J is "irresponsible, lazy, forgetful, procrastinating etc".
I submit to you that J is not being these negative things, he is actually suffering from PTSD... and he's hurting enough already.
I just want to scream "Act like an adult! Get off your ass and do what you said you'd do!"
I understand your frustration, but this is extremely offensive. It's like telling someone with diabetes to quit whining and eat the food that's being offered; or someone with skin cancer to buck up and spend the day in the sun with friends and family; these things can be done... but at what cost to the sufferer?
I'm in the midst of discussing this issue with my husband, from a sufferer's point of view. Like your fellow supporters, I don't need the background information on this... I am familiar with it from my perspective. My husband's point is: How can we give the kids strikes (which lead to loss of privileges) for not doing their chores when I don't do my chores consistently? And, shouldn't I be given strikes as well? (Am I on the same learning curve my children are on, despite my age and experiences?) My kids have both called me lazy on different occasions, and my husband has as well. This isn't something they say often, but they have said it. They snipe at me, here and there, because I didn't get off the internet all day, among other things.
None of those negative things helps me in the long run. Usually, I respond in some way that suits them but which is only a temporary fix to an immediate issue; but which actually sets me back in my recovery. I am FILLED WITH NEGATIVE THOUGHTS... so, adding more negatives doesn't help me at all. It may make those around me feel better that I got off my ass and did something, but it adds present tense resentment to my negative thoughts. It reinforces that I am unloveable and disgusting. Regardless that their intention has nothing to do with that. My symptoms look different to outsiders, frustratingly enough, my symptoms usually give the opposite impression to how I actually feel. When I am overwhelmed, I appear not to care at all, for instance.
I have had PTSD since I was a child, and I took it upon myself to bridge the gap in understanding my family. It's only recently that I've been able to see me from their perspective and not become belligerently angry, and that's because it just hurts way too much to see that while I'm suffering and thinking of killing myself, my behavior is pissing off everyone around me; pushing them further away from me, making them less compassionate towards me. It's like... I have this mental illness and it's literally driving me crazy at times, but I cannot burden anyone with it and if I did they wouldn't understand why I keep thinking these thoughts anyway. I can't say "I'm sorry I didn't do anything today, my PTSD was flaring up" because my husband doesn't want me to use my PTSD as an
excuse.
BUT, the symptoms of my PTSD look like I'm lazy, unwilling to leave the house, uninterested in family fun, etc... and so they are okay with criticizing me for the symptoms of my PTSD. How is that fair? I don't choose this. I want to participate. I want to contribute to society. I want to be important. I want to be respected. I have a college degree! I have had good jobs. I have been reliable, when I am willing to commit to things, but like Gizmo, I take extra care not to commit to very much. Having PTSD is really
NOT the same as being normal. My thoughts are hijacked on a regular basis.
Everything triggers memories and negative thinking. Everything. Good and Bad stuff. People I'm with, people in the room, people on the street. Almost every conversation reminds me of memories that lead to negatives. Hell, everything is a f*cking trigger. Is that my husband and children's problem? Hell no. Is it something they can fix? No.
-I'm dealing with it. I'm working through it. I'm getting a handle on it.
My past progress shows that I am on the right path toward healing this issue. I am able to write about it, that is when I know that I am starting to be able to do something about it. When my symptoms were unrecognized, by myself, they were out of control. But, recognizing them has gone a long way toward setting them aside and continuing to be happy anyway. I have had weeks at a time, recently, where I was happy and taking care of business. My family was happy with me too. But, 10 days after something negative happened and my PTSD symptoms became unmanageable, my family started sniping at me again. Wouldn't it be nice if they'd believe that I have a mental illness and that I am actually doing my best?
But, then again... that is part of my problem... accepting my own limitations. In order to defend myself against the fact that I appear lazy to my family, I have to convince them that I am mentally ill... and that I am actually, in reality, no kidding... unable to follow through with completing a simple task. That's something that is one of the hardest things to admit, something I couldn't admit until I was able to accept it myself... and it's taken me a year to accept it. A year that looks like I've sat around wasting my life and not caring about anyone, in a major depression, trying various drugs to help me end the symptoms without ever having to face the words, Mental Illness. I chose to take my lumps for 34 years, first from my family of origin and now from my created family (to a lesser extent). Because it's hard to admit that I really am limited... it hurts my pride, my self-esteem. It is the reason why, when I was a child, I wished that I'd had some physical disability... so people wouldn't ask me to do stuff that I wasn't capable of, and then be angry at me for failing. Or they wouldn't expect so much from me when I'm feeling sick.
Well, as I said, I'm working on this with my H right now. I believe that I will, by the end of this year, be able to distinguish for myself, when I'm experiencing PTSD Symptoms and when I could follow through but would rather do something else instead. I would like to virtually eliminate the latter by positively reinforcing my accomplishments internally, and by allowing myself to be sick when I am really sick. PTSD is worse when I feel guilty for failing, so I need to allow for the fact that I have this illness that chooses the times to mess with me, and I cannot always beat it. So, sometimes it's better for me to succumb and validate my life experiences, in an effort to be able to maintain our family's positive experiences for longer intervals between episodes.
Do you see what I mean? And, my thinking is that your husband is somewhere on this same learning curve. Has he started? Is he getting therapy? Is he aware of his symptoms? Does he know that they are not in his power to control? Does he know what will put his mind at ease at any of the various thoughts? This is a long process. It takes years to master it all, and it's really difficult to motivate oneself to become more proactive in managing the upsetting thoughts, especially when many of them feel like a part of one's personality, or a compulsion to understand or confront.
I hope reading about my side of this argument helps you in some way. My opinion is that you need to keep the pressure on your husband to be as normal as possible, but to be compassionate when he fails. Also, he is the only one who can manage his PTSD symptoms, and even then he won't be normal.