Cate, I totally understand what you are feeling and going through as I will be having a similar conversation tonight. My (ex) boyfriend and I have been broken up for 5 weeks now - we still talk, have seen each other and text and he hasn't gone out on any dates with other women yet. He claims he doesn't want to - but he still has an active dating profile online. Again, like you said, he has done nothing wrong as we are technically broken up. He has even encouraged me to move on, yet there is still this connection. He wants me to move on because he feels broken and unworthy. He feels he is pulling me down and I can do better than him. I've tried to explain to him that our relationship is not a dictatorship - that I know what my needs and wants are and I was quite happy with "us" exactly how we were.
I wrote a big long letter to him which explained my feelings, my thinking on the matter and what my expectations are for my relationships. I was nice, but I was blunt too. I asked him a few days later if he wanted to talk about my letter or not. He said yes. He could have very easily said no and then that would be that. I'd have my closure and he could be done with me. But he said yes and suggested we speak tonight. So, he appears willing to discuss us and I will feel it out more tonight, but if that is the case then the dating profiles need to be removed until our "grayness" is gone. I won't be an option. Either he figures it out and we move forward together, or we both move on - but its disrespectful to me for him to be looking for other women if we are still on the table.
We do love each other and really did have a great 3 year relationship - his PTSD/TBI is causing stress and confusion in his life and has put a halt to "us" for the moment. This issue is nothing with "us" together, and it is nothing with me as a girlfriend. It is totally him and his mental health/state of mind at this moment. Why can't life be easy?!? :confused: