• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Therapist doesn't want me to mention my grandmother

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fadeaway

Diamond Member
I am so baffled by this. My therapist doesn't know anything outside of my hatred for her.

There are things I can see my therapist helping with, but she won't help with my past. I am not going to stop trying to understand myself better, and part of that is wanting someone to help me understand behaviors that no matter how much pressure I put on myself to change cant be done on my own. I my past is important to figuring out how to change! Am I wrong?
 
No, you’re not wrong.

But is this a legitimate therapeutic approach that works for some people? Yes. Me included.

I fought it initially. My great big issue was X. Spent all my time, every day, really distressed about X, trying to resolve X.

My second T? Said “we aren’t gonna talk about X any more.” So when I went in for my appointment, X was all I wanted to talk about. X was the problem I wanted to resolve. What the hell are we doing if we don’t talk about X???

Several years of practice later? I’d managed to identify that actually there were other issues in my life unrelated to X that my t helped me work through. And spending a whole tonne of time in therapy talking about me, rather than X, helped me seperate out X as an issue that I could kind of coexist with while I was improving other aspects of my life.

If we’d spent those years analysing X from ever possible angle? X would probably still be the great big unresolved issue that it is today. But I wouldn’t have accomplished anything else, resolved any other issues.

When I first started with that T, I honestly thought that every other issue I had I could live with comfortably if only we could resolve X. But now? I think maybe X is an issue that may not have a solution, and working on the rest of me? Has ultimately been helpful.

Does that mean this approach is going to work for you? No. Just saying that it may be a deliberate strategy to try and explore other ways to bring you a life of less distress. Different strokes for different folks.

Maybe see what she’s got planned, if you aren’t allowed to talk about the key issue you want to deal with, what’s ber alternative proposal? If you literally can’t sit down with a T and talk about anything other than this one person, why is that? Because you and the way you experience life, ways to reduce your distress and improve your well-being - that’s a whole lot bigger than this one person.
 
How do I become this?

Is a different question from

How did I become this?

Sometimes answering how did we get here is important to figuring out where are we going. Other times? All it does is keep you from doing anything.

It’s easiest to see in others... when someone is caught in a negative feedback loop. It’s like a flashback, but not, because they’re choosing it. Day in and day out, living in the past, refusing to see what’s right in front of them. Learning to break away from that? Is similar to learning how to ground out of flashbacks. The past will always be there. It’s not going to go away if you focus on your life today and plans for tomorrow. But people caught in that kind of loop? Usually can’t see &/or believe that. It’s (also) like grief. The time when it’s fresh and raw and pure pain; and the belief that any joy -or even any lessening of that pain- somehow disrespects or erases the importance/love you had/have for that person... and settled grief; where you love them just as deeply and profoundly as you always have but ALSO feel joy. Can think of them and smile, & can live your life. Settled grief is like loving 2 people at once. You don’t love 1 less for loving the other. Nor do you have to choose which you’re going to love, because you can only love 1 person at a time. Love adds. It doesn’t subtract. Setting aside the negative feedback loop / stepping out of the past to change the present? Doesn’t change the past. You don’t lose it. It changes the future. Because you become more than what you were. Rather than less.
 
@Sideways I have only said two interrupted sentences about her. If it was all I could talk about I would agree that in that situation you were right. I think I need a combination of both approaches.

@Friday agree 100% I definitely needed to hear that about grief. This isn't a negative feedback loop though. When I get obsessed with wanting family? I can get really stuck in that. This is different though this is... trying to find the right words.. I am trying to figure out what is motivating me to behave in direct opotition what I really want to do. I want to understand what is driving the behavior I want to get rid of so I can flip the damn auto pilot switch off and take back the controls when confronted with C+G+K in that order unwanted behavior happens.

My first memory of it happening, I think my grandmother was pleased? As I am writing thisit kinda hit me that it is a fawning behavior. Those aha moments and feedback if the "aha"is sound. Maybe it started out as fawning and became a maladaptive behavior?

I just don't know how effective my therapist is going to be if what she knows about my history couldn't fill a thimble.
 
I just don't know how effective my therapist is going to be if what she knows about my history couldn't fill a thimble.

Does she need to know?

Imo you know, what she needs to know is how to work with your reactions & a way of seeing the world in a way that aids you.

She does not necessarily need every little bit of why, to be good.

((Trying not to project, here, but I have at least three therapists I could contrast with:
One having heckuva lot of information... Not getting a single thing of it & Not useful to me.
The worse thing than not saying anything is spilling to a moron, check, lessons learned.

One having a lot of information... Bad with implications of it, not getting what it means for daily life, actively worsening me off.
One having minimal information... Being quite open minded & brilliant with questions, darned useful.

It is not how much they know... but how they work with what they know, & what they don't.))
 
Makes sense, but if she is trying to treat me based false beliefs I have yet been able to clarify? I. E. no sexual trauma (didn't have the energy to keep trying to over talk her to clarify) and that my issues surrounding death are because I am an atheist. They aren't and while don't believe in a god, I do believe in spirits. (evolving theory)

She is great at practical fixes for current stressors so I don't to make it sound like I am getting nothing out of it.
 
Every therapist has a unique approach. Speaking for myself I would always reevaluate my need to continue with someone if they were hurting me. And free speech prohibitions are a real red-flag in MY world.

My advice is to listen carefully to your own gut feeling and then hit the therapist data-base if you need to move on. These people don't know as much as most people would love to believe.
 
@blackemerald1 Pretty much all my history. She only wants me to focus on things that have immediate solutions.

I have zero other options for therapy.
There is online counseling too. You can pick your therapist and switch if it isn't working.
I know enough about this stuff to tell you this...many therapists act as if their one (often shortsighted) approach is gospel and you are wrong for not believing it. Does this ever remind you of what many teachers or politicians do?

The least they should do is follow general ethics. Censorship of speech has no place in any therapist's office. I wish you strength and confidence in proceeding. It's your life and your choice.
 
Well then I agree with you.. how you've handled/experienced life is likely to illuminate how you deal with life now. I mean it's not so simple but we really can be habitual at times... even when those habits are unhealthy/unhelpful.

Can you ask her more about her strategy /approach?

Could she want to see how you are regulating/managing with day to day things before reviewing your history?
 
Can you ask her more about her strategy /approach?
I agree with this. I'd really want to know more about how this therapist "does" therapy if I was feeling shut down. Maybe there's a good reason for it that you can work with. Or maybe it's something that you really can't work with at all.

Regardless it would be good for you to know the reason behind her choices.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom