• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Mentally Disabled Siblings, Can Anyone Relate?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah, there ya go. Not all read all the posts. I just happen to be bored lol. So i think folk...

Yes, I read all of the posts and I'm a bit disturbed that you believe that your siblings would have had an excuse for what they did if they were mentally disabled. You wish your siblings were mentally challenged because then they'd have an excuse for being ass-holes? I responded to Chava as I believe she was responding to you, not the poster of this thread (in the bit that I quoted). The comparisons drawn just don't sit well with me, that's all.
 
I think the issue is that "f*cktard" is derived from "retard" on top of a connection being drawn wherein "If my siblings were disabled, they would have some explanation for being awful."

I'm looking forward to watching this movie. I looked it up; it looks fabulous. I work with people who are developmentally disabled. I love my job immensely, but I can only imagine the kinds of challenges faced by siblings, especially younger ones, trying to cope with the behaviors that sometimes accompany developmental disabilities.
 
its a great movie. I was so scared of him. I feel like an arsehole because I get freaked out by disabled people. I was made to go to his home for visits & Christmas... where there was 4 or 5 of them... I couldn't deal with it. I just found a corner & stood with my back to the wall & froze. the worst was no one took me aside & asked me if I understood he couldn't control his actions. all I had to do was say his name & he would punch me in the face. then he would be comforted not me. I thought I was the bad one.
 
Australian slang.....
just shorten to "Tard" which I use when refering to myself alot.... If I do something silly I will just say Tard Power!
its not very PC but if I cant make fun of my abuser or some situations I would go crazy
 
I did not take offence to it at all. I dont think there was any true meaning in it. just a joke. I very much doubt they believe such at all.
it honestly sounded like something I would say.
 
Sibling abuse gets very little attention. The particular 'disability' is irrelevant. Parents routinely fail to protect kids against siblings. Mine was a reborn Christian who did enormous damage while traveling the 'moral high ground'. It took a court order to get her the f*ck out my life. @Kimberley, I can imagine how difficult it must be to have an abuser and royal game wrapped into one.
 
I'm just wondering if anyone has had a similar experience?
living with a mentally disabled brother from birth to 12. he was my abuser, so wondered if anyone can relate. especially with not understanding that he had no control over his actions or parents ignoring the clear damage caused.

there are also extremely odd things that only people living with this kinda thing would relate.
ie, trying to have friends over but your naked 17 yr old brother is in the middle of the lounge room driving his trucks through his own poo, with an erection. making car noises.
It is very hard to live with a sibling with a severe disability. I do know what that is like. I can't understand how hard it would be to have a brother that was older than you, that was your abuser, and your parents failed to protect you from. There have been some interesting articles on the sexual abuse by siblings in Australia in the last year.

I have a sibling with a severe disability. I protected him from my father for a very long time. And when people came up to my Mother in the shopping mall and said to her "I had a child like that, but fortunately it died" I protected her and my siblings as well. I got very good at getting in between vicious adults and people with disabilities that are not cute or glamorous.

Nope, wish my siblings were most of the time cuz then they'd have a half way "excuse" for being complete f*cktard assholes!
That is an appalling thing to say @lostforgottensoul.

I think the issue is that "f*cktard" is derived from "retard" on top of a connection being drawn wherein "If my siblings were disabled, they would have some explanation for being awful."
This is why @lostforgottensoul it is very offensive to those of us with siblings with disabilities.

Connected to the really annoying piece of US slang: "that's retarded" = "that's backwards and stupid".
And to a phrase that has driven me to a great deal of angst and anger over time "That's retarded".

It is one thing for Kimberley to express the immense complexities and frustrations coming from a situation like hers, and for you to use a blanket usage of all people of disabilities - what Simply Simon said.
 
Okay, I don't know how it is in Australia. But @Kimberley , you responded to a poster by calling your own disabled brother a f*cktard. Your post, in title, drawns in those who would related to having a sibling with a developmental disorder (low cognitive, whatever it's called in different areas), but then the f*cktard angle is incredibly off-putting and feels really insensitive and misinformed. Sounds like your brother was scary. I understand meltdowns in some of these disabilities. But the responsibility was with your parents. It sounds like they lacked resources or knowledge to help manage his behaviors and also protect you, or they were just plain negligent. I would put the responsibility on them in this case.
 
I feel like an arsehole because I get freaked out by disabled people.
It happens. I feel like an ass because most of the men in my life can tell I'm afraid of them, even when it's very irrational.

Long ago at my agency, a nurse was unpredictably attacked by someone she was attempting to give care to. He stabbed her through the eye with a pencil. She wound up needing all kinds of medical care, lost the eye, developed PTSD, and could not work anywhere near that field again.

None of the people who work with me get into it disliking the disabled. I would bet she did what she did because she loved that environment. But trauma makes fools of us all, breeding nonsensical fears and laying waste to our trust.

I agree with @Pencil; sibling abuse is under-acknowledged and gains little attention in the public eye. A lot of the invalidation I have encountered around sibling abuse is the mantra "Kids will be kids" and variations thereof that essentially state siblings can't abuse one another, because sibling problems are universal and non-traumatic. There is a very serious difference between expected horseplay or rivalry and malicious ongoing physical, mental, or sexual abuse by a sibling who is somehow more powerful than the other (especially in terms of age, size, and parental favor).

My brother is not developmentally disabled, although if you asked my mother about him, you might get a strong impression that he is. She has (especially now that he is in his 30s) framed his shortcomings by incessantly pointing to mild learning disabilities. Story of my life. My poor, stupid, incompetent brother needs to be coddled and taken care of, nevermind how vicious, malicious, manipulative, selfish, and remorseless he is. I could not imagine if it were true that he had an actual disability with which she could attempt to justify his abhorrent actions.

Having worked with this population for over a year and a half, I can say with confidence that one can distinguish harmful behavior that arises out of not knowing any better or not being able to help themselves versus malicious intent, and it's hard to explain to the general public that there is a difference. The public would, by and large, like to discredit and infantalize the disabled community by assuming they simply know nothing rather than to admit that they are like all people: a constant shifting dynamic of good, bad, sweet, and nasty. Such is the mercurial nature of human character.
 
We had a member, who I haven't seen for about a year ( hope they're alright).

They and another sibling were sexually abused by the eldest sibling, who has a learning disability.

When our member came out about it and sought help/ relief, the social workers went over the top, parents also went over the top in protecting the abuser and invalidating the victims.

Victim ended up, aged early teens in a local council "care home", and as an adult was still being invalidated and blamed by now elderly parents, whom our member felt duty bound to help, for supposedly making up such lies...

It seems as though disability is one of those issues that can obscure peoples ability to see anything but, either all good, or all bad, never mind the endless shades of grey that lie in between.
 
@Kimberley While my brother is not primary cause of my problems. When I was kid I approached my parents, because I wanted to put an "External Door Lock" on bedroom to keep my bother out. Panic room - since when he lost control it was dangerous. He has serious mental health condition. They agreed.

Once he broke down door. Only friend I let visit me. Both of us had backs against door locked, he still broke down door. Telling us he just wanted to play with us. WTF!

Before that school sent social worker to visit. She was freaked out my bedroom had exterior door lock.

In reality I needed a metal security bar to secure my room.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom