• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Why Is Cutting Worse Than Other Forms?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I personally get disturbed by it because of my inability to see blood/wounds/etc. without fainting. I see what you're saying, though. Many things are self-harming and coping mechanisms all in one, just not readily or immediately visible.

I guess many folks see it as more of a direct purposeful wound and can't understand why/how someone would purposely create it, all the while, enjoying their more subtle ways of self-harm via whichever means they choose that they have likely, albeit mistakenly, convinced themselves is a lesser harm. As with most things, unless we directly experience something full force, we struggle to wrap our heads around it.
 
In my psychology class in graduate school we've been taught to look out for cutting because self-harm in such a way is directly related to suicidality and that self-harm can lead to suicidality more so than other maladaptive coping strategies. At the school site I am currently placed at for practicum (basically pre-internship) I've had multiple trainings on looking out for suicide warning signs, of which I have been instructed that self-harm is one of the major markers. I'm not sure if it is worse than other maladaptive coping strategies or not, I don't feel like I'm at liberty to make that distinction. I'm sure there are statistics and articles I could find if you want me to look for them, but I won't unless you ask me to. I think it all comes down to shock-factor with some individuals on the reactions to these kinds of things.
 
I can think of a few other worse forms of self harm. Some people break their bones with hammers. Other people bang their heads causing brain damage.

My 2nd favorite form of self harm I can be arrested for. I wouldn't say it's worse than cutting, but the consequences are worse. No one arrests you for cutting. And this one can also kill you. ((My favorite, though, I'm praised for. Now there's a mindf*ck.))

Point being... Why do people freak out about some forms of self harm more than others? Because some forms of self harm ARE WORSE than others. Cutting is more damaging than hair removal. Just is. If you can't see that? Then I would suggest that you need to take a step back for a moment.
 
I think there are a lot of cultural and social factors at play. It might seem more "acute", in comparison to a self-harm behavior that appears more insidiously or gradually (such as an eating disorder, if it is conceptualized as self-harm). Different types of self-harm might be considered more socially acceptable (such as overworking, self-sabotage, etc, again if they are conceptualized as self-harm) - they might occur more commonly, and they might play a role in perpetuating the norms of a social system. "Socially acceptable" forms of self-harm might not be explicitly labeled as such. Maybe cutting is more "tangible" in the sense that its physical effects (cuts and scars) are more apparent. Also, cutting is associated with mental illness, so there might be more stigma attached to it because of the stigma associated with mental illness. Really sucks.

Like you said, it is a coping mechanism and it also causes suffering. I care about the suffering it is causing you. Are you doing therapy, and is it something you and your therapist have addressed?
 
Tendon and or nerve damage risks, not just blood combined with the fact that something repeated til it becomes a behavior generally escalates not decreases and that desensitization can for some over time lead to more extreme acts to get the "same result".... not just with cutting the latter of that, but it further engrains the behavior and is a maladaptive coping mechanism where there can be any number of others that are less self damaging.
 
Self-harm (of any kind--cutting, burning, dripping hot wax on yourself specifically to feel pain, indulging in reckless or unhealthy behaviors specifically for the danger and damage of it) is a maladaptive and inappropriate coping mechanism because it demonstrates a complete lack of valuing oneself.

When I put a similar question to my T, I was a teenager. I'd cut using a sewing needle or a safety pin. It was not dangerous. I'd dig little trenches in my skin over and over and over again until I felt relief. If I didn't, I'd pour nail polish remover on the wounds, hoping to find that sense of peace I only seemed to get through really knowing I'd hurt myself. There was no terrible danger of hitting a vein or anything. I had no desire to scale up to knives or razors: my method hurt more than a sharp blade and was "safer."

But it was really worrying behavior. When my T explained why, she asked if I would go through my closet and cut up all of my clothes or my bed sheets. I said no. Because I valued those things. I didn't want to destroy them. Me? I had not a care in the world for myself. Not a single care.

These days, if I have a desperate desire to self-harm, I turn to intense physical exercise. It can be bad if it becomes compulsive and constant (been there, too), but it allows me to put myself through a sort of pain that contributes to my health instead of damaging my body. When I wake up, sore and tired, I feel so much better off than I did when I woke with the shame and scars from my former "coping mechanism."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom