• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

News Ariana Grande's (pointless) PTSD brain scan

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just thought i'd clarify too that the therapist i was talking about was referring to scans done during research, as at the time it was an emergent therapy & me being scanned was at no time mentioned in any way.
I would also like to add that, given the importance of research (& rightfully so) lets not ignore the enormous body of reseach that has been done on & around the power of belief alone &/or happiness that has also come to show how the brain changes over time & in accordance to it.
Personally i like the facts or truth but, when believing in snake oil can get the job done too, i say do whatever you got to do to get the job done. Afterall, there is research to suggest that both can be just as a healing.
I guess it's kind of the whole point really ..do you want to be right or do you want to be healthy? Now if you are wanting to become a therapist then it is really important that you are right, but for me, my only concern has been to get healthy & i say if Ariana gets benefit from it, i say go for it.
My recovery philosophy has always been to only focus on working in the areas that were stopping me from doing the things that i wanted to do..the rest was a matter of opinion, regardless of how educated a position it was coming from. Might seem harsh, but as we well know, PTSD doesn't take prisoners & at times there were definately some very thin threads keeping it all together.
 
The CNN article states that she says the bombing at her concert that killed 22 people is the event that caused her PTSD. I don't know why someone would be upset that she is sharing this post of her scan with her fans. She has fans. And, 22 of them were killed at her concert. There are researchers scanning brains of people and comparing them. I se nothing wrong with Ariana Grande sharing a scan she had done somewhere, who knows where it was scanned, she doesn't say who scaned it, and relating to her fans about a very traumatic event for lots of people. Trying to making sense of acts of terroism whether you are famous or not is normal in my opinion. Sharing your collective processing experiences with those who were there, or were watching, or who are currently worried about terrorist acts in our midst I think is healthy. For her she is sharing publically because she does have a relationship with her fans.
 
My beef isn't with Ariana sharing her scan results, it's with the doctor that sold her that quackery.
Seeing 22 people that were there specifically to see her being killed is a horrible thing for her to have witnessed. If that didn't cause her long term psychological harm, she wouldn't be a human being.
I don't doubt she is doing this because she really wants to help others.
 
But.. she's not helping anyone. She's not sharing.

She doesn't want to talk about 'her ptsd' - not now, not with her fans and has said so.

She isn't reaching out to those affected by the terrorist attack at her concert specifically.

How is telling a bunch of media that you had brain scans for your ptsd going to help anyone?

The science is dodgy and at least for now isn't going to bring any assistance to her fans. Or anyone else.

I'm all for celebrities (or anyone really) taking on causes that are close to their hearts, raising awareness, money and hopefully research and anything else that assists sufferers and supporters. How do you reckon she's done that with this media release?
 
Dr. Amen.... something about him makes me very uncomfortable.

I had several scans done. One was done weeks leading up to my failed attempt and the comparison size of the amygdala was huge compared males of same age. It really does look like an almond...

Ariana is welcome to join us here too. I hope she gets downtime to process her trauma and recover.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom