Point Blank.,, do you want Guy #2 around your kids?
Forget about what your husband will think or how he will react. These are your kids, and they come first. If you don’t want an unstable alcoholic around your small kids, then it is your right to say so.
You are not divorced, you are not legally separated, and he does not have full custody. You have as much right to those kids as he does.
I’d be concerned about his stability and ability to take care of the kids. He’s acting erratically. Also, if the VA is saying that he’s out of their area of expertise for treatment, I’d strongly consider the fact that he has some other kind of mental health issue. Treating PTSD is kinda the VA’s thing, and it just seems odd that they would not be able to treat a case of it, even a severe one (even if the treatment is shit).
Honestly, I’d make it a priority to move into my own place and secure other childcare for the kids. You need to be the custodial parent right now. He is unstable, and is going to move another unstable guy into the house to exacerbate the situation.
I do have my own place—I bought a house. We haven’t filed anything as far as our marriage goes, but we’ve been to the court mandated parenting classes, have a parenting plan, and I am the custodial parent on that. It was his parenting time on the day in question, but we were going to trade a day. I didn’t explain that earlier, because it didn’t seem relevant
As for Guy #2, I do not want him around my kids, but he isolates so much that I think it’s a non-issue. He also wouldn’t literally be living in the house. My husband lives on acreage and has a detached garage that he wants to convert to an apartment space. He already converted half of the garage for Guy #1. I’m honestly not as concerned about Guy #2 being there as I am about Guy #1. Guy #2 is self-sufficient. Guy #1, can’t do anything for himself. My husband literally has to remind Guy #1 to shower.
From my husband’s point of view, these guys are just renters, and no different from any other renters one might have. If I were to try and fight him in court on this, I don’t really know what I could argue. I have no idea how much these guys see the kids or how they behave in general. I know Guy #2 has a bad reputation, but I would need something more than a reputation if I wanted to argue that my husband shouldn’t be renting to him and that doing so is putting the kids in danger. The same with my husband—he’s being erratic, but not violent. I could say he’s doing a bunch of weird stuff, but none of that necessary means he’s an unfit parent.
My bigger concern is the effect Guy #2 will have on my husband. I always felt like my husband’s symptoms get worse whenever he hangs out with other veterans, unfortunately. I told my husband this, and he says he would make Guy #2 leave if that happened, but I don’t know if my husband would realize it was happening. He also says he will make the guy leave if he doesn’t stay sober, which I 100% believe.
As for his treatment, the VA originally rated my husband at only 30% for PTSD, so I think they may have sent him to a counselor, but not someone who can prescribe medication. I’m not really sure who they sent him to, but they told him he needed medication. He showed me the message they sent, but never told me who he actually saw.