habits. I see a distant light at the end of the tunnel. And I know that if I reach that light, I will be better, healthier, more balanced and most importantly more at peace than I have been my entire life. Cured? I don't know. I'll leave it to others to debate the semantics of cure and recovery. All I know is I am on a road to health. And it feels great in a broad, stable sort of way (not a topsy-turvey manic high!).

But I've got to tell you, I wouldn't where I am on this road to health had I not gone through the hellish months of talking about my problems and reintigrating those things back into my life.

Sarge, I'm sure while on your tours, you saw some terrible stuff that ideally no man or woman should ever have to endure. You probably were forced to make some decisions where you were chosing the best of the worst and only options available. You may have even done things that everything in life before you became a soldier taught you were terrible things no person should ever do to another. I bet you are suffering inside terrible senses of loss: loss of those you may have loved or liked, loss of your own innocence, loss of your sense of who you were before you went to war. But like so many trauma survivors, remember you did the very best you could with what you had available at the time.

And now as a soldier/citizen and veteran, if you have one duty left it is to work your way back to health, as frightening as it may be to take those steps. Be good to yourself. Make sure you have a proper support network in place, diverse and broad. Your doctor's suggestion of vet support groups sounds like a good one. Consider it another spoke in your hub. Between such a group, your doctor and here even (the trauma diaries section, public or private) you can then take that first step and begin to talk or write about it. Remembering can be devastating, but you can with guidance and help make it through the other side. And trust me, the air is a lot easier to breathe on this side of that tunnel.

You are a good man. You deserve health. :Hug_emoticon:
 
azrael,

That's not always the case. If you read my post, I've been in a lots of different therapies and more. I've been IP, OP. I had a man walk into group with a gun (He was a former corrections officer). But one of the things that helped me the most was going on forums like this one and being able to "talk" to people i *don't* know from anywhere and everywhere. Soldiers have it kinda hard imo. My uncle spent a round in Kuwait and 2 in Iraq. Now, he's infatuated with guns. Go Figure. I'd rather give SGT the benefit of the doubt and if he needs to start here, well then, he needs to start here.

Just a Thought
S.
 
It will help its better than just leaving it in your head you have to get it out. The group would be good for you, it sounds bad but you wolnt be the only one talking. You can hang back and just be polite and hear where theyre coming from probably around the same place your at. for me I can talk about it once to a person for the First time just so they no where I'm coming from and know where I'm at. And I ussally only talk about it when I'm asked (could be a problem) and I talk about it only for how long I'm comfortable talking but I don't leave it awkward ussally change the subject or ask if they have advice answer the questions. You could get some freinds that share your intrests.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom