righkindofme-I agree that ACOA's become parents and their children grow up as if raised in an alcoholic family. This is the typical situation, unless the ACOA make a real commitment to change. I had a daughter when I was 17 and was in an abusive marriage that I left when she was 6. All my sisters were older and their children older. I saw this happening in the absence of alcoholism. Rather than neglecting, there was doing things for kids that they should have been doing for themselves. I began learning about ACOA before having other children.
I went to counseling, read every book, did a ton of work. Basically, I threw out everything that I thought that I knew and re-learned. I came in real touch with my real feelings. I had a very safe environment and the benefit of the time to dedicate my life to this. I was determined to change the family cycle. I was very happy, healthy, and did not guess at normal. My whole life turned around from this work and I was so grateful. Then I had 2 more children. The changes were hard at first, but after awhile, they become very comfortable. My first does act like she grew up in an alcoholic family. My second two do not.
So all that counseling, individual and group, that was directed at ACOA, co-dependency, etc, and groups that members came from dysfunction, abuse and neglect was very helpful. It was the 80's and very popular and I still agree with the concepts. However, they did not address the abuse and neglect from a trauma standpoint. Early on, my therapist did say some symptoms were ptsd like. Looking back I can see where during those healthy years, there were a couple times triggers of trauma but extinguished pretty quickly.
It wasnt until my children were ready for college that things fell apart and the trauma came through. A divorce, an accident, in home assault. This led to full blown ptsd which I am told was always there but lying dorment. Childhood neglect and abuse led to choosing an abusive and addicted first husband. His drama led to a second husband that was unemotional but extremely stable and a good provider. Yet with growth, eventually one wants more from a marriage than safety and stability. When going out into the world, the trauma was unresolved and not processed adequately.
I think it is great to find anything that works, and if you try and it doesn't work, we just have to keep looking for something that does.