Abstract, I hadn't been in therapy for 20 years prior to last year. I thought everything was worked through, etc. Now I wish I would have started back earlier, before I lost my job, as I wasn't handling my chronic illness and depression with much finesse.
I was recommended to a company of therapists by two different people. One was my gp and the other happened to be the hospital I ended up in when I became suicidal. The first therapist of that company, that I went to, was nice, but it didn't work out for me. I needed something, someone, different. To this day, I'm not exactly sure what it was, but I needed a change. I like my new therapist. I like that she gets me. The thing I think I'm trying to say is that it may be trial and error but that is okay because you are, you sound as if you are, in a better position to get what you need out of this therapy. Do not, please, be discouraged if you do not mesh right away. It took me a few visits, or more, before I decided her method just wasn't for me. I just felt stagnate. Part of that is finding your comfort level.
I think there are a lot of good suggestions on here that people have given you. I'm glad you are considering them all. I just wish I had more to offer.