• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Would You Have Fired This Therapist?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Soli

New Here
Hi everybody,

I'm new here. So thank you for your generosity in reading this.

I've had a brutal couple of weeks. I've been very sick (physically ill and in a lot of physical pain) with a new, debilitating illness. The children's home where I've been volunteering for over a decade shut its doors. One of my best friends lost her father, unexpectedly, and I've been literally dragging myself to be with her. For the past few weeks, I've been unable to drive to my therapy appointment, an 80-minute drive each way, because I am sick. For me, getting bad health news is a bad trigger (I'm a survivor of several bad medical mistakes that have left me disabled). It doesn't matter what the bad health news is, it makes me feel suicidal. Because I was having suicidal thoughts and generally struggling, my counselor offered to call me to check in once or twice a week until I was well enough to travel again.

He made the first call, and then missed the next two. This brought up flashbacks for me of very bad situations from childhood in which I was forgotten and neglected. It added a lot of pain to what was already a painful situation. I confronted him after the second call, sent an email that said, "did you forget?" And he replied that he did forget, and he apologized.

I was ready to talk this through and try to deal with it with him, but he got defensive and said he was doing the best he could and that I essentially lacked appreciation for his good intentions. My point: if the actions don't match up with the intentions, they not only don't honor the intentions, but they hurt people. I was hurt. He didn't get why it was such a big deal that he forgot to call when I was very ill and in crisis. There was one other time during the time that I saw him that I had a little bit of anger about something he did, and he threatened to abandon (terminate) me, and I had to apologize profusely to keep the relationship going. I'm ashamed to admit that but at the time I was really vulnerable and scared to be without a counselor. This time around, I felt that he should have been reaching out to me and trying to help me work through what came up. He wasn't interested in that, so I fired him. I'm really upset about it because I've been going to this guy for eight months, trying to work on things that are deep and unspoken. He does great work except when he screws up, at which point he gets defensive and I just couldn't take his defensiveness on top of my emotional pain. I feel sad a about losing the good aspects of our relationship. But he obviously couldn't deal well with me getting triggered, and I can't help getting triggered. I just wanted for him to fully hear my pain and despair. But I could tell he was angry with me for being upset with him.

Was I wrong to have such a strong reaction to being forgotten while I was in crisis? What would you all have done? Would you fire a therapist who forgets to call you when you're in crisis? I've been crying and second-guessing myself all day.

Thanks for listening.
 
He offered to call you. As a professional, once he did that he had an obligation to do so. He could have agreed on which days to call you and put them in his schedule. If you can't count on someone in your time of crisis, especially when they made the overtures to help, then that person is a hindrance. The fact that he became defensive is bothersome. He offered. He screwed up. He needs to own that totally. Consistency is something that all therapists need to have.

You are the only one who can truly determine if you over reacted. However any therapist that says to his client that the client doesn't appreciate his good intentions, in other words, empty promises are okay, is in the wrong field.

While it is a set back, move on. He has already eroded your trust. The saying you have to kiss a lot of toads before you find your prince applies to therapists. I can appreciate how hard it is to find someone new that you can trust, and repeat everything over yet again. Take the good you have gained from working with him, don't dwell solely on this incident, and forge ahead.
 
Hi @Soli, and welcome to the forum. I tend to agree with @nursenurse, once someone, I'd say especially a therapist, broaches your trust and leaves you feeling those old, terrible feelings of abandonment, and then fails to own their mistake, apologize, and prove their good intentions, that sacred trust relationship has been damaged. And especially within a therapeutic client/therapist relationship, I would think it would be very difficult to continue on with the same level of trust and openness that was there before. Which of course would be pretty detrimental to making forward progress.

I'm really sorry you are dealing with this on top of the other stressors you've got going on. I would definitely be extremely hurt if my therapist "forgot" after she'd promised to call me (or email, text, whatever the case may be). I too, have a history of childhood neglect and struggle greatly with feelings/fears of abandonment.....and my therapist is well aware of this and would know that her having forgotten me like that would trigger these old feelings and fears.....and your therapist should have known that too. Perhaps he has, or will, realize the magnitude of his mistake, but the damage to the relationship has been done. Is he a young or rather inexperienced therapist? It just strikes me as immature or unprofessional of him to have become defensive like that instead of validating your feelings and emotions and apologizing emensely for having caused you pain.

It is always hard, and never easy to lose or change therapists, or even to find a new one after having been out of therapy for awhile. But it is possible to find someone who you'll "click" with and be able to work well with. I know when I returned to early after several years, I was very apprehensive about it because the last time I had to change therapists I had some really bad luck with the ones I was referred to and tried.....so much so that it was why I turned my back on therapy for so long. Please, don't let this happen to you! I was extremely fortunate to have finally found my current therapist....we clicked right away and work extremely well together. Se is actually the first trauma specialist I have ever seen, and the difference is amazing!

So please don't give up on therapy and healing because of this. Seek out a trauma specialist that is close enough to you that you'll be able to get to them....either now, or once you are feeling a little better physically. If you haven't already, try typing, "trauma therapists in (your current city)," into Google search (or whatever search engine you use.That should at least give you a starting place.

Good luck, and keep posting here as much as you want/need, you'll find lots of support and understanding here. :)
 
100% agree that this therapist needed fired!!! They are NEVER supposed to tell you their feelings, or get defensive, or threaten to 'fire' you. Absolutely, and TOTALLY WRONG!!!

Good for you, and hopefully your next therapist has TRUE compassion and empathy!!!
 
Thank you all so much. It makes me feel better to know others would have done the same thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom