Figuring out what’s needed at the time the urge arises is something I struggle with.
The urge probably has something to do with occasionally needing a respite from the pain you carry around all the time. Often it might come because one too many stressors have piled up and you need some relief.
I think usong analogies is helpful, but the ones being used here I think are feeding the habit, rather than helping you find less destructive ways to manage your pain while you work through things.
When we engage in these behaviours, we aren’t
releasing anything. We’re
distracting our brain from it temporarily (big difference). And that brings relief. Spending time just not being so conscious of all the chronic pain? Is a huge relief.
But you’re not actually letting your pain out by these behaviours. You’re temporarily covering them up with something more distracting in that moment. A whole lot of sudden pain is a big distraction!
Understanding it that way may help with beginning to change the way you approach this as a management tool. Pain is an effective way to distract your brain. It really is. That’s why it works.
But pain is not the only way to distract your brain. The trick is finding other methods of distracting that work for you, and trying them out with the same conviction that you currently give to your present management method. Then honestly assessing afterwards - did that distract me while I was doing it?
The thing that really motivated me to finally address my addiction to SH, and invest in healthier coping strategies was an entirely different issue. When we physically harm ourselves to provide relief, we often tell ourselves that we’re actually doing a kindness to ourselves.
Unfortunately, the brain doesn’t interpret it that way. That’s plain old cognitive distortions justifying dysfunctional behaviour (which is what cognitive distortions are brilliant at). Our brain actually recognises “I’m physically assaulting myself right now”. Underneath the cognitive distortions that make us feel better in the moment, our brain is actually seeing it for what it is.
The end result for that for me (and I suspect for many others)? Was that SH as a coping mechanism, each and every time I did that, I was reinforcing core beliefs about my worth as a human being. I wouldn’t assault someone that had a lot of worth. So doing it to myself was reinforcing the core belief about my self worth that I was trying so hard to shift in therapy. My SH coping strategy was reminding me (unintentionally) “I really am worth abusing - I’m even happy to do that to myself”.
Behaviours reinforce beliefs. For me? That was my reason to change the way I coped with pain in those desperate moments. I simply couldn’t afford to keep reinforcing that belief, because as long as I did? My pain wasn’t going to get any better.
That was my experience with it anyways!