Thinkingman, I understand. I am sure there is a lot to the verbal abuse from your older brother. He is a drug addict-he is sick. Addicts are sick people and there are many other ways to be emotionally sick that hurts those they may otherwise appreciate, love, and encourage.
I had 4 older sisters, the oldest died when I was 15. The other three are all different that each other ( 1 passive aggressive recovering alcoholic, 1 drama queen and pot stirrer and awful-izer, 1 so emotionally injured and lacks memory-suffers many somatic illnesses-very angry), but what they all have in common is one thing, assuring that I am the scapegoat. None would help with our mothers funeral arrangements but were happy to criticize every detail and blame me, all have unrealistic expectations of me, all try to control my life and are bitter that they cant. So I also have no contact with them. I do keep in mind, they came from the same dysfunction that I did. There are 7-11 years difference and they have had a life of experience. The one 7 yrs older told me that she wished that I was dead from the time I was a toddler til age 8 and a regular if not daily basis. I am the Cinderalla (they are actually half sisters. I was treated poorly by them as well growing up.
When I was a teen, they criticized my failures (not being a good student, marrying an abusive man, being too thin, other physical attributes, my friends who were below their standards, etc.) Later in life, they have criticized my returning to college, getting my masters, living in an up scale neighborhood (snob), my social circle of educated, healthy and motivated professional friends, my kids success and confidence). They are sicker than I am, much sicker. When we were speaking, they have never supported or encouraged me in anything positive in my life. We were all emotionally neglected and abused, but they think I was less so than them and that they openly resentful. I understand internalizing all of this all too well. I think that during my darkest time in the past few years, I too hear my sisters voice "I wish you were dead" or "I wish you were never born" but it has changed to " I wish I were dead and wish I was never born" and think that my sister was right. But then who would be their scapegoat.
We have cut of communication when I was in my thirties but re-united during death of a family member only to repeat the process. This time it is final for me.
Sounds like your brother is toxic and insecure to say the least. He came from the same environment as you as well. Im not exactly sure how your trauma arose from your brother's behavior toward you but do know that when we are treated this way within our family we often allow it in other parts of our lives as adults. You have the choice to live by choice or live by chance. It sounds like you have many good things going for you (intellegence, deeper thinking and ability to see full picture, talents such as music, many interests, etc) You do not need your brothers approval and will likely never get it. I am saying that from experience. I am 54 and wasted time trying. You have made the choice to ex communicate and now your focus is how to get him out of your head, and any other toxic people who are holding you down. Maybe you could snap your wrist with a rubberband everytime that you hear his voice criticizing you.
I am nobody exceptional, I am average intellegence, looks, personality, talents, etc. I discovered many years ago that I had to "leave the pack" to enjoy my life. During these rough times I am saddened that I do not have the family support that could be but is not. I have supported them through many crisis over the years. I have to remind myself that I am lovable and the lack of caring from them is not about me. I was just the one that sought counseling early in life, chose not to dramatize and awfulize, to not see things black and white, to be non judgemental. At the end of the day, it is only I that needs to approve of myself and my behavior. That being said, also during my own crisis, I am sure that their attitude toward me has been most injurous for me, but I have allowed it.
During a better time, I have learned who I am, what I value, and have lived with integrity. I want that back-so I need them to remain out of my life and any other toxic people.
Of course I dont know what lies beneath your anger, but it sounds like you fear success, hold on to self doubt that your brother has instilled or strongly contributed to, and have a need to be right. (poor memory but think you said you were neglected as child) -that can leave us feeling not good enough so when one person points that out regularly, it can create extreme fear that they are right. Some of that may be the ego talking. You have developed a need to defend yourself-I have experienced that with sibling and with others since trauma.
If you dont have a therapist, I would get one. Even if you can only see periodically, it may provide guidance for you to address through self help books, groups, and other resources. Your anger is natural, you have a choice about ruminating about beating him with a bat, or chosing to see the reality of who he is and how unimportant his opinion and words are. You are better than that, and the best proof is how we chose to live.
Best Wishes with this
Brat