• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

I Hate My Therapist. Advice Please?!

Status
Not open for further replies.

HAlex

New Here
So I have seen my therapist a few times, and I actually hate her.

Every single time I have been to see her, she tells me that people have much worse problems than me.

Of course I know there is plenty if people out there who are suffering, but I feel like she is belittling my problems and it makes me feel needy and annoying.

She also suggests things that I don't think are right, and then when I try and explain why I don't agree she just says she doesn't understand my point.

I don't feel like she is helping me at all!, but because I see her for free on the NHS, I'm not sure how to ask to see someone else?

Advice would be hugely appreciated!
 
Who referred you to her? It's difficult with the NHS, but if you really feel you can't work with her, you can go back to whoever referred you and explain that you want to see someone else. You may find yourself back at the bottom of a waiting list again though as a result. :-/
 
Definitely get a new therapist. Anyone who belittles your issue is not helping you.

My first therapist did this. "It couldn't have been that bad" he said. So for 10 +years I tried to believe him. The problem was, it was that bad. And his saying otherwise only delayed getting the help I needed and made me deny the abuse. I never told anyone, even my husband, because I knew "it wasn't that bad" because he told me so.
 
I don't think that is very good of her to tell you that others have worse problems. Its sort of a big DUH, because if you think about it, there will always be someone who has it worse than you....well, unless you're the one person on the planet who really does have it worse than everyone else, but fortunately, that's not you. (Conversely, there is always someone who has it better than you....) So my point is that this sort of talk isn't going to move you forward. I have a feeling that along with it comes the "just get over it attitude...." as in, "others have it worse than you, so just get over it already!"

I'd end up snapping on her with a condescending "DUH, I KNOW others have it worse than me, but that doesn't mean that I don't have problems to work through!" But of course, I am not advising you to do this. I think you really should look into getting a new therapist, even if it does put you at the bottom of the waiting list.
 
Yep, a new therapist is called for. You may want to mention that having PTSD isn't a contest to see who has the worst case of it. So what if someone has it worse? Is that supposed to mean you don't need help? Sounds like more than a training issue; sounds like a basic personality issue. Sometimes I wonder what draws some people to become therapists.

Yes, there are always people worse off. Then again some are better off. Two people that experience the same traumatic event may go off on different trajectories: one with PTSD, one without. None of that changes the fact that you would like to have a better life given your unique situation.
 
Goodness yes, a new therapist even if you end up at the bottom of the list and have to wait. Continuing to see this person would do a lot more harm than good.

Of course there are people with problems / issues / situations than yours...but that does not make your problems / issues and situations less valid! Ironic for me to say, because I keep everything to myself..I don't want to burden people with what is going on cause I figure they have their own problems. But when you are speaking to a T, you should be able to feel safe to express yourself without this sort of judgmental nonsense.
 
Anyone who degrades you and diminishes your suffering isn't a human being, still less should they be allowed to be a therapist in my not-so-humble indignant opinion.

The background is that the government rushed to create more access to therapy and pushed thousands of people - almost off the street - into short training courses to be 'therapists' providing short bursts of 'therapy'. We are now counting the cost....

I've been through the mill with NHS therapists. 3 out of 4 seriously poor. The first was so abusive that I took legal action, proved the abuse and won. The second was very good - so good that sadly she left the NHS and set up in private practice. The third, 3 years waiting later was, frankly, a total full-of-himself tosser - I stopped seeing him after 4 sessions. The fourth, only 4 months later, was an ineffectual, wishy-washy new-man type who was quite defeatist and just didn't grasp the issues. I am now waiting for yet another 'review'. Only the good therapist realised that I needed a longer period of proper therapy than the kwik-fix short burst.

My point is that it's very possible to change therapist. And it's essential when they show themselves as negligent or abusive or even just plain stupid. If I may give some advice in the strongest possible terms I'd say that it's equally essential to voice record each session. Those therapists who refuse are not worth sticking with. The good ones will suggest it before you do!


Also a note about 'hating' your therapist @HAlex .... to say that you 'hate her' makes it sound like the problem is in you. But, actually, if someone is putting you down in any way, the problem is in THEM! I wonder if what you're feeling is an entirely normal reaction of disgust and self-protection?

This subtle re-framing could have quite an impact if/when you ask for a new therapist... if you say to your GP or whoever, "I hate that therapist you sent me to, please refer me to another" the GP may assume you're being awkward or whatever (perhaps because you're 'mentally ill' and 'can't appreciate' the treatment etc) and may resist referring you on.

If you locate the problems, correctly, in the therapist's attitudes and give a few specific details then the GP will be deterred from thinking you're at fault and will be better disposed to find you a new therapist (e.g. "I've had x(number) of sessions with the therapist now and
1. from the start in each session she tells me that other people are worse off than me;
2. on x(number) of occasions she's bluntly stopped me from speaking about the trauma I've suffered and the ongoing effects;
3. makes inappropriate suggestions such as xxxx.

It's increasingly apparent that she doesn't understand PTSD and doesn't seem to be able to listen accurately. So I believe it would be a waste of my time and hers to continue to see her. I don't want to add to my negative experiences. Please could you refer me on to someone who has more experience with PTSD?")


It's about managing your GP or whoever's responsible for referrals.

PS. As an NHS patient you/we all have a right to be treated with respect and compassion, and to receive the best possible treatment. We don't have to put up with disrespect and wrong treatment just because we think it's 'free' so we should just be grateful for crumbs. The fact is that the NHS is NOT FREE. Every single adult pays taxes in some form or other, a large amount of which goes to the NHS.
 
Last edited:
My vote is also to wait for a new T. If it was me, this one would do more damage than any potential good.

This subtle re-framing could have quite an impact if/when you ask for a new therapist
Excellent suggestion !

Maybe you could add to you list..."We are having difficulty communicating...when I try to explain something, she frequently says that she doesn't understand me and does not seem to want to understand" (assuming that is true, I'm guessing a bit).
 
The therapeutic relationship is more important than the therapy itself in terms of outcomes. If you hate them, fire them. You wouldn't keep going back to a restaurant with bad service and the same rule applies to therapists and other health care providers. If you have the strength and time perhaps send them a letter later on and explain why you fired them - it might prevent someone else going through the same grief.

Totally agree regarding going back to the referrer, and yes definitely specifically ask for someone with significant experience working with trauma. I feel being specific regarding whether you are seeking treatment for chronic or acute PTSD would also be helpful as the methods employed can be quite different.

Finding a therapist that matches you can be challenging but it's worth it :)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom