Ok, apparently I have so many skills books that I have NO idea which ones I actually own! long/short, I do in fact own the DBT skills workbook, and yes, I have worked through it before :-/
So last week I was reading through the workbook in between innings (big baseball fan, lol) and I was ok with everything, although it was all review, up until I got to page 200 (yes, that's the precise page...open your book and you'll see what I'm talking about!) So for 199 SOLID pages we are told up and down, left and right, inside and out to NOT judge anything good or bad. Not a hard concept to grasp, right? (A bit harder to master, lol). And what happens on page 200? You are told to judge your feelings as good or bad! (I kid you not!) My first reaction was to throw the book across the room, but that wasn't wise considering I was sitting in front of a huge flatscreen. So I reconsider donating the book to the thrift store. Another bad choice as I wouldn't want anyone else to be confused. So ultimately I decide that it's best suited for fuel in the woodstove. So maybe you're thinking this is a rash decision, but I haven't burned it yet. I have the original DBT book and I understand the skills. Seriously, though, don't tell me to do one thing for 199 pages and then pull a 180. You lose ALL credibility with me! (Bad, bad editing....they could have simply worded it as "more desirable" and "less desirable" feelings!!) I'm currently working through my CBT for dummies book, and I'm getting SOOO much more out of it.
Sidebar. I am HOCKED off at all of my past therapists who pushed DBT on me. Nobody ever pushed me toward CBT (outside of hospitalization)...it was always "you need DBT!" And is it just me, or is CBT much more in depth than DBT? I whipped through my DBT book pretty quickly, but my CBT book is a harder read and the skills are harder to master (lol, maybe because it was written by the Brits and it takes me longer to understand word usage. Yes, I can hear you all laughing at me from across the pond....)
But, to each their own. We all heal differently, and while I don't get a lot out of DBT, I'm glad that others do.