I wanted to say thanks to everyone for their insights and sharing their own stories :) Specifically, thansk toAnthony for your insight on teh behavior. I think ti explain a lot. Especially because I noticed that he doesn't cut off communication completely.
Last weekend didn't totally go well and aside from being busy, I took a few days to think about things and let events unroll before I wanted to talk about it here. I apologize in advance that everytime I share a personal story it's like a novel.
Just in case it wasn't obvious, I was pretty anxious after last Friday's incident. I couldn't decide if he was being controlling/possessive/jealous or just overreacting (I feel that he tends to feel perceived abandonment and discourtesy very strongly therefore react very strongly too). When we kind of talked about it on Saturday I found out that he seemed to have thought I was changing my plans to hang out with my friends completely, but my intention was really only to cancel dinner with them but I'd planned to hang out later that night still.
Anyway. We went to the wedding on Sunday and at first it was okay. We were there early and I introduced him to my two friends who were also there early. We talked for a little while until my other friends showed up, at which point things started going downhill.
Throughout the night, I could tell things weren't quite right. To add to things, his left knee and foot were bothering him a lot because of past injuries. Around 9:30 I could tell he wanted to leave and since I wasn't totally having fun and feeling comfortable, I decided it was time to leave.
On the way back he started telling me that he felt most fo my friends (except for the first two he met) were rude because they ignored him when he tried to talk and they were being very exclusive. To be honest, after so many incidents where I questioned whether he was trying to isolate me, I immediately did not take well to his criticisms of my friends. But more importantly, I tend to be very forgiving of people and I make excuses for everyone. I could see that yes, my friends were being knid fo exclusive, but it was because it was like a mini reunion--we all went to the same college--and this was the first time we'd all been gathered at one place in 5 years. So yes, everyone was busy catching up and talking to each other.
The other thing about him is, he often picks out things about people that he can make jokes about and he did this all night (mostly just to me because he didn't want to be overbearing with his jokes in front of my friends) and some of them were directed at my friend the bride and her husband. The jokes don't immediately offend me because I have seen that he does this to everyone.
As he talked about how he badly he felt he was treated, I could tell he was pretty miffed about it. I didn't know what to say because 1) I felt he was overreacting 2) I didn't know how to tell him that without making it sound like I'm dismissing him 3) I've never been in an argument like this with a significant other. He became increasingly agitated by the fact that he felt he was talking to himself because I was mostly silent. I could tell he wanted me to say I would let my friends know that they were being rude because he wanted to know that I cared that he was being treated badly. Problem was, again, I felt he was overreacting, I do feel more loyalty towards my friends just because I've known them longer and I KNOW they're not rude people normally, so I felt stubborn about it. I didn't want to "give in" because in teh back of my mind I kept trying to analyze the situation and if I was being manipulated.
At one point after 2 hours, I said something--and I can't remember what I said--and he said, "Oh good, some attitude about what happened tonight." He got up and packed up his stuff and left the hotel room. Some minutes went by before he came back to grab one more thing and then he spent about 15 minutes giving me a piece of his mind and saying some mean things, during which time I said nothing. Eventually he left.
At this point, I figured we were breaking up. When he got home, we exchanged some texts. He sounded angry and bitter. He doesn't have a substance abuse problem (we've hung out enough that I am absolutely certain of this) but he does resort to drinking himself to sleep when he is overwhelmed by stress. From I could tell, these stressors are usually break ups. I knew he had a paper due on Thursday which I had helped him with on Saturday, so I told him good luck on his paper. He said he wasn't going to work on the paper at all and is going to drop his classes because he can't concentrate on school when he is stressed. I tried to let him know that he was a good person and I told him not to piss everything away.
We exchanged more texts in the morning. Again, I figured the relationship was over, I eventuallyt old him that I didn't feel we were compatible and I wasn't sure I could be what he watned me to be. He called me then, sounding upset that I was so ready to give up. I told him I don't see how he could still like me after some of the things he'd said the night before. I forget what all we talked about, but I let him know that I would talk to my friends about it because I do agree they weren't totally welcoming. Eventually he asked me if I wanted anything from him, because if not, then there was no reason for me to talk to them.
We decided to keep working on the relationship and he would not do anything crazy--like dropping his classes. On Tuesday he asked me to read over what he has written for his paper so far, revise it and he would finish it up. Maybe he was passively threatening with the dropping classes thing? But I know from his records that he's gotten a lot of bad grades because of stressors causing him to quit school/classes. So I don't believe he idly threats with it.
Later that day, I talked to two of the friends. One of them said he understood where my bf was coming from and wanted to apologize. The other one did not agree with that and said that they had gotten a bad vibe from the guy and they felt his jokes were inappropriate (he did tell some). And I could see where she was coming from too. I apologized for any awkwardness and I felt I did my job at conveying my bf's sentiments. He accepted my way of dealing with it but he said if my friends were ever rude to him again, he would speak up.
Oh, I forgot to mention. He had texted me after the phone call that he cared a lot about me and that he didn't mean the mean things he said, that picking people apart was his defense mechanism. That was something I knew early on and even though I had kind of forgotten, I tuned him out when he said them the night before because I knew I wasn't going to let him mess with my head if that's what he was trying to do. He never said similar things to me before and if he ever talked about an ex gf's flaw, he would always assure me not to be self-conscious about it because he didn't see that in me. So, I decided to forgive him for that. I don't like that he does that but for this incident, I can forgive. It definitely went in my possible "red flag" box though.
So to sum everything up. Basically ever since I have been in constant state of questioning myself. I keep analyzing every little thing, looking for signs. I know that if I were not in the relationship, I would be very concerned. My friends have told me to be careful. I also know that it's impossible for me to be objective in this but he is a wonderful person when he's not stressed out. It's hard to tell how much is a "reasonable" response to perceived stressors and how much is not. From what he's told me, I can tell he's come a long way since he first realized he has PTSD and he didn't blame others for the wrong things he's done because of his suffering. It just seems to me that he gets frustrated and stressed out easily and when that happens, he can overreact (or at least that's how I perceive it).
He doesn't try to dress me, prevent me from hanging out with my friends when I tell him my plans in advance, and I never think he will hit me. But he doesn't want to hang out with my friend because of Sunday and honestly, even though I know my friend will not say no to him hanging out with us, I'm pretty sure it would be uncomfortalbe (she's the one whose 6th-sense instinct told her I should be careful around him). But, like I said, at least he's not telling me not to hang out with her.
We hung out yesterday and I kind of tested him by sharing a story about my male coworker and I, to see how he would behave. His response was normal, so I feel encouraged by it. So for now, I am going to try to be positive, but vigilant. I think I am a little terrified of becoming a victim--plus I keep thinking about my friends' comments--so I might be messing with my own head a little bit.
We are supposed to go to the Renaissance Faire on Saturday, something I think he might be doing mostly because I seem so interested, so I think that's a good sign.
Anyhow. I told you it would be long. I appreciate any of you who read through it :)