Hi Kunoichi,
I've just been reading through all the posts on this topic and am delighted to read that you really liked your therapist.
I am a therapist, and am in therapy too, and I recently went back to therapy after a break since my last moved away. Even though it's my job and I've been in therapy lots, it was still very scary meeting this new guy for the first time (first male therapist too). The thing that helped me, was giving myself permission to have an opinion on him! I always say to new clients that the most important thing is that they feel a 'click' with me, that they feel that potentially, I might be someone they can trust - and that if they don't feel that 'click' then that's ok, and I ask them to really listen to that. We don't expect to be friends everyone we meet so why would we expect to necessarily like and trust a random therapist, even if they come recommended.
Anyway, I decided to try my own advice (great at dishing it out, not always so great at actually doing it myself!) and just check out what my 'click-o-meter' was telling me. I noticed that I was a lot less anxious after about 10 minutes. Decision made, then and there.
The hard part if you have PTSD can be to get past all the jumble of anxiety and self-doubt to be able to listen to your instincts about someone. The relationship itself is everything in therapy, that's where healing happens - well, that's my opinion I guess, it might not be everyone's - so if that's not right, I'd be looking elsewhere. But you sound happy so, best of luck to you on this exciting journey.