• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

News Breastfeeding In Public?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Infants who are birthed naturally, held, nursed on demand, and otherwise have their needs met at an early age generally grow up with the kind of emotional strength and resilience that makes them strong, healthy members of society, the kinds of people the world desperately needs more of. Even if I did find it offensive to see them nursing (I don't) I would swallow my objections in the interest of supporting what I see as a positive act. Any support I can give mothers and children, I give, whether it is just a smile or an offer to help load groceries so a mother can deal with a screaming toddler, or chatting with a talkative four year old. It's just part of the ever-widening circles of building strong human beings leading to building strong communities leading to building a strong world. There are some bigger ways of participating that I don't feel ready for because of my own problems, but I can contribute in these small ways, and though I never thought about it until now because it never occurred to me that a nursing infant would be a problem, I realize this is part of the same deal. It's a political act.
 
It's a deep seated issue in society. It's the way we have been cultivated. If you see a baby=not sexual. You see a boob=sexual. Both are okay in their own little images. But if people see both together, people get uncomfortable. They can't seem to separate the sexuality of breasts to other functions. I find this incredibly stupid. Let me explain before you get all upset. People need to see that there are more functions to the breast than just sex. There are multiple parts of the body used for both sexual pleasure AND other functions. For example: the mouth. You use it to eat, to talk, but also for kissing and other pleasures. Why is it we can separate those but not the breast? Society has put so much emphasis on the sexuality of the breast than the function of it, that we can't see the separation there when we see an innocent baby attached to a sexual object. That is the reason for the upset. I just wish that when people do see it, they understand that it's a place of food for the infant. That is all. Just as if you saw someone else eating a hamburger, you wouldn't correlate that to kissing (or the like). Neck, feet, hands, mouth, legs, etc....all are the same deal.

I am passionate about breastfeeding. I would be one of those mothers during the nurse in. I have been told to cover up. I've been told to nurse else where in so many words. All of that is wrong. The issue does not lie with the mother or the baby. It lies with the person that is upset with it. Evaluate why you feel this way and change your perceptions. Because it is causing many nursing mothers to feel they have to stay home. Or feed a baby in a bathroom...because of your thoughts. Most moms are thinking while nursing, "I love my baby. Here you go...time to eat. I love you. Is that better?" Nothing sexual about it. But they cover up just in case someone thinks it is. See the issue?

On a more personal level with having to do with childhood sexual abuse: I have a friend that refuses to nurse because it reminded her too much of her past abuse so she bottle feeds. It's a personal decision. My breastfeeding experience did not cause to stir those memories. However, being sneered at or being compared to a molester caused me undo stress. One that a new mother does not need. Mothers, please nurse in public. Please do not cover up. We do not need to change. Society does.
 
I'd like to add that this isn't like other things which are a matter of OPINION ie abortion. This is a matter of comfort level so it's a bit rude to tell someone that their uneasiness or uncomfortableness is wrong. It is a feeling and as such feelings aren't wrong. Wouldn't you be uncomfortable if you were forced to watch an abortion or bj? Similar deal, I FEEL uncomfortable when it's in my face.

Breasts ARE sexual and nobody is ever going to convince me otherwise considering that Uhm, yes, let's just say that's the fastest way to turn me on. Maybe other women aren't that sensitive if they can honestly say they're just hunks of fat flapping in the wind with no sexual element? Can you not see that it's not breastFEEDING but the breasts themselves that make people uncomfortable?

I think I kinda pity women who say that breasts aren't sexual b/c OMFG you have no idea what you're missing out on.... (Yeah, I think I just went there...)
 
My breasts are not very sexual for me. Thank the years of abuse.

Abortion isn't just about "opinions". It is about people being able to choose when and how to have children. That's not just an opinion. That is life planning.

If you do not breastfeed your child you are choosing to feed them food that is less nutritionally appropriate. You are choosing to not give your kids the autoimmune boost they really need to have. Breastfeeding isn't just about "opinions"; it is a normal biological process. Your choice to WATCH or not is a choice. The science behind breastfeeding is solid. The issues with it are recent, cultural, and kind of ridiculous.

Your comfort level should not trump my child's ability to eat a normal diet. Sorry. I don't think that my rudeness about people saying my kid should have to eat in the bathroom trumps the rudeness that people think my kids should have to eat in the damn bathroom. Unless and until you eat all your meals there, your feelings are not somehow more worthy of consideration.
 
We see breasts all the time. That isn't the issue. Go to a local pool and you'll see more breast tissue than most people would like to. Open a catalog or magazine. It is the baby on the breast that offends people. The older the baby gets, the more offensive it seems.

I'm not saying that breasts aren't sexual. For sure they are! So are other body parts!

You are entitled to your feelings and opinions. For sure. But they can change with more knowledge. Think and research a little bit.

Something that many people that don't breastfeed that have a hard time understanding is how much LOVE flows between mom and baby during breastfeeding. There is science backing this up too. It is something that should be valued. It solidifies the care giver role and that she is the one to come to for anything. It makes the baby feel secure so they may thrive. It lowers their stress levels. There are so many positives that I just can't believe that some people would NOT do it just because it makes someone else feel uncomfortable. I understand personal choices, but please, make sure they are for your own personal reasons, not for someone else's feelings.
 
Oxytocin flows when you breastfeed. That's the bonding mechanism/hormone in our brains. Without breastfeeding it is harder to bond. (Obviously not impossible because millions of loving mothers bottle feed.) But given that I have massive attachment issues and it is very hard for me to form relationships with people... I'm going to go with the natural drug assist.
 
I struggled with breast feeding because of my abuse and I struggled seeing women breastfeeding...but I know these are my issues so I have never said anything.

What is interesting is that having been a mother for over a decade now, and having been exposed regularly to breastfeeding mothers, I have noticed that my comfort has increased. This makes me think that if we lifted the taboo, people would actually become more comfortable.
 
Also....my first would not feed if they were covered so (because of my issues) I didn't feed in public.

Once I needed to be out and so I had a bottle prepared with my breast milk. While feeding I had a person come up and lecture me on "breast is best" .... All I could think is - you are damned if you do, and damned if you don't.
 
May I ask what it is that is offensive/upsetting/disturbing about breastfeeding?
for me - the op- who started this post it is the fact that my perpetrator tried to do 'pretend ' breast feeding from me as a teenager. It was a part of my abuse. that is why it is such a big deal. I have tried hard to work with it because I understand my issues are not the norm, I do wish all infants to have the benefit of breastfeeding - but I would also like some adults to understand why it hurts me so much.

and this is why this post was started in 'childhood' and not somewhere else.
 
for me - the op- who started this post it is the fact that my perpetrator tried to do 'pretend ' breast feeding from me as a teenager. It was a part of my abuse. that is why it is such a big deal. I have tried hard to work with it because I understand my issues are not the norm, I do wish all infants to have the benefit of breastfeeding - but I would also like some adults to understand why it hurts me so much.

@Lucycat I think it is *totally fair* that you want people to understand why seeing breastfeeding hurts you. That makes a lot of sense. If someone abused you in this way it would probably be more abnormal if you had no lasting hangups. I'm really sorry. That shouldn't have happened to you.

I'm terribly sorry that someone took something "normal" and "natural" and made it repugnant to you. Abusers can really do lasting damage. It completely makes sense that you are sensitive around this issue. If you ever do have kids and you can't breastfeed because of these issues, please know that you are still a good mother. I'm rabidly pro-breastfeeding, but I understand that people are complicated. You have to make the choices that are right *for you*. And for some people breastfeeding isn't possible for physical, psychological, or situational reasons. There is no shame in doing your best, even if your best isn't THE BEST!!!!! (there is no such thing.)

Breastfeeding is biologically normal and not doing it can be somewhat problematic. Breastfeeding when it is emotionally distressing to the mother is FAR MORE problematic and should never ever be encouraged. It's a dyad relationship. It must work for both or it isn't working and you need to try something else. Thank goodness we live in a time when formula is such a readily available option.

I'm not trying to make you feel bad for having your feelings. They are your feelings and you get to have them. I'm still going to defend the act of breastfeeding. :)
 
@rightkindofme thank you for your words. Sadly for me - I had to add infertility into the mix. I am now 50 so no it will never happen, but I always wished for the opportunity to try. Now that I am 'old' it seems like the understanding has gone and I am expected to stick up for today's youngsters and ignore my own hurt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom