I need to go over this forum thoroughly. I just found this thread. I am always late to the party.
Anthony, your post is one of the most thoughtful and cogent posts I have read about the subject. So spot on. It is strange that I am excited by new situations but they always have an element of dread with them. I understand why. I did go through some EMDR but as you said, I have had multiple occurrences so I would have to go through a lot of sessions to get anywhere. As it was, I just covered the ones that sprang up from nowhere and could not process them without the EMDR. I am still so confused but no one would even know it to look at me.
I am still fascinated with how incidents, the small ones being the most overlooked and scary, come from nowhere. They are the ones that hang around for weeks afterwards, even years. And at times, they are innocent, for instance when I helped someone severely injured even if just to adjust a position to make him more comfortable after a long surgery and I had seen his internal organs shattered and pieced together. I knew he did not have long to live. Images like that linger for a while until you get busy and forget them, only to come up later at a time when you least expect them....