Managed to read a fair amount of the thread now.
I think its an excellent question in general and it is also quite likely a good thing you are asking it. For you. Breaking things apart often leads to change.
I was thinking about it further and the other analogy that comes to mind is sometimes a wheel isn't making contact with the road, or I am spinning my wheels. Continuing doing the same thing without asking why tends to mean that continues longer.
But also:
Realising the wheel isn't touching the ground and getting it down there are two different things. Sometimes we need to work and work and it seems no progress has been made, but then MOVEMENT... and all of a sudden things improve. Lots of progress can be invisible for a while. I find my progress goes in cycles. I also think a lot of work didn't generate much noticeable result for a while but it was exponential. It gathered momentum and the different parts started slotting together, at a point.
neither being kind or pushy work.
Oh yes, poor you, I know why that is scary", or "For goodness sake woman, just do it".
A stick seems more effective for me, without it, I'm fairly consistently inert.
One of those wheels that were off the ground was being able to deal with myself in an effective way. I didn't really understand how much this affected things until it started to change. Neither of what you describe above sounds helpful. It took me masses of hard work but then it did start taking hold and when it did - movement.
If you do have movement when someone else is affected it likely means you care about others more than yourself. And that movement is possible. Its just that you for you isn't a motivating enough factor at present. I truly know this feeling. Frozen.
When it comes to not reading the books or doing the homework: its worth looking at why that is happening. I know for me internal conflict often means that my brain is pulling in so many different directions that I don't do what I need to do. Or there is such a thing as avoidance.
Procrastination isn't laziness by the way. It is usually thought to relate to anxiety. Avoidance is too. At some point we need to really deeply accept that avoidance is not bringing us peace. It is merely delaying and keeping us suffering. Its horrible facing stuff but we have to go
through to get to the other side. There is no way
around. We often need to do things again and again before things take. And often the things we need to be doing don't mean we need to make it harder for ourselves. Making it easier on ourselves is a big lesson for many of us and harder than continuing with the self judgment and harshness. Essentially we have to be a good parent to ourselves. Tricky if we haven't experienced what that looks like.
I have to say I managed my earlier change through the use of the stick. When I hit up against the limits of that method I ground to halt. I was really stuck. The stick was no longer doing what it needed to do and in order to use something different I had to change a lifestimes habit, all sorts of belief systems, and rewire my brain. It was very hard and very frustrating. It did start yielding results eventually. It was ... unpleasant getting there.
One of the best things I did for me was to decide: I don't have to believe in treatment, in myself, or my ability to change to put one foot in from of the other.
Curious about the 5 year thing. Did you read something that gave that number?