Friday
Sponsor
What I am getting at, is lets forget the diagnosis. She has been diagnosed by a doctor, can we not let that rest and offer practical support. As has already been stated it could be that this experience has triggered a reaction to a previous DSM 5 Criterion A anyway
So why don't I just nip on down to the infidelity forums where everyone and their dog has been diagnosed by their GP as having PTSD and tell them to come on down? Diagnosis no longer matters! :confused:
Except it really does. Really, really does. Treatment modalities & best practice widely differs between disorders and conditions. So much so that the best treatments for one, are often the worst idea on the planet for others... But less severely, it wastes years of a person's life to be treating the wrong disorder, even if they aren't damaged -often permanently- by the wrong modality and meds. How many people here in this forum have wasted years struggling in misdiagnosis? (A lot, there are polls). Worse, how many people have been mis-medicated, retraumatized, and have completely cocked up their lives (lost marriages, children, friends, jobs, homes) while laboring under misdiagnosis and wrong treatment?
Making sure that a new person has the bare bones and verifiable facts so they aren't suffering those same consequences and can make informed decisions about their lives is, at the baseline, the most sincere help I can offer. So many people are clueless as to either PTSD or psych in general, they don't even know to go look up the DSMV, much less what to expect (or why it's important) to rule out all those differentials in a tediously long, and usually frustrating diagnostic process.
There has been absolutely no judgement in my prior 2.5 posts, ((although I will freely judge her doctor to be an egotistical buffoon if he/she based their PTSD diagnosis with no CritA Stressor or differential. Ego for not sending her to a specialist who would know the first line item requirement & buffoon for not bothering to look up the requirements themselves if they weren't going to send them on. )) For all I know she killed her rapist after she was sodomized with a broom handle in the basement of a burning school during a hurricane in a war zone after being kidnapped from parents who were murdered in front of her! Oy vey. That's why I asked.
And still haven't been answered.
Its also why I didn't answer the questions that try to compare things like being tortured, raped, violently assaulted, picking up body parts, being sold to pedophiles, or any other CritA capital T Trauma ...with an uneventful few hours sleeping off a drunk in a holding cell. Because they're not comparable. This isn't some special club where all one has to do is be miserable, and there there sweetie. Lots of things make people miserable. Lots of things are worse than PTSD. It's not a pissing contest. This is a disorder. At least the last time I checked. And treating the wrong disorder serves no one well.
______________
ETA / cross-posting
In my past I have been raped by my own dad, which I reported last year, and raped in October 2012. these things have never bothered me before and I was fine until I went to the police station, now that just wont get off my head
Ah. Voila. CritA Stressor in past? // Yep. // That makes sense, then.
Last edited: