• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Does everybody get diagnosed anymore?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Gs172003

Diamond Member
I went on Twitter And was looking for more resources. It seemed like there was person after person saying they had it. Is it that prevalent or is it seriously over diagnosed? I can't see myself going online and telling everybody on the planet that I was told I have it regardless but that's just me.
 
Lotta Christians in churches*

Meaning if you’re looking for PTSD resources? You’ll find most people in/around those resources also have PTSD or are associated with people who do.

* It’s a ‘bad science’ reference for how to conduct studies/surveys that’s taught in pretty much every research 101 ever. Whether scientific or political or mathematic. If you’re trying to figure out how many people in population are Christian? It’s a good idea NOT to collect your data in churches. Because it will skew your results. (According to our data? 99.9% of the world is Christian! Ummm. No. No it isn’t.) That’s where the vaccine/autism scare came from. The researchers included a school for autistic kids. Which massively skewed the results; the entire study was failed in the peer review process because of that, but the media had already jumped on it. If they’d been studying toothpaste? The results would have read that toothpaste causes autism.
 
Lotta Christians in churches*

Meaning if you’re looking for PTSD resources? You’ll find most people in/around those resources also have PTSD or are associated with people who do.

* It’s a ‘bad science’ reference for how to conduct studies/surveys that’s taught in pretty much every research 101 ever. Whether scientific or political or mathematic. If you’re trying to figure out how many people in population are Christian? It’s a good idea NOT to collect your data in churches. Because it will skew your results. (According to our data? 99.9% of the world is Christian! Ummm. No. No it isn’t.) That’s where the vaccine/autism scare came from. The researchers included a school for autistic kids. Which massively skewed the results; the entire study was failed in the peer review process because of that, but the media had already jumped on it. If they’d been studying toothpaste? The results would have read that toothpaste causes autism.
You're right....that makes alot of sense.

Also I didn't know that about the vaccine scare. Wow!
 
I went on Twitter And was looking for more resources. It seemed like there was person after person saying they had it. Is it that prevalent or is it seriously over diagnosed? I can't see myself going online and telling everybody on the planet that I was told I have it regardless but that's just me.
My psychiatrist said he treats symptoms not the cause? He is new, my other went someplace else. I mean, I thought it was weird at first. Maybe that's why no one ( now) is really diagnosed. Maybe they guess at their diagnosis. It is overused..
 
Last edited:
Sorry in advance for for the rant...

I personally believe it's self diagnosis and a lack of understanding of what PTSD actually is. When measurements of basal, cerebral-spinal-fluid corticotropin-releasing-hormone, circulating catecholamine levels, and CB1 receptor concentration can be legitimized as biomarkers then we will be able to accurately diagnosis PTSD. Currently we use the DSM as a self-confirming ouija board for psychoanalysts to justify their validity by pretending to be scientific. That book is very destructive and makes normal people seek psychiatric and therapeutic treatments which they do not need. That's why most doctors who own one won't let laymen read it, unfortunately the internet made that possible.

I am a huge believer that PTSD has become synonymous with "anxiety from an identifiable stressor(s)". It seems any type of anxiety that has a perceived, inorganic cause is now considered PTSD to an uneducated person. I frequently see people who think that anxiety has an organic cause and PTSD is simply anxiety from a stressor rather than innate biology.

Some leading experts are even talking about labeling PTSD as a "stressor and trauma related disorder" to distinguish it from anxiety disorders. PTSD is from repeated responses to fear (stress response from a real threat) and cognitive distortions or implicit memories from PTSD lead to anxiety (stress response to a percieved threat). PTSD is more of an issue with conditioned fear responses leading to pathological, implicit memories and physiological and psychological disorders arising from those memories activating the amygdala which is activating the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal Axis which is messing up hormones. Anxiety is similar, some would argue the same mechanisms are at play, but it doesn't involve implicit memories that "trigger" the response or even necessarily involve a stressor. It can simply be caused by a cognitive distortion.

This is important to distinguish correctly. Treatment is different. Talk therapy typically works much better for anxiety. Someone with PTSD may not even be aware of their reaction (if implicit memory triggers the anxiety) and therefore things like cognitive behavioral therapy don't work as well. There is also a much greater rewiring of the connections between things like the amygdala, hypothalamus, cortex, striatum, etc. Hence all the focus on psilocybin and other neurogenerative agents that might help strengthen certain pathways. PTSD is also generally considered more permanent than most causes of anxiety are. Addiction, depression, and dissociation are also a greater concern in PTSD than anxiety disorders.

Reading about human behavioral biology can really help differentiate between these similar conditions. At first they seem nearly identical but after awhile you realize how extremely different they are. I strongly encourage Robert Sapolsky's lectures and books. They are easy enough to read, not like a normal biochem book.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom