• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Is Dissociative Identity Disorder caused by anything other than childhood trauma?

Status
Not open for further replies.
What kind of dysfunction it causes, for the person or their life in any way - or that of others, is a different thing from attitude though.

I can view us being 'us' an asset all days long and it still doesn't change it's a problem if no one of us can answer how old the body is, after checking our IDs four times.

Not even starting on the more problematic / getting in not-prepared for nor necessary, danger, just because, oh, the five year old knows how to get a ride and be sweet to people but not that when in doubt, you talk to trusted friends.
 
I think what we often forget is the dms is not only cultural but also societal times book rather than scientific and it is one reason I am not too attached to it. There were times they had official diagnosis for the runaway slaves???? In the same book.... Even being gay was a diagnosis? You gotta wonder? What is our blind spot today?

Yes! And @Lumos - this is what I meant by agenda. The diagnoses and their criteria are very much culturally based. They show the bias of the people who developed them
 
Research says DID can only be "created" during childhood. It can lay dormant and after traumas in adulthood can become more apparent.

Also, other dissociative disorders and complex trauma disorders can be created in adolescence and adulthood.

Domestic violence can cause c-ptsd, a disorder in which dissociation is very prominent. A disorder doesn't necessarily need to be DID to be valid.

Other dissociative disorders can be caused in childhood or adolescence and present later or present all throughout an individual's life.

Sending love to all ?
 
Personally, I'm an adult 35 y/o male that now has DID with no childhood trauma. Nor is it rooted nor or any of these personalities seemingly "me". I'm a very strong willed and sane person with no ego.

*Please keep an open mind with my experience* :

Absurd as it may sound, spirituality plays a large factor in this (at least for me). I've recently been forced into paganism in order to alleviate my symptoms of 7 other people which was sparked during spiritual harassment from another person who seemingly may have DID themselves perhaps? Crystal work and meditations keep them at bay temporarily for me. No prescription drugs help. Figured I'd add my experience to the discussion albiet out there or not as it actually answers the possibility of it being done to anyone at any given time or age.

Research says DID can only be "created" during childhood. It can lay dormant and after traumas in adulthood can become more apparent.

Also, other dissociative disorders and complex trauma disorders can be created in adolescence and adulthood.

Domestic violence can cause c-ptsd, a disorder in which dissociation is very prominent. A disorder doesn't necessarily need to be DID to be valid.

Other dissociative disorders can be caused in childhood or adolescence and present later or present all throughout an individual's life.

Sending love to all ?

And I think the largest reason why the assumption of it always being stemmed from childhood is because there's always a "child" voice(s) in every case. In mine, the child is there in hopes to make you act like a child to purposely lower your spiritual vibration. Make you feel giddy and naive so a decietful one can do manipulative spirit work to stay in you to vamp your energy. Keep in mind, children are full of light and energy, makes them larger spiritual targets. Just informing is all. :)

Hope everyone is safe during all of this world craziness lately. <3 :)
 
Research says DID can only be "created" during childhood. It can lay dormant and after traumas in adulthood can become more apparent.

Very true. This is what research says. But we have only scratched the surface of the brain's functioning and how the mind works. There are so many possibilities we have yet to discover.
 
My understanding is that it’s due to the incrediably plastic nature of a child’s brain.

An adult brain? Even just bruising it can cause serious and lasting harm. But a baby’s brain? You can take out HALF of it, literally cut half out, to no effect whatsoever. They grow into completely functional, bright/intelligent, normal healthy adults. With very little lag (about a year, less lag than even being bilingual causes... which is about 2 years). From the moment we’re born? Our brain cells start dying. We have zillions more brain cells, and potential pathways, as young children than we do as adult. (And by adult? Think puberty.) Which is what creates that incredible plasticity / ability to change & adapt. Another, less severe, example of that? One of the more fun studies out there asks children what can be made with a paper clip? The average high school senior can come up with about 8 things. The average kindergartner? Over 500. Why the disparity? A 5yo isn’t constrained by what “should” be. On any level. They blow up paper clips to being 10 miles wide, and orbiting the planet, to dock space ships at. They make paper clips edible, or the human body able to digest “paper clip metal”, and feed the world with them. And 498 other things.

Children’s brains? Are amaaaaaaaaazing :inlove:

Their physiology is at its absolute most vital, and their thoughts are completely unrestrained. Reality and imagination operate out of the same space. So both the physical brain itself, as well as the mind, are in this unique state that you’ll never find again in life. Even the most creatively brilliant adults, who hang onto child-like thought processes? (And that shows, when you stick them in an imaging machine, not just on paper). When researchers stick those genius level artists, scientists, business, leaders, Nobel prize type peeps, etc. next to a boringly average even mediocre 4yo? The 4yo outperforms them. Not at a skill level, or a language level, but at a neurological level. Because those brilliant child-like adults? Light up brain scans like XMas. Easily 10x brighter/more colorful than the average adult, when asked to think about -or do- the exact same thing. But the 4yo? Their brain lights up like the sun.

Something else wicked cool about children’s brains? Each and every single personality disorder out there, is a part of normal childhood development. Which is why they cannot be diagnosed in childhood. (They have to be “enduring and persistent”. Existing not only throughout childhood but also significantly into adulthood.) In point of fact, not passing through those stages is highly indicative of a problem (either a neurodevelopmental disorder being present blocking normal development or atypifying it, or one of those personality disorders locking in/attempting to lock in). Children’s brains just DO that... reach for extremes impossible for adult brains to reach at all, and then recede back like a wave on a beach, to find a balanced normal. And then they do it again. And again. And again. To create a personality disorder? Something has to essentially “stop the tide”. Literally preventing the brain from recalling itself from the extreme it reached, AND preventing further development in other areas. It takes a perfect storm of events to achieve that, and it’s simply not possible -many many many people have tried- to accomplish in adults. Adults go mad. In a few different, yet highly predictable ways. (I’m not joking about people attempting to break other people, in too many different ways to count. Very predictible results follow.) It takes a child’s brain to be able to ADAPT in such a way, to not only function in that extreme, but to thrive, and completely build a person/personality in those conditions.

So my understanding is that’s why children’s brains can create wholly different personalities under certain circumstance. Becoming exactly who they need to be, in that situation. 1 beating heart, 2 souls. Or more. Adults can -and often do- shatter into fragments of themselves (one of those very predicitble results)... but some kids, when the pressure is too much for any 1 person to bear? Instead of shattering like adults? Think to themselves, well... then I need 2 people. Let’s do that. And they do. Because kids? Are f*cking amazing.
 
Last edited:
@Siku

Welcome and thank you for the well wishes, also hoping you and yours are and remain safe and well.

I hear you are having hardships, and grok that's a hard and unpleasant spot to be in...

But it's not DID.
Other personality alterations, different causes, just are not DID, even if there is a more than one acting personality.

These criteria are forms the way they are for a reason, and profound alterations in consciousness just isn't the only criterion to dx DID also for a reason.

Aka yes, cults create profound changes, on every level, no disputing that.
But it ain't DID unless in childhood.

I'm willing to give pass to those literally brainwashed adults, torture survivors, political prisoners, and the like populations. Because the trauma came through is that grade of evil prickery. Some very isolated cults, as seclusion & all else equals brainwashing effects, neuro wise.

But not every (open society & just bad spirituality or what have you alternatives) people, as even considering that DID.

Both because it levels out - DID itself doesn't, no matter what you throw at it, the same way - and because just not that type of literally maddening trauma that makes splits happen... even where still trauma.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom