• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

To Feel Or Not To Feel

  • Post starter Post starter Deleted member 18673
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Deleted member 18673

I have started going to a therapist again recently in effort to overcome my depression and anxiety and deal with the traumas of my childhood.

I survived a horrifically abusive childhood. We were starved, tortured, deprived of school and medical care, and largely kept away from society. After several failed escape attempts, I finally managed to escape in 2009 and rescued my two younger brothers along with me. This December will mark four years of freedom. But I still struggle with depression, anxiety/panic, and post-traumatic stress disorder.

I've begun seeing a new therapist since my old one moved to a different city. My old therapist was very well versed in Zen and Middle-Path Buddhism, and we concentrated most of my therapy on acceptance and finding the middle path. I concentrated on the understanding of the primal animal nature of man, and understanding that whatever drove my mother to do the things she did – whether it was sociopathy or mental illness – that whatever was wired differently about her neurobiology was out of her own control and she could only do that which was in her nature – even if it was cruel. The same as wolves kill and mosquitoes spread malaria and tsunamis destroy coastlines, I viewed her as a force of nature which was neither good nor evil. She was not something to be hated, but accepted as a part of what is. I based all my work with my old therapist in letting go of negative emotion and accepting my past and present exactly as they were.

My new therapist seems more grounded in traditional therapy and believes I need to feel and express all my emotions – anger, grief, etc in order to move forward. She says it doesn't matter what my mother 's psychological problems were, that what she did was still wrong and I have every right to be angry. She wants me to write an angry letter to my mother (but not send it, of course). She feels as though trying to deny or rationalize away emotions is harmful to my recovery. Spent that day being angry – which really ended up with me being hurt that neither of my parents loved me, and feeling grief at being cheated out of the past and present I feel I should have had.

I feel that with a normal family I would have had better education, would have already graduated college or university, and would already have a career. I feel that I wouldn't have all the problems I do. That I would be so much further in life. As of right now, I have been in and out hospitals and in and out of jobs because of depression, panic attacks, self-harm, eating disorders, substance abuse which all stem from post traumatic stress disorder.

Every time I have been doing well – have been holding down a job, have been ready to live on my own in a big city – I've relapsed and lost everything: had to quit work, be hospitalized, and move back in with my brothers.

I take stock of my life at this moment and this is what I see: I am 26 years old and I sleep on my brother's couch. I have no bed and no room of my own. I work at a fastfood restaurant, proverbially 'flipping burgers' and barely earn enough money to get by. I have no post-secondary education, no career, and neither the money nor the motivation to make any of my dreams come true – I no longer believe they will come true no matter what I do; I feel like I will never escape this cycle of suffering and that life will always hold me back and beat me down; I feel like I have been damned since the moment I was born. I am angry at my mother for all this, angry at life, angry at all the people who never rescued us or never realized anything was wrong, angry even at all the people around me who have been through less suffering than I have. I feel full of rage and bitterness and grief and disappointed and most of all I feel cheated.

This is not a zen way of viewing the world. I want to let go of my anger and hurt and trauma. I want to accept everything that was and is, and I want to stop viewing my future with such doom and negativity and self-defeating rhetoric. I feel like this should be done by logically and rationally finding the philosophical reasons why I should not be angry, etc.

But maybe zen is to accept all these feelings and allow them to be there? Should I be striving to rid myself of them or striving to feel them? I am very confused as to which path to take.
 
Live and learn. Never forget, but strive to have a positive future. Learn from the hardship and the mistakes of others.

Do not let them grind you down, or make you feel bitter pain or negativity for then they have won!

Anger is a natural survival technique, but only for actions or settings that are here and now. To feel angry at the past is not a good thing, for it is something that we cannot change.
 
I had no quality of life when I didn't feel. I could only begin to heal when I would feel. I could still practice acceptance even though the feelings hurt. I could begin to let go once I could feel it.

Acceptance is a daily practice for me. Not feeling was very detrimental to my life. I think - at least for me - that a person can practice acceptance and understanding if they want to at the same time as they feel the human feelings that were a natural reaction to the trauma. I couldn't release the trapped trauma emotional energy unless I felt it.
 
Acceptance is only part of the battle and I feel you are viewing it as winning the war. Many different kinds of traditional therapy have acceptance as part of their teachings. Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) come to mind. But, neither of these therapies focus on acceptance with the belief that simply accepting will heal all. DBT uses acceptance as a way to move out of the realm of denial. ACT says we must accept and deal with the original source of pain in order to move forward.

I'm not knocking Buddhism as it has validity, however I worry that all this focus on simply accepting isn't giving you the true healing that you need in that you're not processing what happened or dealing with your (valid) feelings.
 
What we think and what we feel are often at odds. I fully understand your need to let go of the anger, but unfortunately you can't do it cognitively - you have to feel it before you'll be able to let go of it. You simply can't THINK your emotions away, although I so badly wish we could :(.
 
I have to tell you that I really, really relate to your story. I was raised in a cult where I was abused in just about every way possible and was finally able to escape in Nov 2009. Unfortunately, my 4 younger siblings are still stuck there. For the 12 years I was trapped in the cult, I couldn't feel any of my feelings--it wasn't safe or allowed. Then, for the first 3.5 years, I avoided my feelings in the classic way.

Now, I'm finally starting to try to feel my feelings...and it's utterly terrifying. But I personally do believe it is necessary to feel them. They are confusing as hell since I don't even know what they are-just that they are there. I put them all in my stomach before, and I struggled with and continue to struggle with digestive issues. I'm 25, and I feel like I could have and should have done so much more than I have. I am graduating college next year, but I do find myself wondering if the struggle is ever going to go away.

I'm moving for the 7th time since I moved out. I don't know if I'll ever be able to put down roots, and the black hole of pain seems like it might suck me in and never let me out. So I'm utterly terrified to go down that way. But what I do know is that I have a ton of grief, anger, sadness, fear, and whatever else to express. It's all been locked up in inside for years. And locking it up hasn't helped me. It's made it drag on and on, feelings seeping out sometimes and then just smoldering.

So now, I'm taking the risk. I'm letting myself feel the feelings. It's scary, for I feel as if I've removed my finger from plugging up the hole in the dike of emotional waters, and the waters are starting to break free...they may well overwhelm me. And then when they flow away from me, will I be swept away with them? Or when they leave, I will be faced with the emptiness of the dike--the canal that defined me for so long...will that emptiness eat me alive? Or will I be able to fill my heart and soul with what I want to? Will there be room in my heart for others finally? Will I find freedom in this quest? I honestly don't know. But what I do know is that I have to risk it and at least try it. I'm praying that I'll find further healing, but I don't know if that'll happen. But I'm going to step out and try.

I don't know if I really have advice for you; but what I think is that each person will come to a point, a crossroads, as it were, with the decision to either stay where you are or embark on a path of seemingly greater pain in the uncertain hope of a better future. I came to that point, and staying where I'm at is no longer an option. Each person's timeline is different, and maybe you're not at that point, or perhaps you may decide differently than I have.

I hope that you find healing and I'm proud of you for getting out when you did--and for getting siblings out with you. I wish I had been able to. You're very brave and strong for doing what it took. And don't come down hard on yourself for where you are at in life--you are having normal reactions to abnormal circumstances. We don't have the same sort of timeline as people with more "normal" lives that weren't filled with trauma. So we react differently and have different challenges. But we'll come out stronger in the end. I have to believe that.
 
Noah - it's so good to hear from someone who can relate.

I didn't get all my siblings out. The youngest was returned to my mother by social services as part of their 'family reunification' protocol. I have no contact with that sibling and it eats at me constantly. I can't imagine leaving behind four. But I understand the deep pain you must be feeling.

Thank you for your response, gives food for thought.
 
I agree with much that has been said here by others. Acceptance has been life changing for me and I can understand your need not to go into the anger or pain but I do think your new therapist has a point.

The trouble is that truly letting it go on a deep level normally requires us processing it first. In DBT radical acceptance has a a dual nature where we don't waste energy or intensify the feeling by fighting it but we do still work on resolution. I have read that we tend to internalise the self hatred and shame until we are able to put it where it belongs and process that. Until then we tend to go around in cycles of self hatred and shame and stay stuck and I know that has been true for me.

Very sorry to hear your youngest sibling was sent back.
 
Welcome to the forum, conquer. I like your user name.

I can relate in that I have a metaphysical approach to healing (not specifically Buddhism). I've experienced childhood trauma and adult trauma, and it has been a particular tension with childhood trauma. I've learnt a lot about acceptance, compassion and forgiveness but I can't go straight to that because of my feelings about childhood trauma and the need to process that.

I think processing trauma and allowing negativity, despair etc comes first. The letting go, non-attachment, compassion, understanding and forgiveness for the perpetrators comes some time later. However, the compassion, understanding and forgiveness for ourselves is at the forefront.

I posted recently in a different thread, that I think following a spiritual system as a trauma survivor is different from other people following that spiritual system. Healing from trauma has it's own particular spiritual path, and we need to do some work prior to being able to following general spiritual guidelines. That initial work involves things that may seem contrary to the usual teachings - for example, feeling hurt, angry, resentful and in pain, and honouring that.

To me, this is part of spiritual healing, because I see woundedness as part of my spiritual journey. It's only a stage along the way, I don't think I'm meant to stay in woundedness. But I think I'm meant to spend some time there, because it's understanding the woundedness and then moving to healing which has opened me up spiritually. If I tried to bypass the woundedness, my personal view of myself is that I would be missing perhaps the most important part of my individual spiritual path.

I think what your therapist asked you to do in writing the letter sounds very healthy to me. I think your feelings around doing that sound painful but part of the necessary processing. I have a spiritual approach but I also think trauma has to be processed to some extent on a purely psychological level.

If we're spiritual beings having a human experience, then my view is that we need to have the human experience. Not get stuck there, but not try to skip past it either. And trauma is a huge human experience, that takes some time to work through on a human level. I think it's good to honour and work with that human level of trauma experience first.
 
Conquer, my childhood was similar in trauma, with the exception that my mother an Phd, MD, LCSW, did everything right under everyone's nose believing, based on the Polgar sisters, that early childhood structure would yield the optimal or desired result in a child. Basically she did out my childhood a clinical thesis.

I escaped by 14 but my fight has been to fight structure and a robotic approach to life. To fight what was programmed in me. While you had a systematic chaos I was very much your antithesis, and while I can "hold down a job" and have 3 degrees I am as broken and emotional useless (if not broken) as you. Often times spending times wasting away time in healing masquerading all pain and symptoms with busy work. My self medication is an incandescent need to succeed and "win" medals or prizes, because without them I find my self worthless, yet every prize I have I had thrown it away because I feel I truly do not deserve it. See my mother instilled in my perfection was normal and everything else was failure.

I am telling you this to let you know the other side of the coin can be just as bad. But you must somehow while trying to heal understand that your self worth is big, and the feelings of insecurities that you have, the self steem that was robbed from you and which you feel its absence when you feel inadequate while studying (because deep inside you say " i am not like the others") you must work through them. You must become a mental mother for you and say "its ok to fail," and "you can do it, you are smart enough." I have to mother myself, almost every day.

You in trying to accept what what done and coping with it, you are rewiring the preset emotional and social rules that were set in you during that time either by your self defense mechanism or trauma itself. Whether you chose the path of buddhism or a new modern approach you will in the end unravel the twisted ideas/feelings you carry.

I believe a Zen approach is only understood, or carried successfully, once you have done a great deal of healing, because to forget and forgive is difficult. Part of modern therapy is to desensitize you to triggers and emotions to get you to talk about them and revisit them to fully understand what happened. I do not think Zen has such structured to see you through it. When I competed and was in Japan all I knew about zen was that we routinely would get hit while meditating, and though I could meditate and blank my mind I was still very much traumatized.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom