• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Boundaries, Communication, And My Own Desperation

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kintsugi

Sponsor
Yesterday my therapist seemed to come to the verge of tears when talking to me.

She is terrified for me, and she didn't mince words much in telling me how deeply concerned she is.

And she isn't the only one.

Two and a half weeks ago, I picked up my biological brother and his girlfriend from the town they live in to come live in my town. I already had a place I was about to move into, I still had my old place... everything was all paid up for the following--whatever--25 days or so except electricity, which I needed to pay my balance for any which way.

My biological brother and I have had almost no relationship in the time I've known he existed, which has been since I was eighteen. We have four other siblings, two 'full-blooded' siblings and two half siblings. I was the only one who was adopted out, at very early infancy--about two weeks old--and I didn't know I had siblings at all until I was seventeen.

Since meeting him and three of my older siblings, I've been able to spend very little time with them. My brother in particular has been difficult to see, because for most of that time he has lived a very far way away with our biological father (both of our parents are dead now).

His girlfriend had really severe PTSD. You could tell. She was diagnosed and medicated with drugs that were consistent with acute PTSD symptoms from my understanding of what people here are prescribed. I don't doubt she had it. It was pretty apparent.

I landed her a job here immediately. I could have given said job to my brother, instead, but because of her anxiety, I decided she was a better candidate, because it was perfectly suited to someone who didn't want to interact with the general public and an easy job.

Four days into working, she disappeared during a smoke break. Spirited away, back from whence she came.

Their relationship was suspect, though I wasn't expecting that. She'd done it several times before in their short relationship. I know from being here that such random and seemingly extreme disappearing acts are not unheard of. I wasn't extremely sorry to see her go. I was mostly frustrated that she soiled my name at that workplace and that I could have gotten that job for my brother instead.

My brother wants to work. And he is trying. I don't doubt that he wants a job. He has a lot counting against him in some ways, and it's easy but not always outstandingly easy to get a job in this town.

When I go to work, I always let him have my car. Sometimes I let him have it overnight. He has free use of everything at my old place, which again is completely paid for, and I've been making sure he has food and tobacco, even though I swore I wouldn't support tobacco, alcohol, or other substance habits when he and his girlfriend got here, because those are luxuries I wouldn't ask other people to pay for when they're already providing me with every necessity and then some.

Okay. Fine.

I have learned that his perspective socially/interpersonally is completely alien from my own, and I wanted my T's help sorting out if that was a cultural difference, a Simon issue, or a real and valid phenomenon that was indicative of a lack of regard or respect for me.

Unfortunately, my T emphatically extrapolated why she felt strongly that is was the last of these things.

She started bringing up lots of things that made too much sense, and it was really difficult for me to take in.

She told me that

  • He was acting like someone at least seven years his junior
  • He did not seem to emotionally/interpersonally develop past adolescence
  • He was a user, and he was bringing to the table a set of tricks and trappings that I was not equipped to cope with or address, that no one was equipped to cope with or address
  • He did not want to further his relationship with me; he wants to find a new person to enable his lack of responsibility and maturity
  • I was perfectly ripe for being taken advantage of by such a person
  • I am in severe and imminent danger of retraumatizing myself (because my primary abuser is my [adoptive] older brother)
  • The only way in which she realistically sees this situation being an emotionally corrective experience is that those around me are willing to point out, name, and call for action on my brother misusing me
  • We had already established a faulty and abusive dynamic wherein I was being put in the very unfair position of a parent figure to my older brother
I didn't even share half of my concerns with her, and this is the sort of feedback I was generating. She became visibly upset about how dangerous this situation is for my mental health and healing. She was quite clear that she was making a number of assumptions, but she made so much sense, it was impossible to deflect a single crumb of it as paranoia or having the wrong idea on her part.

It's not that I don't see red flags. I do. I'm an old hand at certain games. I tend to witness the same shit that my adoptive brother did, and it scares me, too. I have observed

  • A short, hot temper
  • A sense of entitlement
  • Verbal disregard for my feelings, UNTIL it is completely obvious I'm upset, at which point I see
  • Backpedaling
  • Showering me with trivial gifts (this is a red flag from my abusive boyfriend: "Look how nice I am!")
  • Extremely defensive toward anything nearly brushing against criticism
  • An instant "buck" response to being told no--disproportionate pushback
  • A lack of focus on what is actually necessary to further his situation, seemingly favoring building new relationships with primarily women (perhaps his next stop?)
  • Guilt-tripping that I find completely inappropriate given the situation, as if I don't do enough
  • And, finally, perhaps worst of all, something I experienced with sadly a dear friend I let stay with me in a similar fashion, seeming to always, always "scrape together enough money" for anything I don't provide, which I find extraordinarily suspect
I really need some feedback on effective ways of communicating, because all of these traits hit me where it hurts the most, and my therapist and others who know my situation are all too aware that I am in the most vulnerable situation possible because I am desperate to have a big brother who does not abuse and use me for his own end.

Unfortunately, I'm starting to really panic about whether or not my T is right, and I'm screwing myself over as hard as I possibly could by embroiling myself in this situation.

It's a catch-22, though, because this behavior is insidious, and sometimes I think it's all in my head, because, well, I think plenty of people here can sympathize with being gas lit or feeling that they're seeing the world through abuse-colored lenses, and the very last thing I want to do is estrange someone who has the potential to be so healing for me, especially due to a lack of patience or an alarmist perspective.

But, as my T said, if I come into therapy and say, "Surprise! You were completely wrong! Everything is wonderful now!" she will be thrilled, but she doesn't think that's going to happen, and she really tried to hammer into my head that if she is right about how he ticks, there is nothing I can do to fix it, and trying will only get me into further trouble and further endanger my wellbeing. Most of all, she's worried that this will go south, and all I'll be able to focus on is what I could have done differently to fix everything.

And I hate to admit it, but apparently she knows me pretty well, because that would be a very Simon thing for me to do.

My best idea, which my T seemed to find reasonable, was to give him 40 more days to come up with rent money. It is a bit much for me to handle, it really is, but if I don't deal for at least one more month, I will always wonder what if.

Unfortunately, I don't even have the assertiveness skills in this particular relationship (in which I am so vulnerable and so badly want to please and to do the right thing) to go about telling him that his time will be up after that.

More urgently, he seems to believe that because I've been letting him use my car, he's entitled to use my car whenever he wants to. Like, whenever I'm not explicitly using it or when I'm at work. That seems extremely unfair to me, and I really can't afford to let him continue borrowing it in that manner, because I have a long commute to work, so this practice is burning up more than twice as much gas as I would normally need.

I don't even know how to tell him that much: dude, you can't always borrow my car. I can't afford this.

The guilt-trips are really strong, too, like he guilts me about not having transportation and a social group here. That is totally unfair, isn't it? To claim he gets cabin fever? Especially when he's only stuck for 20 hours or so maximum? I've stayed in that place for three days straight, not interacting with anyone, and been fine, and I didn't have any friends here when I moved here, and I certainly didn't fixate on that aspect of life. I focused on how I was going to make money, and if I wasn't focused on that, I was focused on assisting those who were helping me by letting me stay with them.

I realize this post is imposingly long, and it gives more information than it poses questions, but I could seriously use some sound community feedback on this matter, as I feel at a loss to communicate anything at all, and I can't seem to validate myself enough to empower that communication.
 
You mention a cultural difference -- what exactly is that difference? And what are the circumstances under which he has moved to live with you? I have some ideas about this situation, but could use clarification on these two points first.
 
@Simply Simon from the list of red flags I def agree that he wants to free load. You said he wants a job and Im going to quote Dr Phil here so forgive me, if you dont have a job then you should spend just as much time if not more looking for one then you would working in that job. Is he doing that?

Also, Id say that first, set some hard but strict boundries. No more car and if he needs a ride and if you are willing then he pays gas.

No more money being given as I suspect none is going to come back to you.

He pays anything in the house thats not already paid and if he needs the above listed to get a job or until he gets one then you set a time (say a month) and when that month is over, no more money, no more car, no more anything and if you are renting then your name comes off the lease and his on and if he doesnt agree then he can move.

I would also advise him only what you are comfortable advising for him to understand that his presence in your life, due to adopted brother, is risk your own mental health and that him coming into your life, if you are comfortable, will have to be gradual and slow and only as much as you are comfortable with.

I agree, he is using you and I had to go through that...house turned into a crack house...for me the learn how to set boundries and im still learning; but every boundry mistake is a learning experience on how to set them.

Bring out that "Simply dont play that" that i know is in you! ;)

You deserve peace and wellness both physically and mentally and you dont deserve to be used. Blood means nothing, that I learned with my own family. Its all about how they treat you, if he cant respect you, your mental needs, your boundries, and money then he doesnt need to be in your life!

:hug:
 
For what ever reason, I have a longish history of getting involved with people like your T thinks you bio brother is. I'm working on doing better. So, I can relate. I also have a weirdly dysfunctional family and can relate to the thought that it would be cool to have an actual family that liked me and functioned remotely like I hear families are supposed to. Some things just don't exist in this version of reality..

Having said that, my first thought is "Run for the hills!!!!!" :wideeyed:

What I've come to understand is that there are a fair number of people who make their way in the world by using others. The rest of us can't fix them. Just can't. No idea why. No longer care why either. If there's hope for them, they have to find their own way and the biggest favor you can do for them is not give them any additional reasons to think their current MO actually works.

You say the rent etc is paid to some specific date? Tell him he has until then to get on his feet. Anyone can get a job flipping burgers, can't they? If he gets a job, maybe you can help him make ends meet until he gets a better job, if need be, but he gets a job or he's out. The car? I don't know where you live, big enough to have a bus line? Don't let him use your car! What if he has a wreck? What if he gets a DUI and they CONFISCATE your car? What if he commits armed robbery while driving your car? (I'm guessing you're paying for gas?) What if he leaves town and takes your car with him?

The 2 of you are related by genetics. Nothing else. Sometimes it works that you can build a relationship later on. Sometimes it doesn't. I'm thinking he's probably not capable of HAVING the kind of healthy relationship you'd like to have and deserve to have. That's too bad, but it doesn't mean you owe him anything.

Let's brain storm ways for you to get out of this because I REALLY think that's what you need to do.

But, I wouldn't see this as dangerous as much as I see it as an opportunity to learn and improve skills in handling parasitic humans.

Sorry this is such a mess! I really wish things turned out to be what we'd like them to be more than they apparently do. :hug:
 
It seems like he was basically given carte blanche to take you for all you've got and give nothing in return from the get-go. I mean, if the deal was that he'd take your place for free and you'd provide everything for him, there's no stimulus to do anything on his own, and if he is a freeloader and user, he's just been given the all clear to walk all over you. He doesn't even have to manipulate you. I can hear and sense in what you've written that you were hoping for an actual, proper bond or relationship with this guy, and to be honest, I can feel the vulnerability emanating from you just by reading the thread. That's not to say I or anybody else would have done anything differently, or that you're wrong ... but I do think you've opened yourself up to horribleness here and you need to fix it. Even if he's not a bad guy, I think you're being way too nice. As for his behavior, loads of red flags. Sounds emotionally immature, irresponsible and maybe even vindictive. (How old is he?) Depending on his age, and what he's been through, it's hard to say if he's being intentionally manipulative or if he's just weak and used to having other people do things for him. I think your best bet is sitting him down and setting out some strict conditions for his continued stay -- make some demands of him instead of just letting him stay there for free. Tell him he has to do these things or he can't stay (what those things are - that's for you to decide, depending on the circumstances ... maybe helping you with errands, or showing you proof that he's looking for a job, or doing something productive and useful).
 
You shared you feel you have inadequate skills to confront him on all this... That is what really sticks out to me... You see the red flags.... you already know this is not going to work... so my suggestion would be, work with your T about what to say to him, how to say it, ect. It won't feel good or comfortable...so this is a beginning practice for you on this issue.... I think he is in your life to teach you something, but it's not what you were wanting or expecting, and my heart hurts for you for that part...
But think about this... if you are able to set your boundaries, firmly, and follow thru with a family member, imagine how empowering that will be in the rest of your life...!!! I have no problem with confrontation, so I know this is a very hard thing for you, plus being disappointed that it's not turning out as you wished... but we no longer have to sacrifice our self for what we think is love and acceptance.... sending hopeful energy your way, and hugs if you accept them.
 
I don't know the laws there, but I once had a person taking advantage of me like that, in Las Vegas. She ended up stealing my rental car I was in (due to a car accident) for 3 days before coming back. My x husband had helped me secure the rental with his credit card and he is much wiser than me with this stuff. When he found out she had it for 3 days, he reported it stolen. When she came back, I told her to take her stuff and go, so she called the police and because she had been living in my residence for 2 wks at this point, Nevada law required I give her 30 days notice to vacate my home. Even though she never paid any rent. Luckily, I was able to get her to leave anyway, but she made me pay her $300 to leave that day! After she left, I found all sorts of voodoo paraphernalia in the room she was staying. And there were some really strange smells. Anyway my point is that these sorts of people are best cut off COLD TURKEY...every second you give them is another second worth of devised plans and manipulation. Even if you are going to give him another 40 days (which for your sake, I don't think you should) I would put it in wtiting, like a sort of eviction notice. So you aren't stuck by other means when the time comes where you NEED him gone. :-( ♡♡♡
 
Anyway my point is that these sorts of people are best cut off COLD TURKEY...every second you give them is another second worth of devised plans and manipulation.
Strongly agree with this based on past experiences. And I know exactly where you are coming from on this. I have made this mistake SO many times. The nicer you are, the longer you give, the more damage they have time to do.

I am wondering if there is something you can present to him to show his goodwill (something difficult, not easy) and state in your mind that this is a 'drop dead' deal. If he doesn't do it then he leaves. Just thinking out loud.
 
It won't feel good or comfortable..
Actually, the first time I realized that the person I was dealing with was a liar and a manipulator who cruised through life by using people, she was telling me a story to explain why she couldn't pay me. The story was outlandish. It involved getting stopped for speeding, hauled to jail with her severely disabled little boy in the car. It was all a misunderstanding. They were really looking for her husband but he didn't really STEAL that car, he just took it for a test drive and didn't bring it back.... It dawned on me that this was tripping a little too easily off her tongue. Like, a NORMAL person would have at least been embarrassed! I lost my temper. Informed her in no uncertain terms that I WORKED for a living, and I couldn't go the the electric company with a sad story. I went on a bit. :bag: I also got PAID. And realizing that I didn't HAVE to be a patsy for any narcissist that came down the road was great. Giving in to him isn't helping him, it's enabling him. Standing up to him and making him deal with his own stuff is closer to help.
every second you give them is another second worth of devised plans and manipulation.
I hadn't thought it it that way but YES!
 
@lostforgottensoul Apparently Simon do play when Simon is confronted with a brother figure who she desperately, desperately wants to have in her life as a source of health and comfort.

According to him, he doesn't have any money. Yet he's probably said three or four times that he scraped together change... I've let this pass several times, so it's difficult for me to suddenly be like, "Where the f*ck is this magic change coming from?" But that's weighing on me heavily. Supposedly flat broke... yet magic change. I've seen this behavior before. It disturbs me greatly. The situation with my roommate I was supporting came to such an extremely angry head that I literally took his mattress away (that I'd given him) and left a 7-page letter in its place detailing all of the many cases of disrespect that had been seething in me for the months I'd been helping him. Really unfortunate end to that relationship. I was pretty pissed off when I finally found all the money he'd been hiding. Yet I seem to be at a loss to address what looks like very similar behavior now.

@Sandstone Pragmatically speaking, nothing, really. I mean, he's given me some clothes that don't fit him that are really nice. He fixed the fog lights on my car, which I'd never even noticed or paid any mind to. Emotionally, though... well, the thing is, he found me. He searched me out, and he contacted my parents, which enabled him to reach me, and he found me, when otherwise I probably would have never known anything at all about my biological family. It was a big deal to me to suddenly inherit three brothers. Most of all him. He is so much like me in some ways.

@Casey_03 I grew up in an upper middle class Jewish family in NJ. He grew up in trailer parks in the middle of nowhere in America's South, deep in the more rural nether regions of the Bible Belt.

He says he wants to change his life (he's clean from drugs and doesn't sell them anymore) and that he needed to get out of his hometown (which is fair; it's tiny and rural as f*ck and not a good environment for anybody).
 
Yesterday my therapist seemed to come to the verge of tears when talking to me.

She is terrified fo...
Simon, I don't know if anyone else has mentioned this yet, but the thought just occurred to me that possibly he was the cause of his girlfriends ptsd symptoms. Perhaps she realized this when she witnessed you receiving the same treatment she has recieved from him...perhaps that motivated her to sever the relationship and run. He sounds like an abuser who is capable of doing real damage like ptsd
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom