Anni,
I"m so sorry you have a headache!!
I can't disagree with you EITHER. LOL!
They don't have to check off on everything on the list to be considered disorders. The BASIC rule with regards to these people that ALL of the display is LACK. OF. EMPATHY. and CONTEMPT. What you described above as the creepers they are, are the dangerous ones. This is why you REACT to them...they give you the creeps. If you're healthy enough, you can SEE it. For example, my last ex psychopath was as CALM as a cucumber! NEVER reacted to anything. He CREEPED out my friends, and my kids (who hated this man), because of his low reactive appearance. He appeared as FAKE. VERY difficult to explain, but the normal reaction to this, this feeling of FEAR or being creeped out, was non existent to me. I was SO into my 'fantasy' of him, and what he represented to me, I mistook calm and cool, as emotional and spiritual maturity. He was one of the MOST dangerous individuals I've ever met, the most abusive, and he never laid a finger on me, Anni! These psychopaths are the most frightening because they've learned how to mimic human behavior, and they learn to assess potential victims, almost lazer like in their luring of them into the psychopath's web. They are major boundary violators, master manipulators. They LIE with ease. They can rewrite history at the drop of a hat. For example, you said something to him yesterday and it led to an 'argument', two hours later, you wish to bring the issue to a close so that things are emotionally balanced again between the two of you...and he pretends that the whole thing NEVER HAPPENED.
When this happens to you, it is CRAZY Making and it happens on a regular basis, sometimes I was so taken back when my ex did this i really DID believe I was nuts. It's also not true that these people are *just* mass murderers. They are corporate CEO's, politicians, the guy next door. My last ex had the same job (which he was fired and then through a hearing rehired because of his relationship with ME, I was a client) for 25 years, lived in the same neighborhood in a beautiful home (very creepy, it was beautiful on the outside but the inside reflected his disorder), for 17 years. He's a worship leader in his CHURCH. A licensed Pastor. There are people who know. He didn't just drop out of the sky as a psychopath. He avoids them all because he's built a new persona for the new victim he married last year. If he didn't look the same, in the face, I wouldn't recognize the man I thought I knew at all, because they have no inner core, and they take on the personalities of others they are with, and borrow some along the way for the purposes of manipulation. It IS very scary.
The first one, was violent, alcoholic, drug addicted. Beat the shit out of me. Molested my son. IS he truly a psychopath or is he just an *arsehole* as Anthony put so well....
No, he's a psychopath. This could become confusing. My ex husband is on the anti social scale. He is of the violent variety. His narcissism is low, his psychopathy is high. He has been in trouble with the law since he was very young. He started drinking from his parents alcohol cabinet at NINE years of age. No kidding! He has stolen money from places he worked, he has been to jail for domestic violence numerous times (ruined one christmas because of it), and the last time this happened, he had to go through treatment and anger management (for alcohol and an abuser program). He stayed sober for five years, clean too. The defining factor in whether or not he was a psychopath was one who wanted to diagnose but was AFRAID too (this happens a lot to survivors, as these people are extremely manipulative, it's NEVER advised to attend therapy WITH them), so he never got a dx, but during those five years, NOTHING changed, except that he was sober.
These people have what Sandra Brown, M.A. refers to as, The Three Inabilities: The inability for insight, the inability to sustain personal growth and the inability to SUSTAIN POSITIVE CHANGE. They can be extremely intelligent (BOTH my ex's had very high IQ's), but can be incredibly emotionally inept. It's like having a 'relationship' with a very bright six year old.
To a survivor who has suffered the effects of one of those creepy people you have run across, are devastating in every way. Labels matter to her when it comes to descriptive terms and subsequent content that outlines the behaviors for her. Too many times, when I've described it as she speaks about it, lightbulbs start going off in her head. I have seen survivors literally break down with RELIEF at knowing what they've been involved with...and there is no way I would tell her that just because he'll never be diagnosed, doesn't mean that's not exactly who he is.
As long as these people fly under the radar, they can do substantial damage. They cause enormous amounts of pain and society enormous amounts of money. Once you know who they are (and you seem to give a GREAT example of that), they are not hard to see. Even those that are the most charming (and MANY of them are), do things that scream lack of empathy. They advocate for the destruction of others, they know they are hurting people but they don't CARE.
I think it's hard to accept because those of us with empathy and compassion would have a hard time imagining one who doesn't. At all. It takes a long time to accept.
To address your last paragraph, Anni, you are right. I wrote an article about this on my blog too and I have to remind survivors that not EVERYONE is a spath. These behaviors are a consistent pattern over time. Years and years and they have relationship histories that reveal this. They leave an enormous amount of damage behind. It's most unfortunate because new victims are so caught up in the fantasy that the psychopath weaves for them, they won't talk with ex's about his behavior, even when they've been told about it, or a friend or family member tips them off that something is VERY WRONG with this person. The bonding they create with the victim is so strong because of the depth of deception and mirroring the psychopath does, she is not going to believe anyone. This is very sad. Oops, getting off track.
Anyway, I wrote a post about this very issue. Survivors go through a period in their recovery where they become very hyper vigilant and harm avoidant. They are VERY paranoid. The level of betrayal they've experienced is so deep, that it's very difficult for them to trust again, but I put the brakes on them when they begin to point fingers and accuse others of being 'spaths'. I have had COUNTLESS survivors cut me off IMMEDIATELY due to this behavior. It is VERY frustrating because you cannot encourage their healing in moving forward when ANYTHING ANYONE says to them that is in DISAGREEMENT, means they boot you out of their lives and then run around telling people that you're a spath.
I have seen survivors never leave this state and being around them is like walking on eggshells. Trust cannot be built with survivors in this state. FURTHER, what really angers me beyond belief is that survivor support is relatively new. There are not a lot of therapists that deal with the disorders or the fallout. The therapists that do are like finding gold in shit. Many survivors cannot afford a therapist either, and mental health in this country is inadequately under funded and uncared for. So guess where that leaves the survivorss? WITH THE SUPPORTERS. Oftentimes we are the ONLY support in real time they have. There are books, videos, etc, but most survivors do not have the means or cannot find an adequate therapist. This field is FULL of disordered exploiters. They KNOW that there are victims aplenty. Psychopathy and narcissism run on a spectrum. It doesn't matter if they only have a 'little bit' of disorder, it's still enough to destroy a person's life. There is disorder, ironically, all over the support community. THESE are the people I wish I could reach, but because of their varying degrees of narcissism, they cut me off (which is what disorders do!) when I call them out on their very exploitative behavior and clear lack of empathy. They take the disorders and create HYSTERIA for survivors, keeping them in the SPINS about not only their ex's but the world in general. UGH! I have reported them, called them out personally and yesterday a fellow survivor had to contact his attorney because his copy write work was being stolen by who? YEP you guessed it, a disordered female supporter, who has grown her 'business' exploiting survivors and makes 150,000 a year off their pain. We are in process of doing something about it right now, but I am a HUGE advocate in encouraging survivors NOT to listen to that garbage. Once they know what the disorders are, and what their partners were, their job is then to heal themselves. As little time as possible should be spent ruminating about him or his disorder. The abusers are responsible for their behavior and their abuse, a survivor IS NOT at fault at all for what he has done, however, I find myself in hot water with some survivors who prefer the disordered supporters because they WANT to continue to spin about the abuser and blame and blame him, without looking at themselves, without doing the deep work of purging some pretty ugly stuff. I would say about 80% of the survivors I have worked with, have a family background of pathology or abuse to some degree.
Ironically, I can validate you about just tossing the disordered label out there, because it has been applied to me by survivors who suggest that they would do better moving forward, from him to themselves. It does get tiring after awhile, when the refuse to budge from blaming him and his disorder, rather than figuring out why they were victimized in the first place. I don't coddle survivors and am very straightforward. I know that they are highly emotionally dependent and most of them are not aware of it, which makes them vulnerable to exploitative supporters. I do not encourage dependence, I encourage their independence. In doing this work, MAYBE 25% of survivors will make it through the process. That's a sad number, but it is indicative of the destruction the disordered are capable of. Some survivors never recover.
Thanks for your post. It was very thought provoking. :)