First, I have to say that my reaction, every time I see you've posted something, is just like radicalgratitude. "Oh good, it's Abstract!" (I feel that way about a bunch of you, BTW.)
I get the "parts" way of putting things. Partly because that's the way it
seems to me, a lot of the time, partly because my T talks like that a lot and I'm used to hearing it. But, what he ALWAYS says is, "Everything you brain is doing was, or is, "adaptive" in some way. It just might not be based on up to date, accurate information and you might not see the point. (yet)."
I've experienced a pretty relentless inner critic. My T suggested starting a conversation with it, to try to find out what it was basing it's opinions on. I thought he was nuts (I think that a lot!) but I tried it. Nothing happened for several weeks, then one night I had a weird dream that gave me a totally unexpected insight. Where all that hate was coming from turned out to be WAY different than what I thought. That "voice" is still around, but much quieter and all I have to do is stop and consider it's source and it backs off.
If you had a therapist that tried to make you confront traumatic memories where you weren't even able to talk, I think they made a HUGE mistake. (JMO?) To quote my T again, "I want you to do this as fast as you can, BUT NOT FASTER."
What kind of therapy? I'm sure this is very different for different people. I know, for example, that Solara experiences this WAY different than I do. For me, it's all about the person. I got really lucky. He's good at his job, but I LIKE him. As a result, there's the potential for me to also trust him. For me, it's all about trust. People have to EARN that and it's not easy. I couldn't care less how he chooses to approach this. What ever works for him is fine, because I think many roads lead to the same end. What matters to me is that I can trust him. (And I do, to a point. LOL)
I guess I don't understand why you make such a strong argument for a cure if you aren't willing to seek it out for yourself. It's perplexing to say the least.
You know, on kind of a gut level, I can see how someone might feel that way and for several reasons. I'm not sure I can put it into words and then it may be different for different people.
If you take the chance, you risk "failure". If you "fail", what then? Except that we have the ability to frame our own definitions of "success" and "failure". I would suggest not to worry about "succeeding" or "failing". Look at it as learning.