Thanks Berlinda, yes, definitely closer, they were practically joined at the hip many years ago, I had thought their relationship was not so close anymore. I think it is too hard to hear about the abuse. I have made it clear if he harasses me then I will be contacting the police, then he said how dare I threaten him with the police. I have replied and let him know that I won't be in touch again and that I can see now he is a toxic person. What a horrible person.