@Solara, I guess I could have made it clearer.
It's clear that each relationship is unique, so what works in one won't work in another.
If the supporter doesn't try any kind of reaching out, then they've already failed because they have joined into the self-persecution of PTSD. That's my point, and it applies to any situation. We say it all the time to college students, failing to try is, by default, failure. Better to try and fail, then always wonder.
When people generally push me to have contact with them, I feel intense nausea and panic, making me even less able to tolerate their presence. So no, I am not "different" in that sense. In fact I think I'm a control freak, and that has not improved, as I obsessively try to make my world feel less dangerous.
No, this is just what happens when the right person with exceptional qualities applying himself to the challenge of being in love with a freak like me actually succeeds in putting in the time, energy, and commitment to finally win some trust.
Do I think it will work for everyone most of the time, Not at all. But I don't ever say just give up right away at the first sign of a challenge.
But if she doesn't try, how's that gonna work out for her?
Maybe we should be honest and tell her that he'll push back? And it will be up to her to be able to hold her own and show him or her what she's made of?
I guess that's more than right of you, and fair, to admit.
I pushed mine back, too, Solara, and gave him hell. I won't repeat my words. I tested him real good until I saw that wasn't what I really wanted to do to either of us anymore. I don't know if that makes sense, but it's how I see it.