• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Why is isolation "wrong"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't trip

Silver Member
I haven't been to the forum in a long time. It looks so different I nearly missed it on the Google Search!

Anyway, . . .I've just recently been coming to terms with the impact PTSD has had on my life. It was easier to blame my chronic illnesses, and to 'toot my horn' about that because it was socially acceptable. Mental health is not. I have so many things to share that confuse me. So many questions to ask.

Everywhere I read about PTSD, says not to isolate. This really upsets me. I'm an introvert by nature, but in relation to my PTSD, particularly this last year, I've felt more emotionally stable and peaceful writing my blog, mentoring survivors by email and phone, and staying HOME. I do get out to grocery shop and to doctor/therapy appointments. In the last year, chronic sciatica has prevented my mile long walks in nature with my dog, but I still go out to my backyard and commune with nature there, my garden, trees and flowers around me. . .

I'm a survivor of chronic childhood sexual abuse and a rape, more sexual abuse in adulthood by psychopathic abusers. I am abuse free now for nearly three years. I filed for disability but have been denied two times and my hearing apparently won't be heard for at least another year. The stress of no income and relying upon family to help me has been nearly unbearable. I've been looking for work as a writer, but nothing has come up for me yet, while also trying to start a business from my blog and my mentoring work.

There are some very, very frustrating things about my PTSD that have me feeling very depressed right now. No matter in what way I've tried to do it, I cannot work outside my home. My reactions to criticism and perceived abuse are spontaneous. The hyper vigilance and terror I feel, are related to having lived chronic exploitation. I have a morbid and unrelenting fear of authority figures. I can't be around people for long periods of time. I love my children and grandchildren, but I can only tolerate visits for so long before I begin to feel exhausted.

I've denied the impact of PTSD on my life so much, that now, in understanding how profoundly it has affected my entire life from an early age, no one believes me, except those closest to me who understand my reactions and stress. This is my doing. I'm of reasonable intelligence and have been able to convince others that don't know me, even my therapist, that it's 'not as bad' as it truly is for me. I realized I didn't want the stigma and I've worked hard to get out of victim mode.

So much of what I struggle with, is considered 'wrong'. Isolation is one of them. "Don't let yourself become isolated!", "If you isolate, it makes it worse!" , "You need to get out and be around people!" Um, no, I don't, because it aggravates it. I'm extremely sensitive to noise, chatter, and crowds. I've experienced so much physical and emotional violence that living a simple, quiet and peaceful life, has brought me great comfort and feels incredibly SAFE. My whole world is about safety. I love being alone. It rejuvenates me and I'm much more productive with my writing and mentoring when I feel stable.

I've learned that my PTSD is made worse in feeling shamed about it. It's worse when I feel pushed to do more than I'm able to do. The person I was before I came to awareness about my abuse history and how PTSD played a part in my poor choices in my life, meant I was 'pretending' to be everything I was not: outgoing, extraverted, doing things I felt others wanted me to do and holding onto the societal expectations (as well as what was expected in my successful pathological family), of what it meant to be successful: money, image and wealth.

I put myself in situations in purposely exposing myself to triggers in working to overcome them and it had the opposite affect on me. It made things WORSE, much, much worse.

I don't feel 'allowed' to accept what I now recognize are my limitations. I know some people are able to 'get back out there' and enjoy their lives again. That's them. It's not me. When I feel that there is room to accept my PTSD and the limitations it creates, I feel AT PEACE. Isn't that interesting? It's the external noise about what I should or should not do about it, trying to do what I know that I can't, subsequently leading me to serious decompensation that has me in trouble. I then feel humiliated, embarrassed and it furthers my shame.

Somehow I don't think that shaming survivors with PTSD about what they can't do, is the answer. I'm learning that accepting my limitations allows me to see what I can do and what I have to work with.

I'm curious as to whether or not others here recognize their limitations, including isolation, as a positive thing, that keeps you stable?

Thanks for reading.
 
1. I am SO sorry for what you have been through.
2. Thank you for sharing.

I don't think of isolation as bad. We grow up thinking that we have to be extroverted and to be introverted as wrong. Don't quote me or take this negatively and this is from my experiences only, I believe a lot of introverted people are victims of abuse and violence because we are quiet people who like to be alone, so predators do look for those kinds of qualities in people.

I go to class, joined church, therapy, see a select few of friends who are also introverted, but other than that my fiancee and i live in solitude. We live in the country away from the mess and noise of the world. I love my animals, quiet nice by a fire outside, watching the sunset. All those things make me happy and before I considered them wrong, but they are NOT.

What has helped me was this.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers-Briggs_Type_Indicator

http://www.myersbriggs.org/my-mbti-personality-type/mbti-basics/

After you read that here is the actual test:

http://www.humanmetrics.com/cgi-win/jtypes2.asp

Google your 4 letter type and it will help you understand yourself better. I am a INFJ. I am introverted. I am the "protector" and the "counselor." It helped me accept myself and not beat myself up for wanting to be by myself a lot because of lots of childhood trauma.

Their is NOTHING wrong with being introverted, human contact is important but you don't have to go out and be completely absorbed in the world. I think of it as solitude.

Also, here is a book that I found helpful.

Dead Link Removed
 
I googled imaged my type because it made me laugh as, well.

Here is a picture of my "type" lol.
 

Attachments

  • image.webp
    image.webp
    14 KB · Views: 268
Also, here is this. Sorry I keep posting haha.
 

Attachments

  • tumblr_mhap9kst7X1s2tvfgo1_500 (1).webp
    tumblr_mhap9kst7X1s2tvfgo1_500 (1).webp
    53.8 KB · Views: 299
Thank you so much for posting; I am so sorry you have had so much to deal with in life... I am a survivor as well and am in the middle of dealing with PTSD. I am an extrovert by nature and am a full time teacher(primary age). I also live alone and there are times I get lonely. However, I have learned that choosing to isolate for periods of time, especially when I am dealing with my mood disorder, PTSD, or just want some creative time alone, works for me.

There are certain things I have chosen not to do, even though I have tried (like you have) because they trigger me. I made a decision this year that I will not each lunch in the faculty room because I do not like the way the other teachers bash the kids and I also decided that I will not do ANY socializing of any kind with my co-workers outside of school because I do not want to spend my free time with them. It was a relief to finally be able to say, "I have the right to say no and I have the right to set boundaries, even when I choose to spend time alone." It is very difficult to try to explain to someone else who is not a survivor(or even has PTSD for that matter, without the sexual abuse), how it can affect our daily lives.

If you really have times that you just need to be alone without leaving the house, I see nothing wrong with that. In fact, some people get into unhealthy relationships because they don't want to be alone. It takes a lot of courage to face and deal with what you are dealing with and I give you a lot of credit. Honor your healing process and do what feels right for you. I hope you are able to post again so you can continue to receive support.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe a lot of introverted people are victims of abuse and violence because we are quiet people who like to be alone, so predators do look for those kinds of qualities in people
This is a great statement! I had never thought of it like that before. But do you think isolation and being introverted are the same? I tend to isolate, I won't call or see anyone for a week at a time except for my son and renter. I tend to become more symptomatic. I also like to be alone, read, walk my dogs, garden, but I also think it can be taken to the extreme too and there is a fine line. Do you think that the level of isolation can come into play? I love reading your posts, Ashdawn, you are so enthusiastic and like a breath of fresh air. I'm sorry if that sounds silly :), but its what comes to mind.
 
Aw thank you monster. I think there is a fine line between isolation and being an introvert, you just have to do what feels good to you. If not talking to someone for a week makes you feel good and you are gardening, reading, walking your dogs, and practicing self care, I don't see anything wrong with that :).

It is nice to shut out the world for a little bit. As long as you are taking care of yourself be proud of being introverted!
 
Thank you for this thread, Don't Trip. It really hit home for me.

My traumas began sometime between ages 3-5 so PTSD is the only thing I've ever known. When my symptoms are well managed, I like to work on figuring out who I could have been. . .try to figure out what things I like to do. Many of those things are quiet alone things to do. . .in other words, they look a lot like isolating.

There is definitely a different feeling, though. When I'm isolating there is almost a mania feel to it. . .gotta get away. . .gotta get away. When I'm doing one of those quiet alone things, I feel more calm and I get this feeling that I think is enjoyment or something.
 
I think isolation for an extrovert is different than isolation for an introvert.

I'm very much in "I need to be safe" mode right now. Being by myself and having "me" time allows me to feel safe. At the moment my main goal is safety. Happiness is an ultimate goal, but if I don't feel safe, I'll never be happy.

I don't think we have to justify ourselves. I'm able to go out into the world and interact with other people, so I don't see my introversion and "isolation" if you will as a problem.

However, if someone is shut away in their home and can't function at all out there, then I'd say that is a problem that should be worked on. But, if it comes down to preferences of how to spend your time, then it's all up to you.
 
I guess that is the difference. If you prefer to spend your time alone in your house. I think I do it too much since I used to like to do a lot of things. Then again, I am doing trauma work, and need extra alone time.
 
I believe there's a fine line between isolating and introversion also. And I'm not sure where the idea came from that it's bad for someone with PTSD to isolate. I kind of sense whoever first postulated that theory may have borrowed it from generalized notiion of "healthy psychology" that folks who circulate more, (i.e. who often participate in things with many people) are healthier and happier people. But who really knows if that's true? Or if the survey respondents weren't primarily extroverted people lovers???

I have a few outside interests and a few people whose company I really enjoy, but I don't do well in crowds or noisy places. My home is my refuge: it's quiet, comfortable and serene and I'm very selective about people coming over. The last several months (because of symptoms) I've needed to "pull back" from the outside world and take care of myself more. It's a pattern I've become accustomed to, and I'm beginning to recognize that my symptoms are lessening and I want to begin getting out more. I am ENFJ, one point from INFJ. The INFJ seems to predominate at the moment, BUT if a party were to occur, and I made myself go, I'd be the person to get everyone out on the dance floor.

Overall, I'm with Solara on this one, and think you're really on to something, Don't trip.

Shame is rarely useful and acceptance takes in a whole lot more, thus allowing myself/ourselves simply to be.

Drew
 
Last edited:
I try to keep in context that for a lot of history humans often lived in somewhat isolated circumstances. They lived with their family but not a lot of other people. Given how many people live within one square mile of my house no freakin wonder I like staying in my house and yard. It is kind of overwhelming.

When I was a kid I believed I was an extrovert. Turns out I was just lonely. I have social needs and I try to meet them... but I get people to come to my house *where I feel safe and comfortable*. It's awesome! I have a wide variety of friends and acquaintances to invite over tea and I can have a few hours of nice conversation and then send them on their way. I see no problem here. :)

To me, isolating would involve not blogging and not reaching out to people online. I know that some people think "online doesn't count" but it really does. The people who say that mean well and all but I like to ignore them. I'm a blogger and I also like to talk to survivors online. We are ok. Really. :)

There is no "normal". Do what makes you happy. If you are doing what you want and what makes you feel ok then it is ok. I mean, you need to figure out the money situation. That's really hard.

I hope that things resolve for you in some way that helps you soon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom