• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Issues With Therapist, Considering Quitting

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kefira

Gold Member
This is partially a rant and partially me needing advice. Sorry in advance for the length.

I suffer from PSTD due to a string of incidents starting 8 years ago. I was formally diagnosed when I started therapy 7 years ago with PSTD as well as generalized anxiety and depression. I have seen a lot of therapists: some were just not good fits, I was unable to continue seeing a couple, I move frequently, and the last one was extremely unprofessional.

My current therapist has been reasonably helpful in the 3 years I've been seeing her (off and on: my symptoms and visit frequency vary greatly based on stress). I trust her and have a good relationship with her where I can talk. I also am very bad about keeping secrets though because it was so essential to do so in my past. One of my common feelings is that people tend not to understand how much I suffer from my symptoms because fear of the opinions of others or of often exaggerated consequences keeps me higher functioning than I would be otherwise or than I have been in more depressed states. I made a list about two months ago of everything I think people don't see (how uninterested I am with life, how for months I drove almost an hour to get groceries near where I used to live after a move) and read it to her.

After that session she tried some cognitive approaches for a couple weeks which fell flat with me because I understand how ridiculous many of my actions are and it already makes me upset that I can't apply my intellectual knowledge to my triggers, ect. I also feel she's overly focused on the anxiety aspect of my treatment, often only working on it instead of on the PTSD in general with anxiety as one of many symptoms.

Finally about a month ago she said that she wasn't sure if she could help me, and that if I wanted to find another therapist she'd understand. She spent a few minutes talking about how maybe she's not a good enough therapist for me (I've been trying not to overreact to this as it echos much of my mother's guilt tripping from my childhood, but it was certainly triggering). She then spent almost 10 minutes discussing medication. I am completely opposed to going back on medication at this point. I was forcibly committed in high school and went through a lot of different drugs for several years, most of which only made things worse. I told her at the beginning of the topic that I was uncomfortable and she knew my views on the subject, but she continued to push the issue even using the headache analogy.

I left the session feeling angry and as though my feelings had been dismissed. Irrationally it also makes me feel I'm not making enough progress, but I mostly feel that all of the trust it's taken 3 years to build up has been severely undermined. I haven't been back and have been avoiding her calls. She finally emailed me though and I need to find a way to reply. I was unable to explain at the time all of my feelings (I tend to close off easily and be unable to process) but I'm unsure if I will be able to go back even for a termination session as the thought feels extremely unsafe now.
 
I can understand how you feel I would be very reluctant to go back to a T who wasn't 't sure they could help me - doesn't exactly inspire confidence does it. ? And also my T being flaky would really freak me out . But I also understand you have a relationship and trust and you are 3 years down the path ! It is a long way back . Trust your instinct I expect you know inside whats best for you - try and listen to that
 
I think when a therapist says she doesn't think she can help more, she is recognizing her limitations and it is laudable in a way insofar as she isn't thinking of herself, but instead you. If that's the case here.

I don't like that she continued talking about something you said you didn't want to discuss. That might be said to be dismissive, and ignoring or denying your reality. That would be a huge issue for me. I had enough of that growing up. It would trigger me.

It is such a bummer when it doesn't work out, but now may be the time to go to the next level with someone who has better training specific to your trauma.
 
I think it probably is the limitations of the counselor as well. It would be good to have one more session to discuss your feelings. I would write a letter first and get all the emotion out . Then read it and rewrite it in tactful way.
 
I know this is very hard but I do think a therapist referring us on when they feel they don't have the skills or connection necessary is very ethical practice.

Is she a trauma therapist?

I understand feeling resentful if she was pressuring you too much to do meds. I have to say that sometimes t's do have to push us a little if they feel something is important. They have a duty of care. She may be concerned about the stress caused with you doing a change in t and be concerned about your safety. Meds are not for everyone but can be life savers in certain situations and can also enable us to be able to engage in therapy.

Lastly I just waned to say that there can be times where it is right to concentrate on the anxiety and other symptoms and not the trauma. If we don't have enough coping skills or are too unstable then going into trauma can be dangerous and a good t will take that into account.

Either she doesn't understand the importance of dealing with the trauma which means she probably isn't a trauma t and you need a different type of therapist or she is concerned about the danger of you presently going into trauma without enough safety skills which means she has your welfare at heart.

Do you have a plan for looking for another t and what criteria you need?
 
I had a therapist I saw off an on for a few years and she was really helpful... until she wasn't. Her style was very DBT and CBT oriented and it helped, to a point. When we reached that point, nothing seemed to make a difference. She suggested going back on medications, and even though she was pretty conservative and very mainstream, she even suggested medical pot. (For or against it, it's just not for me.) It was extremely painful for me to look for therapy elsewhere. Now I'm doing a different kind of therapy, and it took awhile to find... and hard to let go and start it... it was hellish actually... And one of the best things I've done. (The termination sessions were hard but so oddly healing, and she said I can always come back.)

I don't know if you should stay with her or go. It could just be a slump you are in, but maybe not.

It is really good that you have been able to trust her and maybe this isn't so much a moment of you being too much or her not being good enough... but that you are moving to a deeper level and graduating from the work you have done together to needing to do a different kind of work to take the next step in your healing.

Maybe it's not time to leave but for you to share more with her, keep less secrets and let her in more... (which can be the scariest thing in the world) - but sounds like you are already doing this though.... And it really hard to do when she is questioning her ability to handle it and help you through it.

I just really wanted to say that maybe this isn't so much you being too much for her, but just being ready to do deeper work than she does.

Hang in there.
 
Thank you for your responses everyone. I'm glad for the validation and the thoughtful responses. I understand she may have been pushing me because of concern and the reasons she would do so, but my gut says she's allowing some of her personal stuff to interfere in session.

She is not a trauma therapist, and I'm beginning to think perhaps I need to work with one.

I do not have a plan to go about finding someone else to work with, but I'm beginning to think the amount of stress this situation is currently posing to me is not worth it. I was already dealing with some additional symptoms at the time of the incident (job and relationship stress) but I really don't need an additional thing that's in question right now.
 
Kefira, that she isn't a trauma t explains a lot. I would think you will find it totally different to see a trauma t. I was shocked at how different it felt for me.

Well done for having the self awareness to know something wasn't working.
 
Last edited:
I think you are right on about the at being a trauma therapist being important. I saw therapists that did all kinds of therapy for all kinds of problems and they could only go so far with me. Now I have seen two trauma therapists and I've been able to go much further much quicker - but it was still tough to switch.
 
Yeah, I feel a little silly, but I only recently realized that there were people who specialized in this. I knew there were other types of specific counseling, but it was never suggested to me when I started or at any point during my therapy that perhaps I should look into finding a trauma therapist.
 
So if anyone is interested in an update on this, I sent her an email explaining basically everything I explained above and indicated I was terminating our sessions and would be looking for a trauma therapist. Her response email felt very self pitying to me and I still don't think she fully understands. She said if I was open to a session she would meet with me just to discuss the last time I was there, which she said was hard "for both of us". She admits there were probably counter transference issues as well.

I still haven't decided if I'm going one last time, but especially given the tone of the message I think I am making the right choice to find someone else.
 
I wonder if you would feel OK about sharing the email with a few changes here? It can be a very good learning experience to get others perspectives on such things and very useful when about to go into a new t experience.

I think seeing a trauma t is good idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom