• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Guilt!

  • Post starter Post starter Deleted member 20072
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi

Who are we to judge? :)

I think It can be hard when you disclose things online because you are unable to see facial reactions. You could be projecting your own feelings onto others. A lot of us do this on here, do not worry :)

I hope you can continue to talk because we are all very supportive really, Promise :)

best wishes
Saffy :)
 
No, it's apparent that I'm not even entitled to be here. Being told by some random broad that I'm misdiagnosed and I had choices about something I opened up about with hesitation to begin with? No thanks. I'll go back to hibernating. You want to talk humane? How about letting the f*cking thing lay there and scream with one eye popped out of its skull bleeding to death. Would that have been humane? Lets see about what you'd do there if you are such a expert on doing everything perfect. You're mortified? What the f*ck do you think I am? No need to report huh? So this is acceptable? Bull shit.
 
Let us not forget that no body on here is a professional and can find some stories a trigger and react accordingly.

We are all going through our own personal trauma and each one differs from person to person.

Whilst disclosing things online is a brave and trusting thing to do it pays to remember that there will inevitibly be comments that you might not wish to hear.

We have to put it into perspective and think about why things are said and about the person saying them as well as how it affects us personally.

We then have a choice whether to take comments personally maybe because it hits a nerve for someone who is feeling intense guilt and self loathing over a traumatic event in their past? or to hear them in a less defensive or judgemental way and accept that for some parts what is said bears some truth in how the trauma would be perceived for what it was.

No one can be blamed for that.

On another side, some people already feel immense guilt over a traumatic event and it takes a while to disclose this to others. When they expect some respite from the guilt and infact get told what they already know in a judgemental way it is going to result in a negative disclosure.

We, I, understand what you must feel and in a perfect world you could have saved the dog and got it to a vet. Without being there I have no idea how I would have reacted. But like you my thoughts would have been to put the poor thing out of its misery. This is not an easy quest and once committed it seems best to carry on. If it is not put to sleep by the first attempt then what should you do, leave it in even more pain? Try again? If you left it to die slowly would you feel guilty about that too? The decision at the time must have been one of pain and anguish not pleasure or indifference.

However, given the topic we can also not be surprised that people find the act disgusting and barbaric. What matters is the motive and reasoning. I believe this was done with the best intentions at the time and I for one cannot judge anyone for it.

I hope this gets resolved so we can all move on in a more positive direction. :)

best wishes
Saffy :)
 
I KNEW I should not have read your post about what was done to that poor dog! :cry: What happened after the dog was hit by accident is criminal. I feel so sick about it that I am shaking.

They beat the dog. Then they bury the dog. See the dog is still possibly alive...but just watch it breathing under ground. Buried alive. This poor baby was tortured. :cry:
 
I've tried to read the DSM but I'm not qualified to apply the criteria let alone on limited information.

I do believe I understand the concept of life threatening, helplessness and horrific.

What I struggle with here is that while the situation would have been traumatic, and having run over an ex boyfriend's kitten, I have some appreciation of how dreadful such a situation feels including the guilt.

Where the line becomes fuzzy for me is beating the dog, supposedly badly injured. Yes the dog was suffering however to inflict cruelty to injury as a means of compassion doesn't sit well with me. Trying to break the dog's neck I can get my head around if knowing how to do it effectively (but couldn't even try that myself) but beating it with rocks is abuse and violence by my moral compass.

I see guilt here but is this PTSD I don't know. I do know if a friend was in a car accident I wouldn't be trying to kill them if badly injured - which is how I interpret the dog situation.
 
Just reading this thread about how an animal suffered like that makes my stomach turn and angers me. I don't need to read your original post or story to know how I feel about animal cruelty. To the original poster, you need to respect that people are going to have strong reactions. I suspect you knew that or you wouldn't have started this thread in the first place.
 
I didn't beat it with Rocks genius. Try reading what you're bitching about. And no you're not qualified so keep your mouth to yourself. I'm not here to argue with some chick who has no idea. Go and Make someone else feel like death so you feel better. I said I was sorry and I'd leave so move on. I couldn't be more sorry.
 
Try reading what you're bitching about. And no you're not qualified so keep your mouth to yourself. I'm not here to argue with some chick who has no idea. Go and Make someone else feel like death so you feel better
This is attacking a member of staff. Kindly discontinue this kind of out burst.
I said I was sorry and I'd leave so move on
That is your decision.[DOUBLEPOST=1369087256][/DOUBLEPOST]Please can we keep this thread civil. Otherwise it will be locked.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom