You can apply this to people as simple as AA... 20 years on and they're still in an AA meeting, stuck. They won't make a choice to let go and walk a path, make a path for themselves, and accept their behaviour. Instead they need to be recognised and part of something that is destructive after a certain point of healing, yet deny that, and refuse to let go
OUCH, broad paintbrush in hand I see.
This is only my opinion from what I have observed in numerous rooms and based on what I think is human nature as I think I start to see bits and pieces of the same here, as well illustrated by this thread.(Just so you know I'm not a big AA guru, I spent lot of time in the rooms, saw wonderful things and saw problems just as with any other group of human beings. I spend less time in the rooms of AA now, not because I don't see its value but because I moved my time for such to a different step based program, Celebrate Recovery if it makes any difference)
You will see those that have maintained sobriety but stay because they remain in the same behavior patterns and they find comfort in those patterns. The classic dry drunk. Many times they are the person MOST forefront in telling the newcomer still struggling "how to do it" and that their way is the "only way to do it", they are consummately adept at manipulating the Big Book to their own means. Don't challenge them, because your opinions, interpretation, experience is clearly inferior to their own. Its there way or no way and you will get a huge dose of defensiveness if they feel challenged in the least, their authority is supreme cause they view themselves as recovered.
You will also find the people that even after 20 years and successful recovery will spend their time and energy in the rooms. Why? Because they are stuck? I don't think so. Many are there genuinely because they are trying to carry out the 12th step and 5th tradition...carrying the message.
A few years ago when I left a wonderful wonderful treatment program that was trauma centered they gave me an after-care plan. First thing on it was within 24 hours to attend an AA meeting. Why? Prior to treatment I had been abusing alcohol to numb and one of their main thoughts was "alcohol is but a symptom but so long as reliance on abusing substances happens it blocks further progress". So I did what I was told. Let me tell you over the next few weeks of being in the "rooms" daily I discovered some sick people. Much like any gathering of people. Nevertheless I stuck it out, and began to notice people that "had what I wanted". When they spoke there was just something there...serenity perhaps. I began to talk to a few of them and thank God I did.
One became a wonderful friend and supporter and coach and sounding board.......
He was NOT in the rooms 25 years later because he was stuck or because he needed some sort of recognition. He was there to share his experience, strength and hope just as someone had done for him years earlier. If all those that find their way in a healthy manner leave the rooms, or a forum, or support groups....who is there to pass it on? There should be more angels. I am blessed daily that those angels were "stuck" in the rooms. Imagine a newcomer meeting only newcomers to help them and guide them.
I said in an earlier post this thread seems to have just gone defensive and everyone in their corner defending unknown positions. Perhaps we need to apply a little principals before personalities.