• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Sibling Guilt....why Didn't I Get As Much Torture?

Status
Not open for further replies.

It's all my fault

Bronze Member
So, my middle name is sorry. And I am...about everything. You see I absolutely got severe emotional constant abuse from my alcholic father. I was afraid for my life....daily. But, I never got physically abused. My arm wasn't broken, I wasnt almost drowned nor was I beaten regularly with his leather belt. You see, I'm the baby and my siblings are 8 and 11 years older. My mom has told me I was his favorite, he loved me the best and by the time i was born, he mellowed. I hate that word! She is cluelss of my fear of the monster as she is incapcitated in her own of him. She has never ever been able to protect us, never will and plays the victim so good she could get an Emmy. My mom has told me and others that if she hadn't had me maybe she would have left him. I believe at 83 she would say this today. My siblings have always been protective of me and I will never be able to repay them....but a part of me says yes you can...in your death. Does anyone else have this guilt of witnessing their siblings abuse and being spared?
 
From what you wrote here, I think your mother was also direcly emotionally abusive, by blaming you for her own choices and actions. I feel angry with mothers like this, like mine, who put their children through all this lying and blame. You and your siblings were not treated as you should have been by either parent, whose most basic responsibility is your emotional and physical safety, especially in the home.

Your birth timing had nothing to do with who she chose to marry and have kids with. A series of choices and lies were made prior to your birth. I'm sorry! But none of this was your fault, and your name on the forum ought to be immediately changed. You don't deserve it.

Nor did the fact that you arrived later than everyone else and got spared some of the intensity of abuse from your father mean you didn't also get negatively affected by the family dysfunctions and dynamic.

The very fact that you are expressing "Survival Guilt" which your whole post is about, is ample evidence of having survived a traumatic family environment. It matters very little if you recall physical of merely emotional violence. It's going to take work from you to process and heal. Emotional scars hurt so much more than physical ones.

It's time to see that none of them are or have been able to be honest with you about who they are, as addicts. It's going to take some therapy and time to weigh how growing up in a traumatic environment has impacted your thinking now.

I think a lot of us can relate to your survivor guilt. :( This is a phase of the healing that is normal with PTSD. You are okay for having these feelings. Just remember that. All the healing you go through, has to be gone through, as a thought process, in which you begin to see your reactions and emotions for what they are--healing. Don't judge and push away your emotions. You did right to post them here where you can be validated, maybe for the first time, as you should have been all along. :hug:

I think survivor guilt is a form of the grief stage of denial. With addicted parents who live in a bubble of denial, manipulation, and guilt, denial is a huge problem for those of us raised this way.

Denial is a protective response; don't rag on yourself for it; just learn to feel when it's happening and work around it. Don't make excuses for others. Rather than getting down to the pain you are really in, you focus on the others (as a kind of distraction). It feels like you can't heal yourself because you have been brainwashed and guilt-ed into worrying about the rest of the suffering family members. It doesn't even matter if they are the cause of that self-inflicted wound! See it for what it is, and realize you can't help them. You can only help you, and that's what you can choose to do now. You can put boundaries down and walk away from those who are keeping you stuck in the past.

I find this to be a very common reaction to trauma in those who grew up with it and who wish to find ways of relating to dysfunctional people, which was the only way to have relationships growing up. This is not "codependent" so much as what you gotta do to maintain relations with less than healthy supporters in life. Point is, now as an adult, you are not stuck with that family unless you want to be. Nor are you stuck with the identity they gave you. You can't change the color of your skin, your family background, disabilities, or illnesses, but you can change almost everything else about you. That's powerful!

Have you read about or experienced recovery or addiction from the adult child of alcoholics? While I disagree with some of 12 step and "adult child" definitions, it does help survivors gain a reframing tool to see the traumatic family dynamic for what it was and to step away into healing place.

So I think grieving the childhood that we (I didn't get it either) needed, did not receive, and will never have is a major step in realization of the traumatic loss and grief process that is needed to grow, heal, and realize potential. Denial is one step that gets processed, and you are processing it.

If you are not in therapy with a trauma therapist who has training in complex trauma and who you feel safe with, you will need some support to go through this and come out better off. An AA local group will have resources in USA for those of us hurt by addictions in caregivers. I'm not sure where you are at. Also, this forum is also a great support if you use it as such. I know you will find help here.

Welcome, Muse
 
Thanks Muse! I just can stop the flashbacks of my brother and sisters physical abuse that I witnessed. They mean well, tell me I am the favorite and say"thank god you didn't get it like we did. They also say, I'm so glad we could protect me'". It just feeds the guilt and I truly believe they meant this as protection. I feel like I can never repay them which fuels my wanting to die. I am working with a trauma specialist.. EMDR, SE and IFS but I just know the outcome regardless of her help will be the same. That outcome is not good. Thanks for understanding and I will look into acoa. I wish I was beaten, how suck is that?
 
No, but I did every thing I could to keep my younger brother safe. I would not want him to feel guilty, but I know he does. I feel guilty too, for not being able to save him. I was 6 and he was 2 when I started trying to protect him. I think there is just a lot of guilt involved in an abusive family.
 
I think that it's important that you know this scenario is not uncommon. Fairly often, one child gets all or most of the abuse while another is spared. The same pattern happened in my home, but I am the oldest and my siblings were spared.
 
It's really hard. I'm thinking about approaching my sister about my guilt but I of course feel guilty for asking for her help! LOL. I don't think she realizes that when she says "you didn't get it as bad, we protected you and you were liked best" that this just fuels the guilt. I believe she only wants the best for me and loves me very much. She does know that I was emotionally abused, it was hell and it was daily. But again, I never got the belt like she did or had my arm broken and drowned like my brother. But, I saw some of it!

I also have heard a lot of their abuse before I was born, like being driven to an orphanage as a frequent threat although this topic hasn't come up in a few years. She has been more of a mother figure than my own. She is my best friend and hero. I owe her my life so it feels disrespectful to complain that I even was traumatized and am asking for her help. Meanwhile, I'm stuck with the flashbacks and suicidal thoughts and feelings.

Last session my therapist was trying to get me to see that I was little, my sister was big and even this thought of her trying to unburden me of this guilt was absolutely terrifying. She has told me my mom never did leave him even after I was grown so she was using me as an excuse. I am convinced that had I not been born maybe my mom would have left and they would have been spared. She said its not my fault for being born last. She said my siblings are jealous of me. A part of me intellectually knows she may be right...maybe....but the majority of my being does not! I think when I heard all of this from my therapist, I literally freaked out in a panic, then dissociated.

It is too much. I have been fighting urges to self harm all day. I truly, truely feel that I need to be punished for not being physically abused. This is so messed up and stupid! To top it off my therapist is now away for 9 days at a conference. She told me I could call her if I need to but I feel guilty about bothering her. So, looks like I'll just stay in bed and miserable. This #%}^}£
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Does your therapist think you should talk with her about it?

I don't think it will do any good because she was traumatized, too. It's like when you injury a limb and then overuse the other one and then injure that one, too. Go easy.
 
I was one of the big brothers, my step father mellowed with my sister who is 10 years my junior and that gave me the opportunity to understand my step father and now we are close :)
 
It is quite common in abusive and disfunctional families that the abuser choses to have a "golden child," in my family it was my elder brother and I was the black sheep the focus of all the abuse, and my middle brother copped a bit of the physical abuse as and when he triggered my mothers anger.

It's not that they are the favoured child, it's more they are used to highlight to the others why they are so unacceptable, it's just another form of abuse, manipulation only you are the tool he used. He used you, in supposedly favouring you he isolates you from your siblings, and uses you for his own sick twisted needs. It's just as sick as the abuse he gave your siblings, it's just a different form because you had a different role in his little game. You don't need to feel guilt, it was abusive, and it wasn't your fault. It never is.
 
Wow! You are all right!....and insightful. No, my therapist has not talked me to approaching my sister. Yes, I see now why it is wrong. I never thought that I was being used to manipulate my siblings... This is also a revelation and OMG, yes I am the parent and always have been. The staple phrase was watch your mother....how about mom, watch the kids from the monster! I caution you with the use of the word "mellow". For me it invalidated my trauma and fueled the guilt that I was spared......which by no means I was not. Thank you all for your input, I feel like I've finally found home.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom