• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Holy Crap There Are Some Bad Therapists Out There

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not like he starts touching me, I tell him to stop, and he comes back 30 minutes and tries again. It's he starts touching me, I tell him to stop, and he refuses. He continues, I can push him away, try to move his hands, remove myself from the room, nothing helps--he just follows me, and doesn't stop. In his head, if I relent and say yes, I must actually enjoy it. But the opposite is happening.

This is wrong. If you can't say 'no' and have that respected, then you can never truly say 'yes.'

Part of the problem, though, is that his behavior keeps getting reinforced when you eventually give in. You and I understand the reasons you give in, but from a behavioral psych perspective, intermittent reinforcement (eventually giving into his repeated approaches even if it takes a while) is one of the most powerful conditioning schedules.

It's the same reason kids beg for so long and so hard in the checkout line at the grocery store--they've learned from experience that persistence pays off...eventually someone gives in just to shut them up, so they keep up the behavior that gets the result they want. The fact it takes so long gives them a lot of time to practice this behavior and train their brains to use this method to get this desire met. According to behavioral psych theory, his behavior would actually be weaker (occur less often and with less force) if you always gave in at the very first request (which is called continuous reinforcement).

I hate to boil this down to behavioral training, but there will have to be some respected "no's" in there somewhere, where you hold your boundary for as long as it takes until he accepts the 'no' and backs off. And going forward, you allow your 'yes' only within the first whatever-minutes.

Say you set a time limit for your own consideration process of 15 min...that's your window of opportunity to consider whether you're in the mood or have enough energy or whatever. Within that first 15 min, you can either say 'yes' or 'no'...up to you. Once 15 min has passed and you're still not wooed by his advances, then the answer is 'no'...period. 5 minutes or 2 hours of more pursuit will not change the answer from 'no.'

Unless he's getting violent with you, you do have the option to hold this kind of a boundary. He won't like it, and he'll try all of the tactics that have worked in the past and then he'll start getting "creative" and maybe even downright angry and mean, so be prepared emotionally and perhaps even leave the house if he keeps touching you (and certainly if you start feeling like you're in danger). But ultimately, the boundary is yours to hold, not his.

Of course, as a I say that, my stomach is rolling from 1) being so repulsed at his behavior towards you, and 2) being angry and disgusted at his T's responses to you. Boundaries and knowing how to hold them in a marriage are foundational concepts in relationship counseling. His T should have been willing to discuss this from a neutral position, asking for both parties' input and perspective, and encouraging open communication between you so that you both can voice your concerns. And then help each of you to see how you can contribute to finding solutions, learn a new approach to this old problem, etc. Just because there's trauma in your background doesn't mean you should have to steamroll over your own boundaries for the sake of his gratification.
 
I don't have any advice. But this is so similar to my marriage. I've been with my husband for 15 years and touch has not gotten any easier. My husband isn't forceful but he is persistent. Touch is his thing. And he will follow me around and almost corner me. I can give in if I've had a few drinks. Otherwise I shut down. It's very painful for both of us and I'm sorry you're going through this. The guilt I have felt is almost unbearable and if I felt further blamed by a T it would crush me. I admire how hard you're working at it. A third T sounds like a great option.
 
Thank you for this. There is an odd comfort in knowing that others are struggling with the same thing.

@DogwoodTree There is so much here that you said that true resonates, and thank you for your response. "If you can't say no, you can never truly say yes."
The psychology on how the award system works is definitely helpful and I will begin to apply it. Recently, I've just made myself 100% off limits and it's working well on my end, but it also makes me feel guilty and isn't realistic in the long run. And I agree, his behavior isn't okay, and his therapist's actions left me with my jaw dropped.

I met with my therapist yesterday and told her what happened. Her response when I told her that his therapist recommend I bring him into one of my sessions to deal with this topic was, "Oh you can bring him in here. We can have that discussion, I don't mind at all! He isn't going to like me though." lol. I'm not sure whether I want to drag him in there or not. She's made me cry once or twice in the past--but only with really good reason, my eating disorder had gotten dangerously out of control and I wasn't trying. So I know she can cut pretty deep with words if she thinks it will create the response she is looking for. And it is effective--her words still echo in my head when I start engaging in those behaviors and it usually provides enough guilt to stop. I shouldn't want to protect him, but for whatever reason I do. I guess, if things continue though, and my conversations with him don't help any, then I will drag him in there. But for now, I will avoid it.
 
@Leighlee87
Survivors of abuse must have control over sexual situations. That's what all my therapists have told me. That's what all the literature says. If they don't, they don't heal.

What your therapist said is true, your husband won't like her because she'll confront him on his behaviors.

At first I had guilt about saying no and creating impenetrable boundaries. Later though, I realized it was the only way I was going to heal from my abuse. It years for my husband to understand the need of mind to be in control. Period. No questions asked. No judgment.
 
I agree. What he's doing is wrong. It needs to stop. I'm glad your therapist is going to help you talk to him about it.

IF he is willing to acknowledge that he needs to change his behavior, and IF you believe the relationship is worth working for, I have a suggestion. I was very touch adverse for many years with my husband. Touch is very important to him. Hugely so. So we compromised: I touched him. He didn't get to touch me, but I touched him. I was in control. I was physically free, and it didn't trigger me. I would pet his hair, scratch his back, stroke his skin, touch him sexually if I was comfortable... being the one in control helped me a lot.

But he's going to have to give control to you before that could ever work. As long as he's being sexually aggressive with you that way, you're never going to be able to meet him halfway. I'm sorry he's being like this. Torturing you until you give in is definitely marital rape in my book.
 
I need to vent. Majorly.

So, my husband and I met with a marriage counselor a few years ago. I d...
I have always wondered if it is smart to have one counselor as a marriage therapist, because inadvertently someone might take the side of the husband or wife.
I think it may be smart to experiment with that sort of thing, because if the couple sees the same therapist the issues that are being faced by each human being themselves may not be worked out. I think in a marriage it is often forgotten that people are individuals and that they should only exist as a couple. I think that the individual has to be treated first and then any additional problems in a relationship can be tackled.

I am very lucky to not have had too many things happen that disturbed my own body image, including touch. I have no problems in that area but I think it would be very useful for you to first see a therapist by yourself on your own terms so you can work through your own individual challenges. There are some challenges that need to be faced by each individual by themselves first. At least that is what I think.
 
@Freedomfighter I agree, and it is something my therapist and I are working on extensively at the moment. I have my own therapist. My husband is seeing his own therapist who we happened to use as a marriage counselor a few years back. So our marriage counselor/ husband's therapist is a different individual from the one I see personally. The problem comes in that I need to heal my own trauma. He needs to work through his own issues, but also to learn sexual boundaries and what is/isn't acceptable in a relationship. The big issue being that I cannot heal my own trauma so long as his behavior persists.
 
I am having trouble understanding why your husband would want to touch you if he knows it causes you the flashbacks/pain. Why doesn't he want to work with you on overcoming it? For me, I didn't have any issues until the ptsd kicked in this year. What works for me might not be legal everywhere, but I figured out that if I drink and smoke some pot, when I feel a tinge of fear, my mind can handle it or just not care. (But I am not fully advocating those things especially since when they wear off I tend to feel too much) Also, I need to feel like I am in control. I have been avoiding doing things that match what was done to me. Also, I would think that professional therapists wouldn't take sides. They would help you see each other's needs and how to work through them both individually and together.
 
I need to vent. Majorly.

So, my husband and I met with a marriage counselor a few years ago. I d...
First lets deal with the language "what is normal" I understand his frustrations and i also understand your reluctance and trauma. Rape is a very traumatic act . Do you feel your husband is insensitive and selfish and abusive if not then it is not rape.

Have you discussed how you feel . Do you blame yourself for what happened to you and does your husband refuse to accept or understand how painful touching is for you?

Changing the subject is dismissive it's a problem it needs fixing .

You need to try and explain that rejection is not because you do not love your husband it's just to painful and is a trigger .

From what you have told me it would seem that your husband is not getting it. It would not appear from what you have told me he has raped you unless he forced you to have sex against your will and would not stop when asked due to your distress.

It is possible to overcome this but your husband feeling he has raped you or you feeling this to needs to be addressed .

Many in your situation have therapy which helps in removing this trauma. Showing affection and love can be demonstrated in many ways. Starting by holding hands then a cuddle maybe if possible spontaneous and preferably not in bed . Tell each other how much you love and share this but without pressure building bridges to knock down walls .

Remember this as it's important you are a survivor not a victim and seeing yourself as abnormal will only create guilt . You have nothing to be guilty for. You are a beautiful soul otherwise you would not be sharing here. Tell each other true love conquers all .

Some people confuse having sex as making love is what we call it . There does not have to be any love to have sex. Making love is a mood a moment when two hearts and minds come together as one. That is making love and it is a beautiful thing. I hope you can find a way
 
Last edited by a moderator:
First lets deal with the language "what is normal" I understand his frustrations and i also understand your reluctance and trauma. Rape is a very traumatic act . Do you feel your husband is insensitive and selfish and abusive if not then it is not rape.
Do I feel like he is insensitive and selfish? Yes. Abusive? No, because it isn't his intent. My perception of things may be off by my past. Is it rape if that isn't his intent? I'm not sure I would define it that since it wasn't his intent. Maybe molestation is a better word? I don't know, does that exist as a thing in a marriage?


"Normal" might be subjective, and what one person wouldn't mind having done to them might not be the same for another. Things I personally don't find acceptable is him grabbing my privates, trying to bypass my shorts to get where he is going while I'm trying to block him with my hand, rubbing himself on me, while I tell him no and try to move away from him. Meanwhile he keeps grabbing me so I can't get away, and pushing my hands away when I try to block him. He follows me around the house continuing to rub himself on me, and everytime I end up alone with him the behavior picks back up. The only way he will stop is to finally break down and have sex--which I make a point not to participate in more than necessary. He used to keep me awake until I caved--come to bed after midnight, start talking poking, prodding, grabbing, etc, and literally not stop In his head though, I do think he is convinced that since I give in, I actually want it. He also holds the belief that my body is his because we are married, and has told me such. I do not think he has any clue the violation I feel. And I'm not sure he understands truly why I don't like it. He would love for me to make a pass at him every time I pass by (or at least he thinks he would).

I've woken up to him touching me underneath my clothes, his fingers in me, etc. I have told him how much I absolutely hate it, I've told him not to do it again, how violated it makes me feel, it still happens. I wake up horrified every time.

Drunk, is a completely different animal. He's cornered me and tried to get my clothes off when the words were explicitly no. He was naked and covered in his own vomit. When I realized he wasn't going to let me go, I told him I would give him anything he wanted so long as he took a shower first. He thought for a second and said no. I then said to at least go brush his teeth first, which he agreed to. As soon as he went to the bathroom, I ran and grabbed the keys before taking off. I told him the story afterwards and he thought it was funny. I told him exactly how I felt in that moment, but he shrugged it off and continued to find amusement in it, because nothing ever actually came of it. We've had a couple similar drunk instances, but not to that level. He isn't allowed to drink around me anymore, but he thinks I'm being over the top and ridiculous. I'm not. I have no desire to ever get raped by my husband covered in his own vomit. And whether his intent would have been to hurt me or not, I think I would have categorized it as rape if it had occurred, and without a doubt it would have if I had stayed in the room or if he had decided not to brush his teeth.


Do I quantify that as rape? I'm not certain it does. I do think it crosses serious boundaries. I do think he does put his desires above mine. I can't overpower him to get what I want, nor would I.
Have you discussed how you feel . Do you blame yourself for what happened to you and does your husband refuse to accept or understand how painful touching is for you?
I blame myself for not expressing myself loudly enough and for giving in. That's on me, and probably gave off mixed messages. I have, up till this point, and even someone now, avoided telling him how much the sexual touch bothers me, because I've been afraid of hurting him. Except for the whole "while I'm sleeping" thing. I've been very explicit about my feelings towards that.

My reasons for not doing so are many. I've always been afraid that if I fight against him with everything I have and it doesn't stop that the feelings of violation and the level of hurt would be far greater than they are by giving in. So, my fear of being raped has led me to give into situations I very much didn't want to be in, so that I felt some type of control if that makes any sense at all. I'm scared of hurting his feelings because I know he feels rejected by my actions. I was raised by my father who is very much a narcissistic sociopath, and raised to protect my father from his own feelings. I always assumed that he meant well and didn't mean to hurt me, so I would put on an act, and not let him know how I felt. Looking back, my dad's behavior--from the emotional abuse to the physical abuse--was very intentional, and part of the enjoyment for him was in watching me try to cover it. I was raised to take the brunt of everyone's pain, and that it was my responsibility to protect everyone from being hurt, even if it meant taking on the responsibility--which was usually put on me by my parents anyways. I'm really just now beginning to understand these dynamics and how they play out in my other relationships and why my behaviors are the way they are. I know a lot of my behavior with my husband has been to cover my own pain to protect him.


I've been very vocal about my struggle with non-sexual touch. His needs consistently come before my own. It's like he can't understand or relate? Like, touch feels good and comforting for him and he can't understand how it could not for me. I've told him that I hyperventilate and panic when he does things like hug me while I'm facing in, him pushing me against corners, him wrapping himself around me when I try to move away. I literally fight against him, and freak out. The moment I feel physically restrained or trapped, it is triggering. Feeling like something is in my face (even his chest) is terrifying. I grew up in a home where my dad would intentionally suffocate me by covering his hand tightly against my mouth and nose as punishment if I screamed in pain as he beat me. This is something my husband has also been told. My husband's comment has been in the past that I'm going to learn to like it and that it isn't scary. When it comes to this stuff, I've been VERY, VERY communicative on the subject. I think it has more to do with the fact that my husband doesn't want to accept that touch is triggering. He has explained how great his need is, sorta like just needing a hug from someone, but never getting it. Except that it seems like he doesn't need that hug a couple times a day, he wants that physical touch almost constantly. He gets angry when I push away, even though I explain that it isn't rejection. I explain the physical responses to touch, that I want to provide him with what he is asking for, but that I can only do so for so long before I need to pull away. It has nothing to do with him or my love for him. It has been explained until I'm blue in the face. He has stated that he knows this on a logical level, but emotionally it doesn't compute--he still reacts, still hurts, and still grabs ahold of me because of it.
It is possible to overcome this but your husband feeling he has raped you or you feeling this to needs to be addressed
I've not told him that this is how I feel. He understands that I don't necessarily like it. But he puts himself above my discomfort. I've avoided telling him that I feel incredibly violated by his behavior or that it has felt traumatic for me. I'm afraid to hurt him or make him feel guilty. I honestly don't think his intentions have been to hurt me. He's just been unable to relate, and I haven't been forward enough in the past. I completely blame myself in that regard and it's why I don't want him to know. I have more recently explained that the more he forces touch on me when I don't want it, the further I withdraw.
Many in your situation have therapy which helps in removing this trauma. Showing affection and love can be demonstrated in many ways. Starting by holding hands then a cuddle maybe if possible spontaneous and preferably not in bed . Tell each other how much you love and share this but without pressure building bridges to knock down walls .
This is where we are at, and where the struggle is at the moment. He has finally taken a hands off approach. But he is very frustrated and somewhat angry that I'm not initiating the amount of touch he wants or needs. He gets incredibly frustrated by the boundaries I've placed up--like how I'm hugged for example (this one makes him really mad for whatever reason), or that he isn't allowed to hold me tightly, etc. He wants it to be completely spontaneous. He wants to be able to touch me in most ways, have it eagerly accepted, and reciprocated. It's not realistic, I think he is learning that just now, but it doesn't make him any less frustrated. He very much voices his frustration and annoyance with me in this manner. I think he thought that if he just stopped touching, then I would immediately jump in and not be hesitant at all. Like all the physical touch he craves would be there, and there would be an abundance of sex in his life. I think his therapist has been unaware the extent of the damage that has been done in our relationship--largely due to not communicating with one another on this topic. I feel it has left them both feeling as if I'm being very insensitive and uncaring to his needs. When in reality, I'm trying very hard to do what he is asking and to make strides in this direction. I feel like the steps forward that I have been made, aren't really noticed in his eyes. He thinks they are petty and insignificant, and therefore, I'm not trying, when in reality I'm very scared as I'm doing these things. I'm trying to be brave, and I'm being told I'm selfish. It hurts.

A lot of this is me, and my trauma that makes me over-react to the situation. I just need space to sort through this. A lot of what has been going on, has kinda been because I'm digging up a lot of things from my past in therapy. I've worked really hard to avoid these memories and stuff them down, to pull them out and explore them is like pulling off bandaids. My therapist has told me that the entire reason we were doing emdr in the first place is so that I wouldn't feel this way (in terms of the relationship difficulties it has had). I have gone through 6 months of emdr off and on to sort through the recent trauma between my myself and my dad. It is what caused me to cut ties. But the abuse of that event was purely psychological. I didn't directly take on the abuse I went through growing up, or the rape that occurred several years ago (which I've still neglected to tell her--I've frozen up every time I've tried.) I know therapy will get me through this. I do want the kind of physical relationship that is healthy and "normal". But it takes time.


I don't know. I'm so confused and lost on this topic. I don't even know where to begin. I know how it has made me feel and the negative effect it has had. I'm frustrated by all of it. But mostly, I'm frustrated that I tried to bring it up, and have it approached, and it was shot down.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
@Leighlee87 - I would not try and deal with any of this on your own at this point. You need a really good marriage/family therapist. It sounds like your husband is building up resentment/frustration, and you are as well. I'm really glad he's stopped just forcing himself on you. I've been there, and it's a horrible feeling. My fear is that, without a therapist really guiding the two of you on communication skills and trust-building, the situation won't improve and may go back to what it was before.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom